3 ms·
> How many thousands of miles of snow driving data does Tesla possess, compared to the #2 player? It depends. If they're not recording the right things, they h
by toast0 6y ago
> How many thousands of miles of snow driving data does Tesla possess, compared to the #2 player?
It depends. If they're not recording the right things, they have the same 0 bytes of data as everyone else.
There's a not insignificant chance that their sensor data is insufficient to perform the tasks, and the recorded data won't be usable for training a system with whatever sensor is needed; in which case, no advantage for logging customer movements for N years.
- judge2020 6y agoYep, Tesla is placing all their eggs into one basket with purely visual self-driving.
- jjoonathan 6y agoVisual-only also delivers less fuel for lawyers to armchair quarterback, and that advantage applies even in the limit of good AI.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoMan, those humans are so dumb thinking they can drive safely just by looking at the road /s
- toast0 6y agoLet me know when Tesla's cameras can put their arms up to shield their eyes from glare. Or move over a few inches to see around a big truck. Or react to a stopped big red fire truck with flashing lights. /s
- RivieraKid 6y agoWhy does Tesla bother with radar and ultrasonic sensors? Humans can drive without them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoI just find it strange that Tesla is criticized for relying on visual self-driving systems when most humans rely primarily on vision to navigate.
- RivieraKid 6y agoWell but Tesla cars don't have brains. Maybe the lack of lidars makes the task 100 times harder, i.e. de facto impossible. We don't know. This is a big risk for Tesla but they didn't have a choice. If lidars were as cheap as cameras, of course they would use them. On the other hand, Waymo et. al. are not risking anything by using lidars. If they turn out to be redundant, it should be easy to remove them cheaply.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoThis isn’t true: if you build a system for highly sophisticated inputs, simplifying the inputs can break all sorts of assumptions about the accuracy of the input data and other such invariants. If you start with a more primitive set of sensors and go as far as possible, adding more accurate sensors seems less risky.
- johnhartigun 6y agoMaybe in general, but I don't think you're right in the case of self-driving systems. Waymo says that perception is the easy part and most of the work is elsewhere. So in the absolute worst case scenario, they would have to develop the perception part from scratch. At Tesla, this took 2 years. BTW, all companies that can, use lidars. Even MobileEye says that their L4 system will use lidars and they've been working on a camera based system for 2 decades. Tesla doesn't use lidars because they can't.
- 6y ago