3 ms·
>The myth of physical feminization has its basis in existential concerns about power and status. Adams has studied this idea at length. She and other scholars h
by Bakary 6y ago
>The myth of physical feminization has its basis in existential concerns about power and status. Adams has studied this idea at length. She and other scholars have argued that the idea of veganism is rolled up with qualities like compassion, conscientiousness, and empathy—for animals or the environment. By modern American cultural standards, these are feminine traits. Violence, physical domination, and self-interest are masculine. Add in the global history of colonization, Adams says, and meat has become equated with white, heterosexual men. “Now it’s kind of like plant-based meats are here to take away their identity,” she says. “So eating meat is a sort of reactionary attempt to reclaim something that’s already been lost.”
Simply blaming anxieties on manliness and colonialist attitudes is too reductive. Another aspect to consider is that meat-replacements introduce the anxiety of a future disconnected from nature and its bounty and more importantly a certain type of lifestyle that went from expected to luxurious. If you look at online far-right rhetoric, you'll immediately notice that they frame soy (and modern day consumption in general) also in reference to classic science-fiction tropes of compliant populations in dystopian societies that are force-fed terrible meals and toil away with little hope of independence or freedom. Essentially conditions where human beings are reduced to bug-like behavior.
I'd say that this avenue of investigation is a lot more relevant to most people than simply chalking up meatless anxiety to subgroups of white men being unreasonable and calling it a day. It's certainly not an issue that is limited to white men with far-right beliefs. The more left-wing version would be the complaint that the wealthy can live in the equivalent of paradise while the rest are told to enjoy their metaphorical processed soy paste and not be so greedy as to ask for a decent life with a minimal presence of meaning.
We are seeing home ownership become an impossible dream. Semi-pastoral lifestyles centered around strong communities are already a relic of the past. By contrast a future where people can't own anything really important and live mechanistic, consumption-oriented lives with screen based parasocial relationships is already the reality for hundreds of millions of people worldwide. The soylent is just a focus point for some of that anger and dismay.