3 ms·
The problem isn’t a train with a single car of LNG, it’s a derailment of a train carrying mostly LNG. Trains of Oil, LNG, or other flammable liquid can become
by Retric 6y ago
The problem isn’t a train with a single car of LNG, it’s a derailment of a train carrying mostly LNG. Trains of Oil, LNG, or other flammable liquid can become a major hazard in ways that a train full of say lumber isn’t.
Forty-two people were confirmed dead, with five more missing and presumed dead.[3] More than 30 buildings in the town's centre, roughly half of the downtown area, were destroyed,[2][4] and all but three of the thirty-nine remaining downtown buildings had to be demolished due to petroleum contamination of the townsite. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lac-Mégantic_rail_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lac-Mégantic_rail_disaster
- ars 6y agoExactly! And none of that would happen with LNG because natural gas is lighter than air, it would all rapidly rise into the sky and make a very pretty, and harmless, fire. And speaking of lumber: https://bangordailynews.com/2020/07/29/news/a-scene-from-hell-train-derails-on-arizona-bridge-that-collapses-catches-fire/ https://bangordailynews.com/2020/07/29/news/a-scene-from-hel... (I need a better link, but basically the cars with hazardous material did not leak, and the fire was from lumber.) Surprise surprise, Lumber is actually more dangerous than LNG! Because none of that would have happened with LNG. With LNG it all dissipates very fast.
- pietor 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viareggio_train_derailment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viareggio_train_derailment 32 dead because of derailment of LPG transporting train. Is the hazard posed by LPG much different to LNG?
- ars 6y agoYes. Propane is heavier than air, so it sits on the ground and just burns and burns. LNG rises up into the air and is gone.
- jjk166 6y agoPetroleum gas is heavier than air so it stays at ground level for an extended period of time, natural gas is lighter than air so it is dispersed quickly. The gasses in petroleum gas also have significantly lower ignition temperatures.
- jjk166 6y agoYeah, but we already have trains of flammable liquid, and most are far more dangerous than LNG. Had a LNG train been involved in Lac-Mégantic there would have been no flaming tsunami of oil nor any petroleum contamination.
- gruez 6y agoThat sounds more like an argument against allowing rail transport of petroleum rather than an argument for allowing rail transport of LNG.
- jjk166 6y agoIt very well could be if you don't feel the benefits outweigh the risks. But it's dumb to be fine with rail transport of petroleum and not LNG.
- Retric 6y agoLatent heat of vaporization means huge quantities of LNG stay liquid for plenty long enough to get a flaming tsunami. Your not going to end up with petroleum contamination, but in terms of loss of life their about equally dangerous. Anyway rail transport of oil through populated areas is also a major risk. Which is why it’s also banned in some places.
- jjk166 6y agoIf you had a tsunami of LNG it would be more likely to freeze you than burn you. However the latent heat of vaporization for LNG is very low, it will vaporize quickly as it spreads out, unlike crude oil. You certainly won't get a flaming tsunami - you can actually extinguish a flame in LNG. Transport of oil through populated areas is quite common. Local governments that have restricted its transport are welcome to do the same for LNG.
- Retric 6y agoLatent heat of vaporization of LNG is 512 kJ/kg vs 2257 kJ/kg for water. Which is basically irrelevant when your talking into the million’s of kg of the stuff. Do some math and even just a single 35,000 gallon tanker load is going to flow around like a liquid for quite some time.