8 ms·
Info is available about which college majors pay off, students aren’t using it
- commandlinefan 6y agoWell, it’s not as if every major takes the same effort - the harder ones “pay off” faster.
- analog31 6y agoI suspect that even if hardness or effort could really be quantified and compared, there would be some glaring counterexamples to this rule. I know someone who is a classical violin performance major. She has a very heavy, difficult workload.
- onecommentman 6y agoWhich then brings up the painful question, with today’s mountain of recorded music and audio and AI techniques to make Joe Average sound like Heifitz, how many classical violinists do we, as a society, need? If, in a population of 7B+, the children of top .1% in wealth can supply that, then they pay their own way. They can also more easily economically survive the ups and downs of a musician’s career. Just doesn’t seem fair, though...reinforcing the natural elitist bent in classical music.
- watwut 6y agoThat question has nothing to do with fact that theory where money are reward for hard degree is bonkers. Another glaring contra example: I studied computer science. I like it, but fact is that getting that degree is much less work and easier then chemistry, history and whole bunch of other degrees. I however earn the most.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ta988 6y agoNot everybody is getting into a job just because it makes money. People have passions and ambitions to have an impact on the world sometimes. Doesn't mean that you can't do both at the same time. I chose to not work for one of those ad-tech companies, would have multiplied my salary by 10 easily just at entry level, but optimizing a system so people click more on ads is not what I want to spend my life doing. Of course you could take the big salary and do good with the money... Later... but I don't see many people around me doing that efficiently and a lot of what they give is wasted by people that know how to abuse them for "a good cause". And in the meantime more important work has to be done anyway.
- clmay 6y agoYes, what a reductive, bogus article! The assumption that 1) people choose majors based solely on ROI and 2) you cannot enter a field outside the domain or discipline you studied in college are both ridiculous and flawed. Even if one were to take the lucrative salary at an ad-tech or fin-tech company, and then invest that in "effective altruism", you'd likely never offset the net harm, even if you contributed 100% of your salary.
- ytwySXpMbS 6y ago> “effective altruism” It’s funny because it’s really a justification to be selfish, the carbon offset of bad ethics.
- clmay 6y agoIt's true. What a world we live in.
- dmarchand90 6y agoDo you think you could maybe elaborate why you think the harm by ad optimization is so severe it could never be offset?
- tracerbulletx 6y agoAgreed. The only issue is university education is priced like an investment in future earnings that simply isn't justified.
- Throwawayjedi 6y agopaywalled
- efitz 6y agoWhat gets me is why isn’t major (as a proxy for future earnings) considered as part of approving student loans?
- hartator 6y agoPublic guarantees.
- someguydave 6y agoBecause the entire system is a scam to transmit federal subsidies to education employees.
- pengstrom 6y agoWell, the simplest reason I can imagine is that not all good things can be measured in dollars.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoBecause taxpayers are guaranteeing it. It’s how you get elected by both “helping” students and keeping taxes low. Long term, you’re harming students and taxpayers, but short term the optics look like you helped and you don’t have a cash outlay for helping anyone so it doesn’t affect the budget.
- wmeredith 6y ago
- threwawaysoff 6y agoAttention Comrade Students: You must chose the correct major to make the most money in order to give the most taxes to the glorious empire's military-industrial complex! To not do so would be unAmerican!
- realjohng 6y agoMaybe because it's behind a paywall .. jk
- torstenvl 6y agoFor some definition of "is available." If these 17yos are already capable of conducting research based on primary sources and not provided to them in a structured learning environment, why do they need to go to college? The implicit blame-placing in "students aren't using it" is unhelpful. We're mostly talking about people who, by definition, haven't even graduated high school.# If DoE wants students armed with this information, it should do a better job of setting policy for guidance counselors. # Yes, there are non-traditional students but they are in the minority. Yes, people can switch majors, but there's enormous cost to doing so for the populations we're talking about.
- hemloc_io 6y agoExactly, this is what gets me about the student debt debate as well. For some reason we've structured the system with the expectation that 17 yr olds are perfectly rational actors.
- travisoneill1 6y ago> If these 17yos are already capable of conducting research based on primary sources and not provided to them in a structured learning environment, why do they need to go to college? That's a lot of words to say "Googling things", and yes 17 year olds are capable of it. And they go to college for the same reason everyone else does, to buy a credential.
- cedilla 6y agoIronically, the idea that "googling things" about a topic won't lead to reductive and incomplete answers might exactly be why you give such a reductive and incomplete answer here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anotheryou 6y agoPassion was the only guidance I had it that age. Hard to become fascinated by hings you haven't really touched before; Or just in school, which might actually actively discourage you. Hobbies are the experience outside of school you have when making the decision what to study.
- olliej 6y agoPart of the problem stems from US universities seeming to charge the same amount for every course. Some courses are necessarily more expensive to run than others.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- forgotmysn 6y agothis info implies a pretty narrow view about why people chose a field of study.
- analog31 6y agoLooking up the highest paying major, and then choosing to study it, is not even a realistic option for most students. Many college majors have fairly selective entrance requirements, such as math and freshman GPA scores. To major in engineering at the nearby big ten university, you have to be accepted into it, after your freshman year. You have to pass the "weeder" course. Nursing is an interesting example from the article. However, imagine a nurse who is just not suited to dealing with people, or following rules. In addition, majoring in something that you're not sincerely interested in, is likely to be a severe if not crippling handicap. Doing with punishing effort what your classmates are doing as a game, semester after semester, might be effectively prohibitive beyond a certain level.
- onecommentman 6y agoI think the argument isn’t that you can’t study what you want, but that you personally will be on the hook for paying for the privilege, now or later. Rather than Society, through increased wages, paying you to study (after a suitable employment lag). If your major is your passion, and you don’t need certification, then there is no better time to be an autodidact and skip all the bills. Online books, free online lectures and content exploiting modern production values...sheesh. If the profession requires the certification, then they need to pony up the extra money for your wages to pay off the debt, or accept the fact that it will be an wealthy-class playground.
- paledot 6y agoUniversity didn't go super well for me, but in retrospect the experiences I treasure the most are the ones I never would've sought out on my own. If you see college as a long form of `#import book`, sure, but that's exactly what it shouldn't be.
- anoncake 6y agoYou can be passionate about something but still benefit from external structure
- novia 6y ago> imagine a nurse who is just not suited to dealing with people, or following rules. What's a good job for someone who is not suited to dealing with people or following the rules?
- tigger0jk 6y agoI think there's an idea out there that a this is a life plan that will succeed: - Go to college - Take loans to pay for it if you need to - Get a degree in something that interests you - Get a career in that field - Make money, buy a house, have a family It seems that this vision is becoming less true than it used to be or has more caveats (try to save money on the schools you attend, pick a degree that pays decently and that there are lots of available jobs in, find a cheaper market to buy your house in). I think the life planning of people entering college has taken quite a while to catch up as this shift has occurred. Although it does seem to be taking hold now as more and more people discover that they really struggle to get out from under student loan debt, can't get jobs in their relevant fields, or find they can't buy a home. I think it's good to see data like this put together, and more crucially to present some realistic perspectives to kids about what possible paths they might take in life and what the risks/rewards of those plans might look like.
- paledot 6y agoThat was the life plan the boomers took for granted, except the college part was largely optional. Now it's our fault that we don't live the same magical charmed lives they did.
- throwawaygulf 6y agoSome college majors are net negatives to society (gender/women studies, among others). These should not be supported by government backed loans, and should not be guaranteed by taxpayers.
- dirkt 6y agoThe concept of choosing a field to work in because "it has the highest pay off" is so utterly alien to me that I don't even know what to say.
- gruez 6y agoI don't get it. Is that the impression you're getting from it? You don't have to choose the highest paying field, you just have to choose a field that you like and pays well, and acknowledge that choosing a field you love most might come at the expense of finances in the future.
- seba_dos1 6y agoI happen to be interested a lot in a field that pays off well - I'm lucky. I can't imagine studying something that's not my thing just because there's money in it and I certainly wouldn't expect that of anyone else, it would be a nightmare.
- rk06 6y agosounds like something useful for student loan companies. if the student is in "safe" major decrease interests, and if they are in risky one, increase the rate. and market the reasoning. and voila, students now have incentive for cheaper and reliable courses. which results in better ROI on student loans
- fakedang 6y agoThe issue is that this might flood talented people to majors they don't like, yet who would be employable otherwise, while also being unfair to those who get a good job. Back in finance, I've met investment bankers and consultants who've majored in music and history. And yes, they often bring a unique perspective into the fold.
- dragonwriter 6y agoIs it, though? Because unless the data is controlled for factors that influence outcomes independent of school or degree program, what you actually have is data on the degree programs that attract the people that will be successful. That's nearly 100% what the outcome data on pre-college schools in the US tells you, so I'd be surprised if the college degree data did not have significantly the same problem.