8 ms·
Israelis give shots to medical workers and oldest citizens first. This should drive down the death rate pretty fast. If this approach works, Covid-related death
by inglor_cz 6y ago
Israelis give shots to medical workers and oldest citizens first. This should drive down the death rate pretty fast. If this approach works, Covid-related deaths in Israel should visibly drop by the end of January.
- raverbashing 6y agoAll countries are doing these groups first, of course Israel is probably the country doing it the fastest so I agree, we should see the results faster. And I agree with the topic, better 2 people somewhat immune "now" than half with the full vaccine immunity.
- adriancr 6y ago> And I agree with the topic, better 2 people somewhat immune "now" than half with the full vaccine immunity. the 90%+ effectiveness is only with 2 does, who knows how long and if it works with only one dose... it's likely not half and/or not for very long...
- jacob019 6y agoImmunity is not binary. Introducing the spike protien to our immune systems now will prime us for a stronger fight later, even if we are not fully immune.
- zbjornson 6y agoModerna's phase 3 includes preliminary data on a single dose, and it appears 80-90% effective at/after two weeks. See table 15 on page 28: https://www.fda.gov/media/144434/download https://www.fda.gov/media/144434/download https://www.wbur.org/commonhealth/2020/12/18/coronavirus-vaccine-single-dose-debate https://www.wbur.org/commonhealth/2020/12/18/coronavirus-vac...
- mercurywells 6y agoFrom the same report: > The small, non-random sample and short median follow-up time limits the interpretation of these results. There appears to be some protection against COVID-19 disease following one dose; however, these data do not provide sufficient information about longer term protection beyond 28 days after a single dose. Obviously it'd be great if we can just dose everyone we can once then do a 2nd dose later, but we just don't know enough about how well that would work out long term.
- dvivsivd 6y agoThe CDC tried to have non-medical essential workers ahead in line of seniors. The argument was that, although more people would die (including more African Americans), it would even out black vs white ppl deaths metric. [edit] source: https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/acip/meetings/downloads/slides-2020-11/COVID-04-Dooling.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/acip/meetings/downloads/slides-...
- selljamhere 6y agoI don’t see any arguments in those slides about trying to “even out black vs white ppl deaths metric.” Social inequality is one of several factors included in their ethical and logistical plan, but interpreting that as an implied black vs white issue seems like a very uncharitable view of the author’s intent.
- danarmak 6y agoPage 31, table row "mitigate health inequities" says: An upside (green) of vaccinating essential workers (non-healthcare) first: "Racial and ethnic minority groups disproportionately represented in many essential industries. ~1/4 of essential workers live in low-income families." A downside (red) of vaccinating adults age >65 first: "Racial and ethnic minority groups under-represented among adults >65". The next page (32) concludes that "mitigating health inequities" (what the paper calls Ethics) is the metric with the biggest difference in outcome, in favor of non-essential workers. A bigger difference in outcome than the one for "maximize benefits and minimize harms" i.e. preventing the largest amount of deaths. Of course, the presentation doesn't define how these two different things are supposed to be compared. But its recommendation is that "Ethics" outweighs "Science" (their terms, not mine), and therefore populations with larger ethnic minority and low income representation should be vaccinated ahead of those at higher risk from the disease.
- zaroth 6y agoThis is one of the better critiques I’ve found of the CDC’s very absurd position: https://www.persuasion.community/p/why-im-losing-trust-in-the-institutions https://www.persuasion.community/p/why-im-losing-trust-in-th... Literally their plan was to kill a greater number of people “because ethics”. It goes against well established pillars of ethical logic against “leveling” outcomes by intentionally making things worse for a group that is better off, and against the most fundamental tenant of medicine to do no harm. You must apportion a limited supply of life saving medicine to the population most likely to benefit from it. To claim that apportioning the medicine to a population which is orders of magnitudes less likely to benefit from it, knowing that a greater number of people will die as a result, is an abject ethical failure. Even accounting for the smaller minority share of the elderly population, you still kill more minorities overall by apportioning the vaccine to essential workers ahead of the elderly, because the death rate is so heavily skewed based on age.
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoThere’s actually a lot of variety in the priority order. Other than healthcare workers the following groups will be prioritized above age 65+ in Massachusetts 1. First responders 2. Nursing home residents 3. Homeless 4. Incarcerated 5. 2+ comorbidities 6. Top priority essential workers 7. Teachers 8. One comorbidity (Check out your state here https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/health/covid-vaccine-states-distribution-doses/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/health/covid-va...)
- camjohnson26 6y ago40% of all deaths in the US have been nursing home residents.
- sp332 6y agoI've seen this number around for a long time, but since I never saw a source posted, I don't know if this is still true. Edit: I found https://covidtracking.com/analysis-updates/ltc-deaths-pass-100k-dec-2 https://covidtracking.com/analysis-updates/ltc-deaths-pass-1... for December 2, which shows about 100,000 deaths from "long-term care facilities". Not all states report differences between staff and residents dying, but I think it's reasonable to estimate it's mostly residents. On that day they show a total of 265,000 deaths in the USA, so about 37% from LTC.
- beat 6y agoMy mother got her first vaccination shot yesterday. She's in a nursing home in Virginia. She's already had one COVID exposure (luckily she didn't get it), and it's just scary there.
- helge9210 6y ago> This should drive down the death rate pretty fast. You can't drive the death rate that didn't rise in the first place. In Israel people are dying with COVID-19, not because of it. We are yet to see someone die from COVID-19 who is not terminally ill, fat and diabetic, immunosuppressed (after organ transplantation or cancer treatment) or very old.
- outside1234 6y agoPlease stop. Having underlying health conditions that make you less likely to survive COVID-19 does not mean that you were not killed by COVID-19. We wouldn’t say that someone with peanut allergies was killed by the allergy — and not the peanut — so please just stop with this propaganda.
- black6 6y agoThe propaganda is what's being peddled on traditional media. Had the media been responsible in their reporting of the SARS-CoV-2 virus and how it predominantly affects those with multiple underlying health conditions, instead of inciting panic over a re-branded seasonal flu (influenza is a corona-type virus... look at a picture of it), the pandemic might never have occurred. Imagine if the news gave us accurate and actionable information: "I am a native Brazilian studying in Norway. I better supplement with 200 mcg cholecalciferol." "I am a teacher who is 5'4" and weighs 190 lbs. I will look to lose 15% of my poundage in three months so that I am less at risk when me state Department of Education makes me return to the classroom of 25 children three months from now." "I gained weight from stress eating and being cooped up indoors from a lockdown. I'm concentrating on a protein-heavy calorie-restricted diet until my adipose tissue offers a smaller attack surface and fewer ACE2 receptors for the virus which is surely waiting for me the moment I walk outside the confines of my abode."
- literallyWTF 6y agoI’ve always wondered how it must feel to literally be irony; claiming something is propaganda while spewing unfettered nonsense.
- nerfhammer 6y agothey're also administering these shots out at a much faster rate relative to delivery whereas we've only administered less than 20% of the doses that have been delivered so far (11.4 million delivered, 2.1 million administered). The delivery rate should only increase especially even as there are several more vaccines in the pipeline so being able to actually administer the delivered doses may be the bottleneck moving forward.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoAren't we doing the same here in the US?
- pstrateman 6y agoMostly, each state decides what to do with vaccines though, so it's not as uniform.
- jamra 6y agoI just spoke with some people in Israel. None of whom are healthcare workers. They all got the first shot of the vaccine. ~4 people.
- edanm 6y agoWere they older citizens? Israel has opened up vaccinations for healthcare workers and anyone above the age of 60. There are a few other groups getting vaccinations as well - I don't know all of them, but I know of some people working in nursing homes or other similar jobs. In addition, there are people hanging around the vaccine administration centers at the end of their workday, and hoping that they have leftover vaccinations that would otherwise expire. Apparently, some people who otherwise wouldn't get vaccinated are able to get the vaccine that way.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- burtonator 6y agoSort of... there are still plenty of healthy people that only didn't die due to intubation. I'm curious to see the numbers there as well. If we vaccinate the old, then resume life as normal, we're going to overwhelm intubation machines.
- capitainenemo 6y agoI'd read medical studies and news articles over the summer that intubation was causing worse outcomes than things like proning in many cases, with dramatically improved survival rates in hospitals that avoided intubation. I'm wondering if advice on that has changed at this point. There was also an interesting piece on HN about jailbreaking CPAP machines to increase supply, although that might not be necessary now?
- hcknwscommenter 6y agoThe standard of care has evolved based on the data. Unlike other respiratory infections, intubation often provides no benefits and some harm to those COVID patients who are not literally dying of asphyxiation (critically low O2 saturation). Basically intubation is now a last-ditch effort, that can and does save lives. But you'd better hope you don't need it because the likelihood of needing intubation AND surviving it are low.
- iso1210 6y agoIsrael's deployment is amazing, they went from 0 to 8% of their population in 10 days. How many doses have they actually physically got?