4 ms·
> advances that push society forward can come from multiple areas "Multiple areas" that could produce advances that can push society forward is still a much na
by pdonis 6y ago
> advances that push society forward can come from multiple areas
"Multiple areas" that could produce advances that can push society forward is still a much narrower category than "areas that are eligible for student loans".
> perhaps you want to be able to provide the opportunity to study a subject regardless of whether you can pay for it outright or not
Students can study any subject they want for free over the Internet. Major institutions have their entire curriculum available for free online. There is no reason why taxpayers should have to subsidize college tuition for that.
- ddingus 6y agoSure there is, and that reason is a well rounded, robust society. Plenty of nations fund higher education as a basic investment in the quality of their future people.
- onecommentman 6y agoWhat is missing is data to support that, perhaps reasonable, assumption. Objective data not provided by those who stand to benefit from a positive result. Data that objectively identifies how that benefit is accrued and at what amount. The kind of data that guided the development of every major industrial and service sector over the last 50 to 100 years and is inexplicably lacking in higher education.
- ddingus 6y agoThis goes well beyond industry and service.
- pdonis 6y ago> that reason is a well rounded, robust society That goal is not achieved by subsidizing college education in which students get to pick whatever major they want and have only a smattering of courses outside their major. According to the people who structured the US public education system, secondary school (middle school and high school) was supposed to serve this goal, not college. And the US does provide free secondary education to all, in which the basic curriculum is dictated by the government and, while students do have some choice in what courses to take, their choices are much more limited than in college and they are unavoidably exposed to a much wider variety of subject matter.
- ddingus 6y agoSure it is. Plenty of nations understand the value of college education and they don't make people go into massive debt for it.
- hnlurker 6y agoName the countries that fit this description that don't also have strict entrance criteria? Criteria that also nearly invariably come with severe caps on the number of students that can enroll in those curriculae. Want to "follow your passion" and become a trained lesbian dance theorist? Sorry, we're all full up on that.. As much as I hate the idea of free college, I for one would happily trade our American model for those European ones. We'd all be better off with fewer college graduates (or even worse, drop outs) in general, and from non-STEM fields in particular.
- pdonis 6y ago> Plenty of nations understand the value of college education It doesn't seem like many of them value it more than the US, and none value it all that much more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tertiary_education_attainment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tertiary_... In the US, 44 percent of people age 25-64 have a college degree; only 6 countries have a higher percentage and the highest is Canada at 54 percent, which isn't that much higher. > they don't make people go into massive debt for it It is true that many other countries have free college education; however, as shown by the numbers above, this does not seem to have resulted in a larger fraction of their people getting college degrees.
- ddingus 6y agoPerhaps the numbers suggest a society with lower personal cost and risk exposure presents less incentive to get higher education. The more important discussion is how massive debt dilutes a lot of the value in the education. That debt is unnecessary.
- onecommentman 6y agoAnd so the question becomes, as it has been for 5 years and could have been for 20 years, how good is an online education, or an online+ education, compared to a classical lecture/exam/lab education? And what should the “+” in an online education look like? And how much should this cost? And does a University add value to the Community and Nation by its sheer existence and, if so, how and at what cost? The greatest challenge I imagine to pure online is the possibilities to cheat during assessment/certification. They are rising anyway with the improvement in IT and are exacerbated by more virtual interaction. The Panopticon might be unavoidable. More direct one-on-one time with professors, whether online or physical, could help. The professor as tutor, rather than researcher who gives the occasional lecture series. I think it’s been that way at Oxford for a while. https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/student-life/exceptional-education/personalised-learning https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/student-life/e... Would also help with motivation, although one of the requirements of getting a college education is that the student demonstrates sufficient self-motivation to complete a program. It isn’t supposed to be super high school...although my impression is colleges were more like super prep schools before the introduction of the GI Bill after WWII changed/matured collegiate life for the better. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G.I._Bill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G.I._Bill This will be a Golden Age for the autodidact. I mean, like, wow.