2 ms·
> 1. Austrian economics is right, Keynsian is wrong. At this point in history, how can anyone claim that Keynesianism is "wrong"? > I would summarize the Keyn
by throw0101a 6y ago
> 1. Austrian economics is right, Keynsian is wrong.
At this point in history, how can anyone claim that Keynesianism is "wrong"?
> I would summarize the Keynesian view in terms of four points:
> 1. Economies sometimes produce much less than they could, and employ many fewer workers than they should, because there just isn’t enough spending. Such episodes can happen for a variety of reasons; the question is how to respond.
> 2. There are normally forces that tend to push the economy back toward full employment. But they work slowly; a hands-off policy toward depressed economies means accepting a long, unnecessary period of pain.
> 3. It is often possible to drastically shorten this period of pain and greatly reduce the human and financial losses by “printing money”, using the central bank’s power of currency creation to push interest rates down.
> 4. Sometimes, however, monetary policy loses its effectiveness, especially when rates are close to zero. In that case temporary deficit spending can provide a useful boost. And conversely, fiscal austerity in a depressed economy imposes large economic losses.
* https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/09/15/keynesianism-explained/ https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/09/15/keynesianism-ex...
I'm sure that there are nuances in the model that can be more or less accurate, but the idea that (aggregate) demand drives economic activity, and that (central bank) interest rates and government (stimulus) spending effects economic activity seems fairly certain. Especially with everything we've seen over the last ~20 years: Fed-driven US real estate bubble, post-2008 economic recovery, lack of inflation due to low/zero rates even with lots of "printing money", austerity caused economic slowdowns (in the EU).
It's been one giant economics petri dish of experiments. How has Keynesianism failed? Non-K folks were predicting all sorts of problem, and yet the Ks were saying 'it'll be fine':
> We believe the Federal Reserve's large-scale asset purchase plan (so-called "quantitative easing") should be reconsidered and discontinued. We do not believe such a plan is necessary or advisable under current circumstances. The planned asset purchases risk currency debasement and inflation, and we do not think they will achieve the Fed's objective of promoting employment.
* https://economics21.org/html/open-letter-ben-bernanke-287.html https://economics21.org/html/open-letter-ben-bernanke-287.ht...
- solatic 6y agoLike most of Krugman's blogs, he's over-simplifying for a mass audience. Full-employment is very easy to achieve for the government, if that is the government's only goal. Create artificial demand for ditches to be dug, and then hire people to dig those ditches. The fundamental question is not how to generate artificial demand, but how to generate artificial demand that succeeds at generating useful value. Now, that spectrum has a range of answers. Sometimes you don't really care about value, or you take value on faith, e.g. when constructing public infrastructure works. They put people to work, get people spending, and everyone agrees that the country is in dire need of infrastructure improvements right now. There are, however, two non-infrastructure extremes: a) spending money on strong companies that will become stronger (instead of failing due to temporary unavoidable circumstances), but if anyone knew for sure which companies these were, the government wouldn't need to spend any money at all, investors would step in and pocket the profits. Then there's b) spending money on weak companies that would've failed in a year or two anyway, and emergency bailouts only forestalls the inevitable, wasting money and time and creative potential for nothing. Now most companies are on a spectrum, which means that the strategy of such wide-spectrum spending is to offset the losses of boosting weak companies with the gains made by strong companies, overall. Will it work at generating (net) useful value? Maybe. If so, then the currency is tied up in the extra value generated, and we'll avoid inflation. If not, then we have far more currency in circulation for the same amount of value, and prices will go up in tandem. Jury's still out.
- throw0101a 6y ago> Full-employment is very easy to achieve for the government, if that is the government's only goal. This is a bit black-and-white: full employment may not be the end-goal of stimulus spending and the government generally, but rather simply just getting the ball rolling. Pre-pandemic there wasn't much need of stimulus, and certainly no need of the December 2017 tax cut (TCJA) that was supposed to "pay for itself" per its proponents, given the state of the economy and unemployment rate: * https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE Now that isn't the only measure of 'success', but if the unemployment rate is (say) >8%, then spending money on 'non-useful value' work, so that people can pay rent and buy food, isn't such a bad thing in the short-term (IMHO). Some certainly argue for full-employment all the time, but that's a separate discussion than the general idea of raising aggregate demand to 'induce' economic activity. > Now, that spectrum has a range of answers. Sometimes you don't really care about value, or you take value on faith, e.g. when constructing public infrastructure works. They put people to work, get people spending, and everyone agrees that the country is in dire need of infrastructure improvements right now. Yeah: * https://www.npr.org/2018/05/15/611389675/why-its-infrastructure-week-again https://www.npr.org/2018/05/15/611389675/why-its-infrastruct... * https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/10/21173209/infrastructure-week-dead-rebranded-trump-tweets-united-policy https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/10/21173209/infrastructure-w... * https://www.infrastructurereportcard.org https://www.infrastructurereportcard.org
- sunshinerag 6y agolack of inflation due to a flawed definition of inflation.
- throw0101a 6y agoWhat is the current "flawed" definition, and what would be a 'non-flawed' definition?