3 ms·
The answer is to accept and embrace the end of population growth, and even cheer for population decline. This obviously requires a paradigm shift but ultimatel
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
The answer is to accept and embrace the end of population growth, and even cheer for population decline.
This obviously requires a paradigm shift but ultimately can be a net positive for the environment, quality of life, and individual wealth.
- esarbe 6y agoWhile some population decline is probably for the best, we need to stabilize the population at some point. Otherwise there's no foundation for a sustainable civilization.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoObviously. No-one is suggesting to make our species extinct... But let's remember that we were less than 1 billion not too long ago while we're on course to be 10 billion soon, with individual consumption massive increased on top of that. We won't solve climate and environmental problems unless this is tackled. The aim of civilization is to make people better off, not to squeeze them into a dystopian world of overpopulation and environmental collapse.
- esarbe 6y agoAbsolutely! I think it would be fine to go back to 1 billion, although the transition to a less extensive infrastructure will probably be quite rough. It's good that we already started concentrating most of the population in cities. This will help with the transition immensely.
- raducu 6y agoHas the concentration of population in cities helped us in the past when things gotten quite rough?
- esarbe 6y agoThe most important factor in keeping people alive nowadays is infrastructure. We're not self-sufficient anymore and it's pretty delusional to think that we'll be able to move back to some kind of pre-industrial pastoral idyll. We are dependent on high-tech and that's not going to change. The easiest way to make everyone able to participate in that high-tech is to have high-density population centers with little infrastructure benefiting the most people.
- raducu 6y agoThis is only true today because infrastructure is made ridiculously expensive by the same overlord-leaches that benefit from artificial scarcity of real-estate of those overpopulated cities which enslaves people and is driving the birthrate decline. A battery one order of magnitude better than what we have today would obliterate that need for infrastructure. Internet from the sky, VR, remote education, remote(AI) medicine, flying electric cars, compact fusion power, would mean unchaining the whole world from the sociopaths that are running it today, but we can't have that, because the sociopaths at the top like centralization in order to leach off the rest of the world.
- esarbe 6y agoNo, it wouldn't. Nothing but a miraculous fabricator that can power and fabricate itself would obliterate the need for infrastructure. Let's just take one example; VR. For VR, you need VR googles. These need to be produced somewhere, in an industrial mass production because otherwise these VR googles would be prohibitive expensive. That means industrial scale energy production and industrial scale energy transportation and industrial scale energy storage. This industrial scale industry needs to be repaired and upgraded, probably by people. These people need housing, food, education, ... Now take a guess on what you need to provide each and every one of these? Yeah, right; infrastructure. It's a rat's tail. You cannot get a way from infrastructure if you want any kind of technological civilization.
- oblio 6y agoWe've never been in this timeline before. Preindustrial cities can't serve as reference.
- raducu 6y agoYou can only cheer if you know you can actually stop the population decline before it leads to a catastrophic disruption of the world wide civilization, right? Who and when will do it? Are we willing to take away women's rights if its the only way to stop a population decline? There's nothing to cheer if you really look into it.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoNot sure what or who you are replying to here, certainly not to anything I wrote... Taking away women rights? Where does that come from, that's ludicrous. Countries where women have the most rights are the ones with lower birth rates as it happens, and for good reasons.
- raducu 6y agoI'm not sure why is it hard to understand the implications of what I said. 1. at some point we "HAVE" and humanity WILL put an end to birthrate decline. 2. "Countries where women have the most rights are the ones with lower birth rates as it happens" Therefore, one solution would be to take away women's rights. That's not something I would stand for, but for certain totalitarian countries, it would work. That's a very easy solution any idiot could come up with, just like slavery. The other, MUCH, MUCH harder solution would involve completely changing world order, creating a much flatter and equal society, which is IMPOSSIBLE to do by the current world wide idiocracy.