6 ms·
Unit costs of goods sold would be interesting, compared to 'traditional' classic modern intensive farm price. An observation from the article also could be ans
by ggm 6y ago
Unit costs of goods sold would be interesting, compared to 'traditional' classic modern intensive farm price.
An observation from the article also could be answered: what areal space is required to generate the power?
Neither of these are meant to be thunderclap proof-it-fails critique, they're just interesting.
In food miles, freshness and lack of need for water, fertiliser and pesticides its winning hands down for feeding its urban population surrounding it. Repurposed brownfield site, existing buildings would also reduce impact.
I fear a loss of jobs and richness in ag. Supporting towns. Jobs are empowering, even crap ag. jobs but a reality here is that farming is overwhelmingly industrialised and jobs are either kept in the family or massively exploitative piece rate so this isn't a killer argument against either, but I do worry the rural area depopulation is a continuing trend.
- AmVess 6y agoTraditional farms aren't going to be upset by this approach. It more of an answer to how we are going to feed 14 billion people than it is a threat to our current way of growing things to eat.
- bjelkeman-again 6y agoAlso, by not growing these products on other farmland, other crops, which aren’t suitable for vertical solutions, can be grown on that land. There is a shortage of farmable land, so this is another piece in the puzzle. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/dec/02/arable-land-soil-food-security-shortage https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/dec/02/arable-l...
- loceng 6y agoEnvironmental impact needs to be calculated as well. The only concern I have is soil, nutrient supplementation quality - profit focus would dictate trying to include bare minimum nutrients which doesn't necessarily yield the best food but "good enough" being produced.
- giantg2 6y agoYep, we already see this in many cultivars today - they are less nutritious than many heirloom varieties because they prioritize production (paid by the pound).
- ggm 6y agoI suspect these target a market intensely focussed on nutritional value, as well as price. Good food commands a premium. Yes, naked competition would force costs down and if nutritional value was costly that would drop, but this technology is early phase, may well still be more expensive than bulk commercial agriculture and succeed because of the variance of price and value and the huge amount of price elasticity inherent in food choices. I think you're arguing too strongly from reductionist economic theories. I already am willing to pay significantly higher prices for brie over US cheese blocks, and I pay over the odds for tomatoes I like. In Food economics, competition is not solely driven by price basically.
- giantg2 6y agoThat may be true for people who are well off, but there is a large segment of the population who are food insecure and many others that do not have that level of disposable income. Then you have the segments of the population that don't see any benefit to more nutritious foods and thing they are all the same. For example, why is organic farming not the predominant method?
- hourislate 6y ago>Environmental impact needs to be calculated as well. The first comment on the articles page was addressing some of that impact. Does it feed insects and birds and support biodiversity? Does it sequester carbon in the soil, making below-ground life healthy, increasing access of plants to nutrients, and hence produce healthier food? Does it help water infiltrate into the ground, this replenishing ground water and aquifers? Does convert sunlight into latent heat via plant transpiration, and thus support the Small Water Cycles that cool the surface of the earth and convey water (via rain) downwind to drier land? Does it engage the senses with beautiful sights and smells? Does it engage humans in an honest day's work, making them proud contributors to society?
- giantg2 6y agoUse of nuclear could preclude the power issue.
- im3w1l 6y agoSo I know nuclear is supposed to be able to handle current power needs of humanity for quite a while, but if we fill earth with super intensive vertical farms powered by artificial light... Anyone ran the numbers on how long uranium would last running sun-less agriculture for a few billion people?
- giantg2 6y agoI'd imagine the few billion number is high. The cost would likely prevent this from being deployed in the majority of the world.
- andy_ppp 6y agoWhat they say in their interview is scaling this to make it economically is possible if they just have the scale. Personally I’m extremely skeptical of their success...
- giantg2 6y agoI imagine that's only in first world countries.
- andy_ppp 6y agoWhy? Everything to run one of these would be cheaper in India (for example)...
- giantg2 6y agoAnd what is the price for the produce in those areas? Less as well. In these areas, it's highly unlikely this system would be feasible if land costs are relatively low and energy prices are a relatively higher expense compared to incomes in higher earning countries (as a percentage of income).
- Spooky23 6y agoToo late for that. My family are big baseball fans, and we go to the baseball hall of fame for tournaments or indications every few years. That drive from Albany to Cooperstown is progressively more depressing first as small dairy was destroyed by deregulation and later as agricultural policy put everyone out of business unless you grow corn or flowers or farm tourism.
- driverdan 6y ago> Unit costs of goods sold would be interesting They didn't mention it because it's impractically high right now. As an experiment this is interesting but it's nowhere near cost effective yet.
- njharman 6y ago> I fear a loss of jobs and richness in ag. Your fear is a century late. Really, all of civilized history late. The very clear trend of civilization is loss of agricultural jobs.