5 ms·
The implication I assume that there would be pushback on Microsoft for doing the same would be because of the possibility of nefarious undocumented changes. Wha
by MichaelZuo 6y ago
The implication I assume that there would be pushback on Microsoft for doing the same would be because of the possibility of nefarious undocumented changes. What possibly nefarious things could an undocumented ISA extension do?
- mhh__ 6y agoUndocumented It's not about EEE it's about Apple taking this attitude in the first place.
- hyperman1 6y agoPresumably the next iteration of the processor can remove them and use the opcodes for something else. Apple recompiles their system library, hence is unaffected. You can't do the same so peak M1 performance is unavailable for you.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoCould those opcodes then be used for anything nefarious, or would it just restrict third parties from fully utilizing the processor?
- Someone 6y agoIf you think Apple wants to do something nefarious to users of their hardware, don’t buy or use it. If they can’t be trusted, they don’t need to add opcodes.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoWell the point of the question is trying to establish if it’s even possible in the first place. If there is no credible way, then there is no need to fear there are nefarious reasons for implementing such a change for either Apple or Microsoft, outside of restricting third parties. If there is, then it’s as you say.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoApple can make tools that use the undocumented ISA, which they don't have to release to the public, potentially using it to develop applications with performance advantages that no one other than Apple can attain. It's similar to how Microsoft doesn't make all APIs on Windows public and uses non-public ones for various reasons--except this is in hardware. It's possible the undocumented ISA is used to speed up x86 emulation and might be kept secret due to intellectual property concerns or similar.
- emteycz 6y agoThey didn't have to open the platform for other software (OS) at all. Let's be happy with what we got.
- _underfl0w_ 6y ago> Let's be happy with what we got. Ouch. It's exactly this mentality that enables malicious actors - "it could be worse". It could always be worse, but that doesn't make it sufficient justification. Functional equivalent: "It could always be even more anticompetitive. Let's be happy with what we got."
- emteycz 6y agoEh, what? What malicious actors? What sufficient justification, and justification of what and to whom? What could be worse? What could be more anticompetitive, and competing with what exactly? I said nothing like this, your "equivalents" are from an entirely different world. I said we should be happy Apple decided to open their platform - because they didn't have to, at all. It's entirely their right to not open anything, not write any documentation, or not even allow 3rd party software at all. If you don't like it, don't buy their overpriced premium products - it's not for you. I wouldn't want my own company to be forced to do/not do stuff, so of course I don't wish that upon Apple. There are enough entirely open computing platforms that are VERY cheap to obtain and easy to use, perhaps that would be a better choice for you.
- 6y ago