3 ms·
The point of the fallacies is inline with your point. These are arguments we believe, even though they are not logically sound. That is, learning them will he
by taeric 6y ago
The point of the fallacies is inline with your point. These are arguments we believe, even though they are not logically sound.
That is, learning them will help you identify your own beliefs that are worth questioning. And, in this case, what behavior you may use that makes it hard to engage with others on their beliefs.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoFallacies are your failure to apply scientific method. The fact that you are aware of them doesn’t change the fact that you don’t know how to use it. It’s like a blind person learning this something isn’t red. They’ll continue guessing until they came up with the right colour.
- taeric 6y agoWhile not wrong, this seems less than helpful. Not all of us have the equipment/context to replicate experiments. Such that the existence of a fallacy does not equal the existence that something is false. That is itself a logical fallacy.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoLogical fallacies are just glorified cargo cults
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Fallacies are your failure to apply scientific method No, they are mostly failures to apply sound abstract logic.
- notahacker 6y ago> That is, learning them will help you identify your own beliefs that are worth questioning. But the OP's point is that they're actually not a particularly good way of identifying that (particularly the rhetorical fallacies). Many if not most things people believe which are incorrect do not involve any logical fallacy. Conversely, if I wanted to identify which of my current beliefs are probably incorrect, beliefs I hold largely because of the appeal of authorities supporting them, for example, would probably be a very bad place to focus my doubts.
- taeric 6y agoI disagree. Authority is a very common base for why you believe something. In large, we call this trust. It isn't necessarily a bad thing. This can also lead to why a rhetorical won't work. Authority works, but only with a shared belief in the authority. Such that if your message requires a new authority to your audience, it has less of a chance of working. Zero, if there is an active lack of belief in your authority figure. If examined with empathy, it can also let you accept someone's belief without believing it.
- notahacker 6y agoI don't think you actually do disagree. :) Authority is a very common base for why I believe things. 'Appeal to authority' is also a classical logical fallacy, i.e. 'but this conflicts with the positions of most scientists' is regarded as a weak and inadmissible argument in a debate versus someone who claims to have performed an experiment themselves. However, this logical fallacy is not particularly useful in assessing which of my own beliefs are incorrect, as suggested by the OP, because beliefs I have in common with most scientists are unlikely to be the beliefs I most need to question.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Many if not most things people believe which are incorrect do not involve any logical fallacy. Every false belief involves a logical fallacy, either the fallacy of false premises or a fallacy of reasoning, because starting with true premises and employing sound logic will always produce a true conclusion.
- coldtea 6y agoAnd herein lies the immaturity the grandparent was talking about. "starting with true premises and employing sound logic will always produce a true conclusion" is only useful where premises can be determined to be true, and the conclusion follows a logical syllogism end to end. This is only done (or even achievable) for quantifiable / statements of fact ("a book is on the table", "the earth is round", "the GDP is 10 trillion" and the like). For 99% of what humans care about - claims and their veracity, values, morals, politics, goals, tastes, aesthetics, interests, etc, there are no "true staatements" to begin with, and many of them doesn't involve a sound logical syllogist-sound process, but only regarding their simplest sub-parts. E.g. two political enemies might have different opinions on what to do with the national debt, but they can agree on the actual amount of the national debt, and use pure logic to calculate it, check where it was spent, etc. That, though, wont help them determine logically and agree on whether something like welfare or military spending is good or bad, and it's usually those latter questions that matter in such discussions. The thing is, people still name all those other things (that are not ammenable to logical process end to end) as true and false, based on their own opinions. Logicians can disagree all they want, this ain't gonna change. And it's those "true" and "false" statements that matter in most arguments, not their less interesting, quantifiable, easily acceptable by everybody and logically analysed brethen. The "let's point people to logical fallacy lists, as the solution" crowd doesn't understand this.