3 ms·
Thanks to them for being so transparent. I'm definitely interested in seeing what they create and I'm rooting for them. I feel like they're borderline on about
by staunch 19y ago
Thanks to them for being so transparent. I'm definitely interested in seeing what they create and I'm rooting for them. I feel like they're borderline on about 6 of "18 mistakes" though, so I'm a bit skeptical. Upgraded office, slow launch, hiring lots of people pre-launch, devs with a C#/Java background, QA people, product managers, desktop software? Perhaps they'll handle it all well, but those are some red flags to me.
- hello_moto 19y agoWhy are these "red flags" Devs with C#/Java background a red flag? Why is that? Should they use Ruby or Python for the desktop app that supports Outlook as a plugin instead of C#? If they haven't launched and they got financial backing (huge), that means they have a solid business model that's important
- webwright 19y agoFinancial backing means that they have a solid business model? Urm, I don't think that's true. All it really means is that some VCs think it has huge growth potential.
- hello_moto 19y agoSo let me see. Xobni showed Khosla people that they have some "cool" desktop app (or plugin, whatever) and Khosla Ventures love it and thought that it has a huge growth potential so they gave them money (in the area of millions). I think that's 1/3 of the whole story. I'm guessing they also show their business model (or at least business plan). Think about it carefully, this isn't YAW2.0 (Yet Another Web 2.0). This is a desktop app (or plugin). It's not like you can throw in the wild and put Ads. And remember, these guys are playing in Microsoft backyard.
- staunch 19y agoPerhaps they do need to use C#/Java for their desktop software but that doesn't mean they need a "Software Engineer with a C#/Java background". Taken in the context of them hiring Product Managers and QA people it seems like a red flag to me.
- hello_moto 19y agoWhy not? If they can get someone who knows C#, more power for them. The faster for the new guy to adapt with the code given he/she knew Java/C#. Java is a language close to C#. I still don't understand your objection. Product Managers and QA? Why not? Who will test the product? uh-huh, it's the QA. It's not like your ruby/php/python code can be tested just by a simple unit test. It's not like your desktop app not need to be tested (UI wise).
- staunch 19y agoThere's a difference between hiring someone who is a C#/Java programmer and someone who can program in C#/Java. That's my point. As for Product Managers and QA people. They have a tendency to slow development down to a level they can manage and test. I avoid them both like the plague.
- Tichy 19y agoUm, what's so bad about being a Java/C# programmer? Is the hubris of the scripting crowd really that sky-high?
- staunch 19y agoNot sure. I didn't say anything was bad about being one. I don't speak for any crowds either.
- Tichy 19y agoSo what exactly was the point you were trying to make?
- mynameishere 19y agoOh, for the love of beans, they're taking the words straight from the mouth of St. Paul: http://www.paulgraham.com/pypar.html http://www.paulgraham.com/pypar.html
- 19y ago
- brezina 19y agoWe aren't specifically looking for C#/Java developers. We are looking for generalists. When developing desktop software, Python and Ruby just aren't viable options. Two of our guys didn't know much C# before joining us. However, they are killer hackers no matter what language they use. QA is critical to a downloaded piece of software - you can't just update it like a webapp if you find bugs. Integrating with desktop email clients was a tough choice for us, until we looked at the market. The majority of business professionals who use email as a critical business tool, and also happen to spend money on software, use desktop email clients.
- staunch 19y agoIt's not hard to look for potential red flags with any company. Sounds like you guys are aware of these issues, which is good to hear. Thanks for continuing to share your very interesting story.