3 ms·
A bold claim which I wanted to believe but regrettably can't - yet. Tried it on a variety of material that I already know well, from pedagogical texts to academ
by anigbrowl 6y ago
A bold claim which I wanted to believe but regrettably can't - yet. Tried it on a variety of material that I already know well, from pedagogical texts to academic papers in multiple discipline to legal briefs to news articles, including my own output.
I like it. it's got potential. With north of 5000 pdfs in my library I'm extremely open to tools like this, and the methodology seems pretty sensible to me. But at present it feels kind of random - good at picking out summary sentences of what a document section will cover, or emphatically stated conclusions, bad at highlighting necessary context. I wonder if it might be better trained on clauses rather than full sentences, although that's probably significantly more work.
I'm sorry I don't have a more positive review, but I think it's a bold attempt even if it falls short, and want to see where it goes. Even as is, I can see myself using it sometimes as its selections offer an interesting alternative to my own skimming/emphasis preferences. Very impressed with the clean no-BS user interface and fast performance.
- heresjohnny 6y agoHi anigbrowl, thanks for your thorough review! This is really helpful. I am aware that Tuchu's current strength mostly (and in many cases solely) lies with identifying sentences that summarize, not sentences that explain a concept or convey crucial detail. In that sense the claim of "highlighting the important parts" may indeed be a bit bold. In my opening post I said that doing your own reading is still a requirement, but it might be good to also mention this on the site — at least until I find a way to improve the algorithm. One way could be leveraging pre-trained word embeddings, but this would require a server or downloading a large blob to the user's device beforehand. In any case Tuchu wouldn't be as fast that way.
- anigbrowl 6y agoWell, your reach should exceed your grasp! It's already an interesting tool and one that I'm sure will improve as you work further on it.