3 ms·
> You can generally sense if someone could be a possibly good fit in 20 minutes of conversation. The last position I hired for had 700 applicants. Paper filter
by prepend 6y ago
> You can generally sense if someone could be a possibly good fit in 20 minutes of conversation.
The last position I hired for had 700 applicants. Paper filtered down to 75. Interview screened down to 30. Detailed interviews with 5.
How would you propose this work? 30 people seemed like a possibly good fit after 20 minutes. Should we randomly hire one? Should we hire all and have them fight it out madmax thunder dome style?
I think if the position has low startup time and is assembly line work or something we could hire all 30 and fire the poor performers. Outside of tech support, I’m not aware of any positions like this.
I’ve worked with managers who thought programmers were like this and would hire 10 or 20 at a time to see who stuck. It was very frustrating as an existing employee because they all had to be trained, reviewed, etc. After a year of arguing, I (and every other senior, over about two years) left that company.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Should we randomly hire one? If the additional interviewing time doesn't produce real improvement in outcomes over random hiring, then yes, don't waste the interviewees’ time and time the form is paying you for doing it.
- prepend 6y agoMy problem is that I don’t know of a good way to determine what improvement. I think it’s hard to design a study and measure. And I think there’s a deontological vs. utilitarian aspect as I think if applicants learned I was randomly picking 1 of 30 pretty goods it would discourage high quality applicants. For me, I think the additional 100 hours interviewing helps and is worth it. I’d be interested in hearing of hiring managers and orgs who just hire randomly from minimally qualified applicants. I hear from lots of applicants who claim they are minimally qualified that this is a successful strategy. But, naturally, they are a bit biased and not very useful for deciding how to hire people.
- xyzelement 6y agoI also don't understand the assumption he/she makes that the additional interview time doesn't help. Of course it helps.
- valarauko 6y agoI'm sure the additional interview time helps - how can it not? I suppose the question is - is it _necessary_ to find a suitable candidate?
- valarauko 6y agoI think I need to update my mental models around the tech job market here, and what the interview process is trying to achieve. To take this example further: of the 700 initial applicants, how many would be _adequate_ for the position? You had the opportunity to have quite detailed interviews from the pick of the bunch - is the goal to find the very best of the lot because you can afford to be picky; or there are genuinely only 3-4 in the 700 who could _adequately_ do the job? My preexisting mental model is that from the 700 applicants, 30 could have filled the position adequately, with perhaps a ~5% gain across them. Each additional step in the interview process yields increasingly diminishing returns but is still worth it because ... you can choose to be picky in this market. The risks associated with a mishire are also presumably greatly reduced with each diminishingly selective step. Or is it that there genuinely exists only 2-3 people in that pool who are a good fit for the role, and you have little choice but to engage in kissing a whole load of frogs to find your prince?
- prepend 6y agoI’m not sure how many could adequately do the job. Generally because the phone screen doesn’t give a good sense of this so the 30 I talked with maybe 5-10 of them could potentially do the job adequately. We only extended an offer to one person and maybe a second if the first declined. If both of those two declined then we wouldn’t have offered to the other 3 detail interviewees. I’d certainly like a better way that uses less time. But it does seem that I need to kiss a lot of frogs. Also, the goal isn’t to get an “adequate” person but to get a really good or great person. I think that a good person can do 5x more than an ok person, maybe even more. So for this position, I’d rather keep looking than just get a body. Again, if I just needed assembly line workers or warm bodies that could bill in a consultant sweatshop, that’s a different story. But I don’t want to be in such a hiring position.
- valarauko 6y ago>I think that a good person can do 5x more than an ok person, maybe even more This is really surprising to me, and I'm not sure how this can be the case. I would imagine that this would be true of a high level position at the top of their game, able to define their own schedules & goals. For a typical worker with clearly defined short & long term objectives defined by the organization, how does one become 5X more productive? Clearly my heuristics about the tech industry are way out of step with reality. However, I could see something like this happening in my own field: academia. As a bioinformatics postdoc, the bread & butter work most of my colleagues do is routine, so they can hit their goals fairly predictably. My project, in comparison, is mostly ad-hoc, struggling to parse a novel dataset right on the edge of what is technically possible. My productivity is in the toilet, and I can imagine a different researcher in my position being 5-10x more productive. This is not how I imagined the tech industry working, though.