3 ms·
If you buy a "non-smart TV", unless you plan to use it with an analog tuner or something, you're going to plug in boxes, and those potentially carry the privacy
by kazinator 6y ago
If you buy a "non-smart TV", unless you plan to use it with an analog tuner or something, you're going to plug in boxes, and those potentially carry the privacy-invading bogey man.
There is literally no difference, in this regard, between a dumb TV with a dongle/box plugged in, and a smart TV which has exactly the same thing built-in.
The nice thing about a dumb TV, such as the one I have is:
- simplicity of operation/configuration. I never have to fiddle with any menus in my dumb TV. You turn it on and it's ready to go. All the HDMI inputs have dedicated buttons on the remote control, so switching inputs is easy. Changing picture mode: dedicated button. Other than for switching inputs, I don't use the TV remote at all. The Android TV box's remote is a beautiful thing of simplicity. Smart TVs running Android TV come with complicated remote controls: the "android box" feature built inside doesn't have its own simple remote (unless you buy an after-market one, I suppose).
- portable "brains": the box or dongle you plug into it fits into a coat pocket. Take it anywhere and watch your content (anywhere, modulo possible geographic restrictions, for which you need a VPN).
- portable "brains": possibility of upgrading the TV, without the hassle of re-installing apps and logging into each one: just out with the old TV, in with the new. Logging into apps on a new device is particularly a pain if you're mooching logins off friends and relatives!
- the ability to shut the TV off, yet have content keep playing and listen to the audio. This is possible if your Android box has an audio jack! I absolutely love this. I hate visual content burning pixels on the screen when I'm just listening to music.
- yegle 6y agoYou can use your phone and a Chromecast Ultra (not the new Chromecast with Google TV).
- kazinator 6y agoWell, not the specific "you" referring to me; I use my Android Box (Chromecast with Google TV would work also) for Japanese IPTV. This cannot be installed on the plain old Chromecast. Furthermore, that IPTV application, though it runs well on phones, is one of those that doesn't cast. We use casting quite a lot in my household, but only for a handful of things that can't be installed on Android TV. The UX of Chromecast is sub-par compared to just using an installed app with the remote, but Chromecast plugs the gaps: connecting mobile-only content to the living room TV.
- toast0 6y ago> There is literally no difference, in this regard, between a dumb TV with a dongle/box plugged in, and a smart TV which has exactly the same thing built-in. There is a big difference. If someone comes out with a privacy respecting box to plugin, I can justify spending $50-$100 to use that instead of the box I have that works fine. If someone comes out with a privacy respecting quality TV, I'm not going to buy it to replace a working TV. Currently going with a TV with smart features that I don't use. Hopefully it doesn't pull a 'must connect to network' stunt after a while as I've heard some do.
- leetcrew 6y ago> There is literally no difference, in this regard, between a dumb TV with a dongle/box plugged in, and a smart TV which has exactly the same thing built-in. I mean, the TV is usually much more expensive than the dongles that get attached to it. I don't love replacing a $30 dongle every few years, but it doesn't hurt my wallet too bad. replacing a whole $500-1500 TV every few years is a big deal. ultimately I've made my peace with the whole smart TV thing. my current one does a much better job streaming high bitrate local media than a chromecast. whenever it stops getting updates, I will probably just buy a NUC to use as a source, and use it as an unnecessarily complicated dumb TV.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y ago> There is literally no difference, in this regard, between a dumb TV with a dongle/box plugged in, and a smart TV which has exactly the same thing built-in. To be clear, some of the commercial units people recommend are missing features like HDMI 2.1, 4K, HDR or DolbyVison, etc compared to their “retail” counterparts. You really need to know what you are looking at when you consider commercial units.
- vbernat 6y agoThe box you plug could be running Kodi for example. No privacy-invading bogey man included.
- realityking 6y agoI trust both my Blu-ray player and my AppleTV not to do too much shady shit.
- olliej 6y agoThere is a huge difference between a smart TV and those “boxes”. I trust Apple, Roku, and even google more than smart TVs producers. They also provide support, have a demonstrated interest in providing security updates, and at least in the case of Apple don’t profit off spying on you. Smart TVs have been repeatedly caught spying on people, both indirectly by reporting what you watch, and directly with microphones. They’ve been caught injecting their own ads into content that you’ve already paid for. They seldom, if ever, get any updates, and even those that do get less long term update support than generic android phones. This is why people hate smart tvs