4 ms·
Farmers aren't 'average people'. A commercial-scale farm requires millions in investment. It runs on small margins, and is run like a factory. A modern 1000-acr
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Farmers aren't 'average people'. A commercial-scale farm requires millions in investment. It runs on small margins, and is run like a factory. A modern 1000-acre farm can be operated by one or two people. That's been the trend for 200 years. America for instance has gone from 50% farmers to under 2%. Arguably the reason we were the superpower we were - so much more manpower for other things.
And to create a fancy mechanical robotic wall-farm to produce commodity products like lettuce seems folly. I'm sure they chose that because it comes to maturity in a score days, not weeks or months. And the 'floor space' per plant has to be enormous for that farm-of-the-future.
The article belabors the 'less land used' argument throughout. Perhaps because that's the only place they win (not on price; not on investment cost; not on variety or flexibility?) While that's important, the issue is not running out of farmland. The American farmer has gotten so efficient, doubling output per acre repeatedly for a century now. Iowa could feed two United States. The US could feed the world. With old-fashioned land-intensive agriculture.
- giantg2 6y agoThat all depends on the crops. The labor needs or ability to use vertical farms is vastly different between tomatoes, citrus, and corn (for example). There are still small farms, although they are continuing to die off. But even if farmers are not average, then what work do average people have?
- ConcreteGidget 6y agoIt's pretty dystopian to see a page comprised of technocrats writing about these topics. Median estimation for AGI is around 2060 so its not just "average" people.
- giantg2 6y agoWhy is it dystopian to talk about agricultural related topics? Is that AGI of 2060 a mistake?
- ConcreteGidget 6y agoThe people who are on this forum are cogs in a machine that, over the next 40 years, will displace millions of American workers. It seems where we are headed into a bifurcated society part overeducated technocrats part gig economy task rabbits. Seeing the former group beginning to consider the effects of their work is dystopian. I'm not sure what you mean by "mistake."
- giantg2 6y agoWhere did you get your number for AGI? An adjusted gross income of $2060 seems extremely low (very far below average). It's not dystopian to consider the possible effects of one's work. If you don't consider them, then how can you make adjustments/improvements? It would be dystopian to maximize the negative impacts. We are doing the opposite - questioning what the best course of action might be.
- ConcreteGidget 6y agoBy AGI I meant Artificial General Intelligence. There is no stopping or meaningful slowing of the machine.
- giantg2 6y agoThey also estimated we would have flying cars 20 years ago. These sort of estimates are highly inaccurate. Even then, do we just ignore the average people for the next 40 (your median) years?
- ConcreteGidget 6y ago"They also estimated we would have flying cars 20 years ago." My number comes from a collection of AI researchers from the future of life institute so I can't imagine a better "they" to defer to. That said, we are bad at predicting the future so who knows? I never said we should forget about the average people or normal people as Yang calls them in his book "The War on Normal People." Even if we don't have AGI we will have narrow AI such as self driving/factory stuff/textiles which will displace millions. I'm all for UBI or some sort of equivalent social safety net (I'm not an economist so I don't want to be prescriptive here as I have heard some drawbacks to UBI). The technocrats have already created platforms that are tearing our social fabric apart by promulgating conspiracies and radicalizing our youth while reducing long-form literacy an increasing anxiety and depression. What we need is some sort of social revolution that in my opinion could only be obtained by an authoritarian government that protects people from themselves and the exploitive tech corporations. Ban facebook to reduce conspiracy promulgation. Ban tiktok and ever increasingly addictive video games to prevent our youth from becoming dopamine junkees. Ban drugs so the listless and ever-growing welfare class remain mostly docile. None of these changes are feasible in a country whose identity revolves around personal freedom/choice.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoWhat work? Not sure what's the question. Its retail sales, service industry, delivery, stuff like that.
- giantg2 6y agoSo automated stuff? Retail has been dying off due to online sales. Delivery services are looking automate with drones. Not to mention that places like Amazon start their own service and pay their drivers less than the major places (worse jobs). Service industry is reeling from the pandemic. Many of those jobs are automatable too. The general trend has been to eliminate onshore jobs that are low skill and outsource those tasks to lower cost countries. As it has also been towards jobs requiring higher education. So what opportunities are there? After all, we are seeing increased dependence on support programs and wage stagnation.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoWorse than that. China is America's number one consumer of automation equipment. They're just a decade or two behind us. Soon their working class will be out of things to do as well.
- edoceo 6y agoMost of your points are solid. However, Variety could be a huge win. With the full-auto farm there is room to try out different types and experiment in small batch with tight monitoring and control which can also give predictable yield.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoAs long as the crop is fast-maturing. Else the expensive 'pot' makes experimentation cost prohibitive?