4 ms·
It's lifted from the original from over a decade ago: https://mobile.twitter.com/sand2drn/status/1343260855488684032 https://mobile.twitter.com/sand2drn/status/
by viraptor 6y ago
It's lifted from the original from over a decade ago: https://mobile.twitter.com/sand2drn/status/1343260855488684032 https://mobile.twitter.com/sand2drn/status/13432608554886840...
I hope nobody expected every single copied document to be analysed and refreshed for this agreement. A lot of existing documents will be copied into a new deal as they exist today.
- Lev1a 6y agoPoliticians and lawyers are paid well enough and then some for us the people to expect due diligence, especially for such an important piece of legislation that's to be in effect for the foreseeable future.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoThe basic pay of Uk politicians are not that high.
- halo 6y agoThe basic salary for a UK MP is £81,932, with additional pay for additional responsibilities (such as being a minister). The median UK salary is around £30,000.
- Ichthypresbyter 6y agoFor comparison- the MP's salary is similar to that of a military OF-4 (Commander, Lieutenant-Colonel or Wing Commander), a secondary school headteacher, or an NHS consultant (specialist doctor with at least 8-10 years experience post qualification).
- dmitriid 6y agoAnd this means... what exactly? That we should expect MPs to perform their duties with the same diligence that we expect from military commanders, teachers and specialist doctors? Or that military commanders, teachers and specialist doctors should make rash uninformed decisions because they are underpaid?
- Silhouette 6y agoBut military officers, school officials and senior doctors don't generally have to spend thousands of their own money applying for a job, with no guarantee of success, and they don't typically get to take a five- or ten-year year career break and then just stroll back into their old career again afterwards. MPs who become part of the government often do fairly well out of it, obviously more so the more senior the government position(s) they hold, and there are a lot more members of the government than most people realise. But rank and file MPs often get a pretty raw deal compared to the kinds of alternative options anyone with the attributes to be a good MP would probably have.
- jodrellblank 6y agoThere is no educational or qualification or experience requirement to stand for election as a UK MP, all you need is a few hundred quid, the approval of your party and ten voters. https://5050parliament.co.uk/get-elected/ https://5050parliament.co.uk/get-elected/ Maybe we'd be better off if MPs had to study and practise as much as an NHS consultant has to before they can run the country?
- dijit 6y agoThe base pay of UK politicians is well above median salary and puts them into the top 5% of earners in the country; before you get into things like the fact that housing costs for two homes, travel and food costs are all fully subsidised.
- mjburgess 6y agoYet the significant majority of them can earn much more. "Isn't that high" is not with reference to the median, but with reference to their pre-existing career prospects. The salary of MPs is not sufficient, by a long way, to attract almost any one from other competing careers.
- Smaug123 6y agoThe fact that you could have a more highly paid job elsewhere does not excuse you from the responsibility to do your current job.
- ben_w 6y agoNo of course not, what it means is that people with the skills to do the job properly and who care about their responsibilities are looking elsewhere, and only those who feel drawn to power and those who can’t get better jobs are left. (I don’t have a solution, every option I’ve heard comes with downsides)
- iso1210 6y agoI'd hope such an important law to be passed after a thorough examination, testing, and debate. In reality it will be nodded through in the UK by 400 people who have barely skimmed it.
- viraptor 6y agoThat implementation has been already reviewed by the UK years ago. The referenced document is about "stepping up of cross-border cooperation, particularly in combating terrorism and cross-border crime" which goes down to details like XML format of the exchanged data and which parts of DNA are used to identify people across Europe. It's not something that UK can change on its own and definitely not something that should give anyone a pause before accepting the document as was already implemented - just because an old browser is listed in examples. It can easily be debated as "do we have any issues with the technical details of the international exchange of forensic information or should we continue with what we have right now?"
- ben_w 6y agoIt also says to hash with SHA-1 and encrypt with 1024 bit RSA, which is more concerning and less amusing than Netscape Communicator.
- thu2111 6y agoEU law is full of stuff like this. There's no philosophical conception that law should be minimal or regulation a last resort, so they pass huge laws all the time that specify precise details of things and which get very out of date. A good example is to compare US law on digital signatures Vs EU law. The latter mandates PKIX and the former just says words to the effect of any digital equivalent of a signature. So you can imagine which is simpler and more flexible.
- realityking 6y agoSince this regulation is not a standard to be used by the public but how governments of various countries interact, I don’t see the problem. Imagine they had only specified “must be encrypted”. Now France is going with S/MIME with SHA1 but the UK with SHA-256. The French system didn’t anticipate this and the can’t decrypt it. Meanwhile Germany is using PGP and nobody can read anything. Long way to say: strong specs improve interoperability.
- serial_dev 6y agoI might be naive but I was expecting that someone would read it and catch things like this. It's a trade deal, not a high school homework. If it's too long to be read, then are all those details really necessary? It just like contracts, most privacy policies, etc that are written in gibberish, are extremely verbose, yet everyone is afraid to simplify it because "there must be a reason why legal documents are not written in plain English". Sometimes there is no good reason.
- Silhouette 6y agoBut that would require proper, diligent scrutiny. I mean, it's only a deal that will affect hundreds of billions in trade every year and numerous other foreign relations issues, indefinitely, and it's only around 1,200 pages long. What could possibly go wrong asking elected representatives of 28 states to approve it with less than a week to even see it and, in the UK's case, a single day of Parliamentary debate? (For comparison, the news today mentioned that Maastricht got more like a month.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- viraptor 6y agoThere are groups interested in those details which will pick them up when the time comes. If people started bikeshedding the details right now, nothing would be achieved. Raising the browser or hash issue in this case would be like stopping a discussion about moving a 2000 people corporate HQ to another location to make sure that a specific wobbly chair on the 2nd floor gets fixed in the process. It's not the right time and place to discuss it.
- dingaling 6y agoBut the wobbly chair was thrown out in 2010, yet is still referenced by name in the premises migration checklist. In other words if it's so insignificant as not to be discussed it shouldn't be included at all. Any processes should have been written at a high level with a call out to the specific specialist organisations who implement them.
- jka 6y agoPerhaps the overall document was reviewed based on a diff, and so the section regarding email clients wasn't highlighted to reviewers, since it hadn't changed. And/or there wasn't any versioning applied to the email technology section, so subsequent updates to the recommended-email-clients package haven't yet been pulled into the document. (this is somewhat tongue-in-cheek; but conceivably some of the techniques that contract reviewers use are not-too-dissimilar to code review. Perhaps it really all is completely manual based on physical documents, but hopefully not..)
- jonplackett 6y agoEither that or UK and EU governments are all still using Netscape. Seems plausible either way...
- vmilner 6y agoWell, the currently in-force "COUNCIL DECISION 2008/616/JHA" at https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32008D0616 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A... contains the same SHA-1 requirement, so the story seems to be that: 1) EU Law requires out-of-date encryption algorithms 2) The new agreement mirrors EU Law 3) From 1 Jan, the UK will be able to enact regulatory divergence, and use SHA-256 (or whatever) instead.
- viraptor 6y ago> From 1 Jan, the UK will be able to enact regulatory divergence Since this is for sharing the data internationally, no, changing it on one side doesn't make sense.
- vmilner 6y agoFor cross-border regulations like this you're quite right, but making sense is the reason for the UK not doing so, rather than it being a legal requirement.