4 ms·
U.S. government has media restrictions at hospitals, to reduce pandemic images
- uberman 6y agoThe article describes as "onerous": "Before letting journalists inside Covid-19 wards, hospitals needed prior permission from not only the specific patients the journalists would interview, but also other patients whose names or identities would be accessible." I feel bad that HIPAA and our support for medical privacy is inconveniencing their crisis pornography.
- lsiebert 6y agoYou mean their documentation of the horrors of an absolutely real pandemic which many Americans have been falsely led to believe is a fraud? Even people literally dying of it don't believe in it. https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2020/11/16/south-dakota-nurse-coronavirus-deniers/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2020/11/16/south-dakot...
- uberman 6y agoYes that. Let's be clear here. If someone has covid and is dying in a hospital about to be ventilated and awake for the last time in their lives and they refuse to admit that maybe this is serous then watching some Intercept crisis porn would not have convinced them either. Some Americans refuse to admit that mass shootings at school actually happened and no amount of "evidence" will convince them otherwise. Having journalist hover over the grieving like vultures asking the dying to describe how they feel is gross. Filming them while they die is despicable. Journalists might have become accustom to covering health crisis porn in famine and war zones outside of the USA, but inside we have legal protections against being the subjects of this kind of exploitative journalism and we have protections against the dissemination of health information.
- lsiebert 6y agoActually I've seen stories about people being convinced by the nurses taking care of them. There's an example here if you scroll down. https://www.thecut.com/2020/11/nurses-are-dealing-with-patients-who-think-covid-is-a-hoax.html https://www.thecut.com/2020/11/nurses-are-dealing-with-patie... But I'd also argue that such denials are on a spectrum, from people who don't believe in the virus at all, to people who don't believe it's dangerous, to people who think it's only as bad as the flu, to people who don't take wearing masks or other precautions seriously, and even people who believe their youth and existing good health will protect them from harm. This has been exacerbated by both the president and allied media putting out false and misleading information. Countering those false narratives are exactly what good journalists do. The journalists, as always, have to have the consent of the patients they are talking to. That's always been the case. They aren't hovering over anyone without consent, and suggesting otherwise takes agency away from people bravely telling their stories, or who consented to have their last moments documented, or whose family consented to their body being shown. Showing the real effects of disease, violence and death are a powerful element of journalism. Consider Emmet Till's open casket funeral. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emmett_Till https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emmett_Till Consider George Floyd's last moments. The issue I see is that, because someone entirely different from the filmed individual has a chart at the nurses station, the government has created a regulation claiming you also need their consent despite that not being shown/viewed. That seems like an attempt to obfuscate the truth under the guise of medical privacy, despite no harm being done to anyone.
- just-juan-post 6y ago> The guidelines made it extremely difficult for hospitals to give photographers the opportunity to collect visual evidence of the pandemic’s severity. > Americans do not respond to statistics,” she wrote on Twitter in June. “They respond to stories. Every hospital needs to let cameras in and show what dying of Covid looks like. Instead, PR depts silence us.” Awww, so they weren't allowed to put out more panic porn. Boo. Hoo. The media could report the >99% survival rate but instead they pound on cases, deaths, and individual stories. Had the media had access to hospitals they would have driven the public into a frenzy with their reporting. Do you think papers would post rational stories or would they play it up as much as possible for eyeballs and money? What have they done in the past? Have they done since day one? I don't trust the government but they did the right thing here. The media would have done nothing but create hysteria in order to get more eyeballs and revenue. PS: Change it from Covid to cancer. Would you want yourself or a loved on to be the object of some reporter's story>
- manderley 6y agoCases and deaths are what's important? We're in a pandemic, the only way to beat that is getting people to change their behavior in order to stop the spread. Just because overall death rates aren't to your liking doesn't mean the media should report that everything is fine.
- evgen 6y agoChange the two words 'media restrictions' in the first clause to 'privacy protection for patients' and you have a statement that is both more accurate and shows how the second clause is more alarmist bullshit from the intercept.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- NE2z2T9qi 6y agoThis could be a great example of "Gell-Mann Amnesia" described by Michael Crichton. Anyone who works in American healthcare instantly knows the premise of this article is wholly absurd. Whether or not it's strictly the best policy, HIPAA is non-negotiable and has been so for decades. And, for infection control, most COVID units didn't even let family members in. Imagine how furious you'd be if a hospital told you a loved one couldn't visit but some non-medical rando who wanted to photograph everybody could. Michael Crichton's point with describing "Gell-Mann Amnesia" is that when you see a news article on a topic you're knowledgeable about, you quickly recognize that it's completely wrong in almost all key aspects. Sometimes they even get things precisely backward. But when you turn the page and start reading about something you're not an expert in--say foreign policy--you strangely forget how shoddy the journalism was just moments ago, and assume that this next article about something you’re not knowledgeable about is probably roughly accurate.