9 ms·
> Inflation and stagnant wages have led to a rise in two-income households I often see it phrased this way, but I always wonder how much of the effect is actua
by sokoloff 6y ago
> Inflation and stagnant wages have led to a rise in two-income households
I often see it phrased this way, but I always wonder how much of the effect is actually "A rise in two-income households has led to inflation and stagnant wages"?
Certainly, there's a positive feedback mechanism at play, but it always seems to be presented as "A causes B" rather than "A and B reinforce each other".
- downrightmike 6y agoWell, we often see the huge start of it in the 70's when the USA was able to get products out of China. Thanks to nixon, well paying middle class jobs evaporated, replaced with worse service jobs, or nothing at all. Then deregulation in the 80's allow Bain and the like to load up companies with debt and take that money as fees. Effectively destroying these American institutions. Sun Beam used to make things in the US. Toys R Us used to be a stable business. We can't have nice things because the basis for them has been wiped out. There is also the two income trap. So people over consume to fill a gap or cope with stress from having to work so much.
- zippy5 6y agoThe other side is that the peak of American prosperity occurred post WWII where a majority of the developed world (any country that had experienced an industrial revolution), was blown to shreds. This gave the US roughly a temporary monopoly on manufacturing and exports. It’s hard to see a future where the dominance of American prosperity happens again unless that scenario repeats itself. Aka WWIII with the US coming out unscathed and the rest of the world destroyed. No doubt your point of mismanagement and bad actors is valid but it’s important to recognize that much of the glory days of the American middle class corresponded to the height of many others misfortune.
- downrightmike 6y agoIt is possible, look at asia, they don't have land lines in many countries, they started around 3G, and now are pushing that further with 5G. The last economy to update will be the most advanced. So if the US can learn from China and Europe, it is possible that they could become a greater manufacturing power.
- akra 6y agoNote that this effect hasn't just occurred in America but other developed countries (e.g. London, Canada, Australia) all which had more secure work, local manufacturing, local union power/membership, etc and have experienced similar trends as the US. In our local newspaper there have been many articles about wage stagnation and the decline of our manufacturing base as well - albeit we may be a few years behind America which isn't much in the grand scheme of things.
- globular-toast 6y agoYeah. The two income households came first. Inflation doesn't happen for no reason. It happens because everyone gets more bits of paper so everything costs more bits of paper because there are only so many things. There's a huge tax advantage to living in a two income house. Two people earning 30k each will pay significantly less tax than one earning 60k. It's very difficult to raise a family with one income now and it's tragic. Women are wasting their lives do menial make-work instead of the one thing they all want to do sooner or later but should have done sooner. We're failing our women by making them work.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> There's a huge tax advantage to living in a two income house. Two people earning 30k each will pay significantly less tax than one earning 60k. This isn’t true. Up until the 2018 federal tax legislation, a married couple earning similar amounts was penalized compared to a married couple with one earner. And I don’t think the new law gave any advantages to married couples earning similar incomes, just removed some or most of the penalty. https://taxfoundation.org/understanding-marriage-penalty-and-marriage-bonus/ https://taxfoundation.org/understanding-marriage-penalty-and...
- globular-toast 6y agoIt's true in the UK. I don't know about US tax law (why would I?).
- cforrester 6y ago> We're failing our women by making them work. I think you should re-examine your opinion and address the misogyny inherent to the outdated and authoritarian concept that women shouldn't be doing important work unless it's related to child rearing. Women and men alike want to accomplish things in life beyond parenting.
- apta 6y agoNo reason that women can't accomplish important things, the problem is that feminism pushed the false narrative that men and women are equal across the board, this is obviously a fallacious and dangerous premise, and now society is paying the price. They also brainwashed people that any criticism of their toxic ideas is automatically labeled as "misogynistic", "patriarchal" and "authoritarian", etc. Add to that the notion of equality of outcome (instead of equality of opportunity), and we see what it leads to.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoWomen entering the workforce in larger degrees helped keep wages low because of the influx of unskilled labor. As they gained more skills and upper level positions, again it expanded the skilled labor pool and decreased wages. It's not women's fault collectively though. The funny thing is mass influx of labor like this are the very things unions have fought against. But unlike non-americans, unions couldn't be anti-women because they'd look bad, and they couldn't be anti-women in the workforce because it'd also be anti American since they're citizens.