3 ms·
Fred Brooks suggests in 1986 that future productivity improvements focus more on: >Exploiting the mass market to avoid constructing what can be bought In 202
by pydry 6y ago
Fred Brooks suggests in 1986 that future productivity improvements focus more on:
>Exploiting the mass market to avoid constructing
what can be bought
In 2020 danluu says that:
>In 1986, there would have been no comparable language, but more importantly, I wouldn't have been able to trivially find, download, and compile the appropriate libraries and would've had to write all of the parsing code by hand, turning a task that took a few minutes into a task that I'd be lucky to get done in an hour.
IME this demonstrates remarkable prescience by Brooks. The only real difference between Brooks' hypothetical future where software is assembled from bought components and the one danluu lives in is that the components are, in this case, free.
Package managers might seem obvious and necessary today, but I don't think they were at all obvious in 1986 (or even in 1996). Fuck, golang didn't even think they were necessary in 2009.
Also:
>Looking at the specifics with the benefit of hindsight, we can see that Brooks' 1986 claim that we've basically captured all the productivity gains
I don't believe that this was his claim. He claimed that productivity gains from improved programming language design would be incremental rather than game changing (hence: no silver bullet).
Some people probably will argue that there is a 10x difference in language productivity due to language but I don't think that is the case. In fact, I think there's a class of people who keep getting proved wrong and wrong again about the relative importance of package management ecosystems over "game changing" language features like non nullable types that are incrementally better, but not an order of magnitude better.
- ncmncm 6y agoI see that you are unaware of the large collection of programming language improvements accumulated in recent decades, which I will guess is because your favored language mostly does not implement them.