5 ms·
Rule Allows Natural Gas Transport by Rail in Dense Areas
- pseudolus 6y agoDisasters involving the transportation of fuel are not merely hypothetical or historically remote. The 2013 Lac-Megantic rail disaster led to 47 deaths and destroyed a small town [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lac-M%C3%A9gantic_rail_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lac-M%C3%A9gantic_rail_disaste...
- jjk166 6y agoThat was a runaway train that wound up going 105 kph around a turn rated for 16 kph and derailed on the main street of a town. It wasn't even carrying natural gas, just crude oil. This change to regulations would have no impact on such an event happening again.
- Pfhreak 6y agoIf that train had been carrying corn, would the result have been the same amount of damage? What could have happened on the worst case if the train was carrying LNG?
- ars 6y agoNatural Gas is lighter than air, not much would have happened. The LNG would vaporize, rise into the air and there would be a short lived fire. If you read the damage description it's mostly due to petroleum contamination and fire. None of that would happen with LNG.
- mimikatz 6y agoThis is why I never understood the intense Dakota Access Pipeline protests. Pipelines are much safer and better for the environment than shipping by rail. Shutting down the pipeline won't make the drilling stop, it will just make things worse for the environment and raise the cost of gas/oil
- pluc 6y agoThe protest for Dakota isn't about the pipeline, it's about where the pipeline goes. Would you be okay with a pipeline going through your house? Also pipelines are usually taking the human element out. When an oil train derails, you know about it. When there's a hole in a pipeline, it can take days for anyone to notice.
- koheripbal 6y agoThe route of the Dakota pipeline was along the exact path of an existing pipeline. The real reason for the protests was that the tribe was NOT paid off because the pipeline CIRCUMVENTED their reserve.
- imglorp 6y agoEnergy Transfer Partners (aka Sunoco) are pulling similar crap in Pennsylvania. Through or under dense housing, shopping malls, tearing up little league fields, occupying rights-of-way for years on end with drilling machines. They've already ruined many aquifers, poisoned a drinking reservoir, caused sink holes, even damaged their own nearby pipelines. All this before the thing gets pressurized with propane, ethane and butane. They subvert legislatures using public utility classification, eminent domain anything they want, and then bully anyone observing. Then they play the national security card for anyone asking about a disaster plan or blast radius. There must be enormous profit here for such enormous public harm. Marsh Creek lake: https://stateimpact.npr.org/pennsylvania/2020/08/11/mariner-east-construction-spills-10000-gallons-of-drilling-mud-into-chester-county-lake/ https://stateimpact.npr.org/pennsylvania/2020/08/11/mariner-... Backfires? https://whyy.org/articles/sunoco-says-mariner-east-2-system-backfired-during-maintenance-but-no-risk-to-public/ https://whyy.org/articles/sunoco-says-mariner-east-2-system-... Criminal investigation: https://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/politics/chester-county-opens-criminal-investigation-into-controversial-mariner-east-pipelines/10047/ https://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/politics/chester-county... Secrecy protection: https://www.spotlightpa.org/news/2020/12/mariner-east-pipeline-csi-act-pennsylvania-public-information-secret/ https://www.spotlightpa.org/news/2020/12/mariner-east-pipeli...
- AngryData 6y ago
- JoBrad 6y agoThe article says that trucks carrying LNG are already allowed in the area, though. Just considering the likelihood of damage to the container, it seems like pipelines > trains > trucks, no?
- ceejayoz 6y agoIt's unlikely that a hundred trucks will all crash at the same time in the same place.
- JoBrad 6y agoTrue. The article said that 3 could be transported at once. I don’t know what (if any) limitations there are on the number of trucks carrying LNG in the same area, at once. I’m just thinking that it’s far more likely that a truck would be involved in an accident that involves a fire vs a train.
- ch4s3 6y agoThe problem with pipelines for oil is that they tend to leak in isolated areas, where trains and truck can be maintained at their origin and destination.
- tyingq 6y agoThe ammonia and chlorine tank cars would scare me more. I've seen these running close to residential areas before.
- bumby 6y agoFamous chlorine train incident: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graniteville_train_crash https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graniteville_train_crash
- MereInterest 6y agoNon-mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graniteville_train_crash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graniteville_train_crash
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoAnd nitric and sulphuric acid. And calcium carbide (gives off acetylene if it gets wet). And toxic waste. And literal military bombs.
- 1cvmask 6y agoWarren Buffet likes trains for oil transportation: https://www.vice.com/en/article/qvamxw/warren-buffett-really-likes-oil-trains-despite-the-explosions https://www.vice.com/en/article/qvamxw/warren-buffett-really...
- jjk166 6y agoA random person being scared of something near their home does not make it actually dangerous. LNG doesn't explode like in the movies, it needs to vaporize and mix with oxygen to burn. A leak in an enclosed space can pose an explosion risk, but that's not an issue for a rail car sitting outside. Boiloff can potentially cause a tank to rupture, but this is easily prevented with a pressure release valve. If there is a leak, there is of course a fire hazard, but such a hazard is no worse than the leak of an oil tank. In fact, where an oil leak could potentially allow a large amount of fuel to pool up creating an explosive hazard prior to ignition, natural gas will mostly dissipate harmlessly prior to ignition. LNG transport is generally safer than crude oil transport, and a crude oil spill has much worse environmental effects. If you are comfortable with oil being transported through densely populated areas, you should be fine with this.
- Pfhreak 6y agoWould a crash be sufficient to cause a sudden aerosolization of the lng? It seems to me that it could, but I am not an expert. Natural gas has a smell added because it has historically exploded... > If you are comfortable with oil being transported through densely populated areas, you should be fine with this. What if I'm not comfortable moving crude but train?
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Would a crash be sufficient to cause a sudden aerosolization of the lng? Well yes, but actually no. You can't get a freight train up to the kind of speed you need to create an "instantly dump the contents of the pressure vessel" type crash without creating a "slowly vent the contents out" type crash first. You would need to use a bomb to rupture a pressure vessel to get the kind of fuel/air mix you need for an explosion or fireball. Fuel-air explosives operate in this manner. But they are devices with countless engineering man-hours spent making them actually work and fairly precise manufacturing. Parking ye ol' Winnebago (or Penske, if you're a history buff) beside the tracks and waiting for the train to go by is not going to be a very productive approach. Look at people blowing up propane tanks on YouTube. At best they get a fireball. I'd much rather have nat-gas wafting up and away rather than crude oil, propane, or some other volatile that sits at ground level.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoA large amount of oil comes into New Jersey on a single line near the Hudson river owned by Norfolk Southern. Every single crossing on the line is in a deplorable state of repair where rails are loose enough that they bounce around when cars and trains run over them. A highway grade crossing had collapsed in on itself and they ignored it for a year. They had to be forced kicking and screaming to start fixing them a couple years ago and the work is still ongoing. I wouldn't trust the assholes running these companies or the FRA to maintain safe infrastructure for dangerous cargo. Their current tactic is to punish the towns that complained loudly by ripping up the crossings and then not working on them for a month.
- JoBrad 6y agoNot saying you are incorrect, but it’s hard to imagine a rail company intentionally leaving a productive line inoperable for a month just to punish a town. They had to have lost a ton of money because of that.
- snarf21 6y agoI think the implication of the parent was that the car part was ripped up not the rail part. The line works just fine, just f* the cars that need to cross it.
- _jal 6y agoThen perhaps you should consider the possibility that you're imagining the wrong thing. Greed is indeed a powerful motive, but insufficient as your only roadmap to the world.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoThe rails are still in place with the road blocked.
- devb 6y agoWhat towns has this occurred in?
- mikewarot 6y agoWe already see the "Big Rolling Bombs" of crude oil rolling through Hammond, Indiana on their way across the country. I'm very glad I live miles away from those tracks.
- jinkyu 6y agobut a truck or tractor full of LNG can drive directly in front of your house. also some people, _gulp_ actually have a never ending supply piped into their houses directly!
- yabones 6y agoTime to air one of my most controversial opinions: I think transporting LNG by train is good. Hear me out. When you build a pipeline, it's good for exactly one thing. An LNG pipeline won't do for anything else, not even other types of oil products. But building a railroad on the other hand, that's good for just about anything from transporting bulk grain to truck frames to solid rocket motors. Even though they built the original rail network 150+ years ago, that doesn't define the limits of what it can be used for today (other than the physical dimensions of the carriage etc). If we stop shipping oil by rail we can just build new rail cars and ship other stuff. Obviously we have to consider safety. There are serious drawbacks of both ways to transport LNG, it's just inherently dangerous. Many people remember Lac Maganetic a few years ago, where a series of technical failures caused a high speed derailment that devastated a small town in rural Quebec. Many also remember the poorly maintained pipelines all over the world that dribble oil into the ground water 24 hours a day. The difference is that trains are comparatively very cheap and easy to inspect and retrofit with sensors. Rail transport is very visible when it goes wrong, but pipelines are far away and far under ground, most of the time buried beneath the 'under class'.
- gruez 6y ago>When you build a pipeline, it's good for exactly one thing. An LNG pipeline won't do for anything else, not even other types of oil products. But building a railroad on the other hand, that's good for just about anything from transporting bulk grain to truck frames to solid rocket motors. But doesn't that only make sense if there's going to be demand in the near future? Unused rail lines get abandoned all the time because they have maintenance costs, so it's not like we can build it, stop using it, and then resume using it a few decades later when demand picks up.
- Arnt 6y agoThose aren't the kind that are abandoned. The kind to carry natural gas goes from A to B. The ones that are typically abandoned go from B to hamlet-near-B, or to factory-near-B, or were obsoleted due to a change in the network. I see all three where I live. A new express route was built and bypasses some stations, so fewer trains stop at those stations, which makes local connections to those stations less valuable, and some X-to-hamlet tracks will probably be closed in the end. A new tunnel is being built and when it's done freight traffic will be routed differently than it is now, and it seems likely that one old route will be closed.