5 ms·
> Outside, the man jumped into a black Dodge Challenger as officers drew their firearms and told him to stop Not sure how this was justified for shoplifting.
by kevin_thibedeau 6y ago
> Outside, the man jumped into a black Dodge Challenger as officers drew their firearms and told him to stop
Not sure how this was justified for shoplifting.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- speedgoose 6y agoDefinitely not justified in my country.
- crooked-v 6y agoPolice across the US are trained to default to the threat of violence at all times, with the expectation that if they don't someone will immediately try to kill them. A couple of examples: https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/12/police-gun-shooting-training-ferguson/383681/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/12/police-... https://www.startribune.com/fear-based-training-for-police-officers-is-challenged/487958041/ https://www.startribune.com/fear-based-training-for-police-o... https://www.minnpost.com/community-voices/2020/06/warrior-or-guardian-how-police-training-fails-us/ https://www.minnpost.com/community-voices/2020/06/warrior-or...
- WillPostForFood 6y agoWhen the police pulled out their handcuffs to arrest the man, he fled out the back door of the hotel, losing a sneaker on the way. Outside, the man jumped into a black Dodge Challenger as officers drew their firearms and told him to stop, but he took off, causing an officer to jump out of the way, the report states. He crashed into the back of a patrol car and a column outside the hotel before speeding out onto Route 9, an officer wrote. Not sure how you characterize that as "shoplifting". They had already questioned him about the shoplifting, without pulling their guns. It was the escape, driving at the officers, and ramming that got the guns pulled.
- aeturnum 6y agoThe account you quoted describes the police pulling out their guns before he got into the car at all. Evading arrest is not a capital offense and they don't mention that he had a weapon or that they believe he intended to harm anyone, so it's hard to see how pulling their weapons is justified. It doesn't make sense to use the fact that he hit some stuff while fleeing from the men with guns to justify drawing the guns. In fact, provoking panicked flight seems like a pretty foreseeable outcome of drawing a gun on someone. If I had a gun drawn on me I might very well flee in a panic, potentially hitting cars with mine. They drew the guns before he did any of that and it's reasonable to think them drawing them made those outcomes more likely. Edit: Here are the NJ deadly use of force standards [1]. My reading of the standards would not allow the use of deadly force in this situation. The rules also state that officers should only unholster their weapons when "circumstances create a reasonable belief that display of a firearm as an element of constructive authority helps establish or maintain control in a potentially dangerous situation." It's hard to see what was "potentially dangerous" in this situation before the guns were drawn. [1] https://www.nj.gov/oag/dcj/agguide/useofforce2001.pdf https://www.nj.gov/oag/dcj/agguide/useofforce2001.pdf
- sebastien_b 6y agoI think the story is missing some context on this (which I tried to point out earlier, but got downvoted for my troubles) - it does seem excessive if the suspect hadn't run yet, but could be justified if he was driving towards them with the vehicle after failing to follow the officers' instructions.
- aeturnum 6y agoI agree that it would make more sense if they drew their guns in response to the suspect driving at them. I also think that, if that had happened, they would have emphasized that in their account of what happened.
- sebastien_b 6y agoAgreed - I think the story's recounting of the events might be missing some (a lot?) of details - looks like the author had only the reports to go on, since no one else wanted to provide comments for the story.
- furyofantares 6y agoMy dad was a biker. He lead a clean and sober biker club, but you can't really tell the difference between that and a gang unless you know the symbols ("colors") on the jackets. When I was maybe 11, we were in eastern Washington, I was on the back of the bike, and we got pulled over for failing to signal when pulling out of a gas station. Which I don't think is a violation? And also we did signal. But in any case, the cop approached the bike with gun drawn and pointed at us. It's not about the suspected violation. These are cops willing to aggressively threaten lethal force when they are experiencing fear/anxiety/uncertainty based on what the suspect looks like, be it their skin color or their clothing.
- mc32 6y agoSimilarly exchange student classmates in college committed a road violation, either speeding or moving violation, I don’t recall. In any event they didn’t know the protocol for pulling over in their rented car. The CHP called for backup forced them over and drew their weapons on them. Same for friends at a University. High, and in possession they tried ditching the cops; bad move. Cops caught them drew weapons extremely infuriated at them.
- folkhack 6y ago> These are cops willing to aggressively threaten lethal force when they are experiencing fear/anxiety/uncertainty based on what the suspect looks like, be it their skin color or their clothing. There are also a fair amount of bully cowboys out there hiding behind the badge. I was a teenage passenger in a car when a friend of mine held up his wallet in the light of the back window to see if he had his bank card or w/e. Cop car was behind us in traffic, pulls us over, and two cops get out guns drawn instructing everyone to get face down on the pavement. Turns out they thought they saw a knife/gun when my friend had held us wallet up in the light, and they figured we were brandishing a weapon at them. We all got searched and when they found half of us Boy Scouts were carrying pocket knives things got really stupid really fast. We had to beg them to be rational with us, nose down on the pavement. Still makes my blood boil. This is anecdotal in rural small-town Iowa.
- iso947 6y ago
- diggan 6y agoJust shoplifting is not the full story, although I agree it's still overkill. > the suspect shoplifted candy and other snacks from the hotel gift shop and darted into a men’s room after a hotel staffer called police. > When two officers arrived, the man handed over a driver’s license from Tennessee identifying him as Jamal Owens. > But police ran the name through the computer in the patrol car and determined the license was not valid and possibly fraudulent, according to the report. > When the police pulled out their handcuffs to arrest the man, he fled out the back door of the hotel, losing a sneaker on the way. The police outside has no idea about the threat-level it seems, for them it's just someone running from the law, possibly dangerous person. That the situation even escalates to this point for some shoplifting and invalid license though, is quite telling of the public's feeling and fear for the police.