4 ms·
The first paragraph is spot on, but the second is just wrong. Turbojets fly much faster than needed, for the convenience of the passengers. Drag goes as the s
by ajross 18y ago
The first paragraph is spot on, but the second is just wrong. Turbojets fly much faster than needed, for the convenience of the passengers. Drag goes as the square of speed, so per-distance fuel economy scales as the inverse of the trip time. One certainly can do much better than a turbojet simply by swapping the fan for a larger geared propeller and flying at half the speed.
- cdr 18y agoAnd in fact, there have been news stories recently about airlines adding a few minutes per flight in this way to save fuel.
- marvin 18y agoAirlines in Norway openly and publicly reduced the speed of their routes by 10%, while attempting to make up for the lost time by improving their pre-flight routines.
- pg 18y agoJets can also fly higher, which means smoother flights.
- ajross 18y agoActually, that's an issue of design choice, not fundamentals. Turbojets fly higher because they fly longer (so don't worry as much about inefficiencies due to climbing to alititude) and want to fly faster (up to the tropopause, temperature is dropping which results for mildly complicated reasons in power dropping more slowly than drag does). But there's nothing inherently "lower" about a propeller. They work just as well at altitude as they do as sea level. It's just that market forces have dictated that props are better suited to low-altitude, low-speed commuter routes. But you could design a high altitude prop without difficulty.
- pg 18y agoReally? Is it an urban legend that jet engines work better at high altitudes than propellers? I wouldn't be surprised. Anyone else know about this?
- ajross 18y agoPretty much. There are actually some fancy solar designs for low-speed unmanned cruisers that work up to the 80-100kft level (solar cells don't lose power with altitude, so they don't have the tropopause limitation that oxygen breathing engines do). Those things are all about efficiency, and they pick props for the same reasons that other efficiency designs do. Jets are comparatively more efficient at high speed (rather: high-radius prop losses grow with speed faster than low-radius fans), not at high altitude per se. But since tropopause-altitude is a design goal for speed designs, these two have traditionally been interchangeable. As far as credentials go, I'm the author of the "YASim" dynamics model that FlightGear (http://www.flightgear.org http://www.flightgear.org) uses. So while I'm a hacker and not an aerospace engineer, I do have at least a little domain expertise.
- pchristensen 18y agoGood freaking luck trying to sell half-speed flights. Maybe as part of a national security deal - less oil used for airline fuel due to slower flights in exchange for removing some painful, slow, ineffective security screening.
- elai 18y agoWhy not? They can offer those flights for lower prices, so people willing to go for a longer, cheaper flight can choose to do so. If they become popular, then they've gotten new market niche.
- khafra 18y agoYou'd never buy a half-speed flight. I'd buy a half-speed flight from Tampa to NYC if it were 2/3 the price of the jet flight. My poorer friends would buy the route on a 1/4 speed airship if it were cheap enough. People have different sensitivities to time vs. money.
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoI might even pay more for a trip by Zeppelin...
- evgen 18y agoI might have been a bit too broad in stating that the turbojet is the best at what it does, but "speed" is a design characteristic just like any other and alternatives will need to come close on the speed side or else anything they may provide on the economy side of the equation will be ignored. Turbojets fly as fast as is practical given the market demand they are serving. If airlines offered people the choice of flying half as fast for a lower price the fast flight would still win (up to a certain point, as the supersonic option showed when Concorde was still flying.) You could do even better by putting your turbofan onto a rigid airship, but that isn't going to happen either :)