4 ms·
It doesn't really need to get a lot cheaper. It's already cheaper than coal. I don't think retrofitting residential rooftop solar is necessarily such a great i
by pydry 6y ago
It doesn't really need to get a lot cheaper. It's already cheaper than coal.
I don't think retrofitting residential rooftop solar is necessarily such a great idea given the high installation cost. It'll make much more sense on large flat roofs like on strip malls. Residential electricity users will probably get more bang for their buck by being able to take advantage of fluctuating spot prices - e.g. with intelligent storage heaters.
It'll make sense on newbuilds though. If you're already building a roof, why not make it generate a bit of electricity? The installation cost will already be built in.
- pjc50 6y agoIt's already almost mandatory for new builds in the UK.
- kccqzy 6y agoAlso mandatory for new homes in California. https://www.marketplace.org/shows/marketplace-tech/new-california-homes-must-have-solar-panels-not-everyones-feeling-so-sunny-about-that/ https://www.marketplace.org/shows/marketplace-tech/new-calif...
- treis 6y agoThe problem is that roofs leak and now you've gotta remove a bunch of solar panels to fix it.
- labawi 6y agoWhy not make a roof out of solar panels? You will need to deal with the gaps and it's not trivial, but if you are already putting huge panels, would it not be easier to route rain/snow/ice from the gaps, than to build a separate rain/snow proof layer with a bunch of mounting holes? It shouldn't be hard to add some overlapping flaps to the panel (during manufature), and roofs with tiles like these [1][2], only use around 5cm of overlap, so 10-15cm might be sufficient and simple for a big solar panel. [1] https://www.diyhowto.com.au/guide/how-to-clean-terracotta-roof-tiles/ https://www.diyhowto.com.au/guide/how-to-clean-terracotta-ro... [2] https://www.recycledbuildingcentre.com.au/terracotta-roof-tiles-5-each https://www.recycledbuildingcentre.com.au/terracotta-roof-ti...
- treis 6y agoPeople are trying but it's quite a bit more expensive than a traditional roof.
- labawi 6y agoMore expensive than roof+solar? Do you have references to any solutions, other Tesla's popular, pretty and expensive version? A flush panel-only roof seems more aesthetic than shingles + raised solar, and would be good-enough for me.
- treis 6y ago>More expensive than roof+solar? Comparable, but that's not the right comparison. It's between a roof and buying your power from the power company and roof+solar. The first is way cheaper. If we want to be green than still, a roof + 1,000 sq feet of solar out in the country connected to your house by wires is way cheaper.
- Animats 6y agoWhy not make a roof out of solar panels? Tesla offers that, but it's not cheap.[1] [1] https://electrek.co/2019/06/14/tesla-solar-roof-quote-price/ https://electrek.co/2019/06/14/tesla-solar-roof-quote-price/
- labawi 6y agoThat's a gimmick with thousands of panels and connectors. Very pretty, but seems like a fire waiting to happen, or at least a regular failure. Also seems expensive financially and materially with all those individual connectors and cables. I was thinking of something a bit more brutalist-fashion, with the roof designed for standard 1-2 m² panels, and a small dose of non-solar same-color panels for any chimneys, corners or other unavoided irregularities. Not small shingles to fit any roof.
- foolmeonce 6y agoThat's not really much different than having a terrace or a green roof to deal with when roof problems occur. Sure you can make a plain roof but it is a ridiculous waste of outdoor space, which leads you to need to reserve other space. I would like to see terrace materials with mediocre efficiency solar collection, similar to the solar streets idea, but dealing with a realistic amount of wear and tear.
- treis 6y agoFlat roofs are significantly more expensive and tend to have lots of difficulties in climates with significant snowfall.
- foolmeonce 6y agoIf you are talking about a single family home then build a solar A-frame, or better yet don't build it. But most larger buildings need to have a significant amount of flat roof.
- ThomPete 6y agoits not cheaper than coal, in fact it cant function without fossil fuel. You need to account for the backup energy needed to if you want to talk about the price
- cbmuser 6y agoRenewable advocates never account for the backup power plants. If they did, they couldn’t make these bold statements anymore.
- epistasis 6y ago10 years ago, the story was that solar could never produce energy at an affordable rate, and if we ever got past 5% renewables we'd see rolling blackouts. Then the panic point was 10%, then 30%, then 50%. Now the FUD has switched to "you're not taking into account the cost of backup fossil fuels." Well turns out that coal is being shut down everywhere, because it can't even compete. We don't need them. There's a chance that we might need natural gas a few weeks a year in 2040. The statement should be "how are natural gas plants going to shift payment schemes so they can survive in this world," not "you're not taking into account the cost." We have storage alternatives that will make natural gas obsolete at the next spike in fuel prices. Storage deploys quick. The fossil fuel guys had better get their lobbying straight if they want a piece of the pie in 15 years, or they will be engineered around.
- kortilla 6y ago> Well turns out that coal is being shut down everywhere, because it can't even compete. We don't need them. Because of natural gas. The growth of natural gas almost entirely offsets the coal shutdown. We have barely doubled the electricity generated by renewables in the US since the 90s: https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-in-the-us.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-... And hydro makes up a 1/3 of it, wind makes slightly more than hydro, and solar is nearly a drop in the bucket.
- 6y ago
- cbmuser 6y ago> It doesn't really need to get a lot cheaper. It's already cheaper than coal. I’m tired of this claim. It’s cheaper when you ignore the necessary backup power plants, yes. That’s not a real-world system though and Germany’s electricity prices disagree with you.
- epistasis 6y agoNo, it's cheaper even with battery backup: https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2020 https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2020 Stored solar, no subsidies: $81-$140/MWh Coal: $65-$159/MWh And then with solar, 40%-70% of consumption will be direct without storage, at $29-$42/MWh, which pulls the all-in cost of solar way below coal. And that's for projects deployed in 2020. Wait 5 years, the typical timeline for bidding and installation for utilities, and any utility that isnt planning for massive renewables and storage is simply bilking their customers. Germany was built a decade ago. Using it as a point of reference is deceptive.
- missedthecue 6y agoAre there enough lithium reserves to store billions of kwh? (Ignoring their usage in cars, phones, medical devices, and everything else)
- epistasis 6y agoYes, we haven't even been looking for lithium until recently, and the availability of it has more than doubled in just a few years. (Note that a lot of lithium comes from "resources" and not from "reserves," as the latter term usually refers to mining rather than brining.) For current chemistries, cobalt is more of a concern, but that's mostly a concern for car batteries, and the concern is more about the terrible conditions of extraction (some child labor from small scale mining) than the total amount. For stationary storage, sodium behaves a lot like lithium, but is far heavier. And there are all sorts of flow chemistries that have barely been examined. However I think the lithium train has left the station, unless there's some sort of serious market interference to cause huge unexpected shortages, there's little chance for lithium competitors to catch up within the next 15 years.