3 ms·
I think few even look at or understand the "moving stars" (planets). Also it feels few understand how seasons work. Every solstice and equinox prompts a news
by gumby 6y ago
I think few even look at or understand the "moving stars" (planets). Also it feels few understand how seasons work. Every solstice and equinox prompts a news article or two explaining what the terms mean. Four times a year. So for them "Sun moves around the earth" is actually just as good as "Earth goes around the Sun."
When I was a kid I carefully recorded the position of the sun for a year, and plotted the sun's "motion around the earth". Then I flipped it around and had the earth's orbit. (I also plotted Venus and Mars, as much as I could see them, and they plotted fine, once I switched to heliocentric.
I seem to remember that this was how Kepler came up with equal angles in equal time; I am sure I read it in a book and followed what it said, but that was many decades ago.
So the reasons are readily available without any tool but a pen and paper, but I don't think they are even meaningful to most people. I can't really blame them.
- pdonis 6y ago> When I was a kid I carefully recorded the position of the sun for a year, and plotted the sun's "motion around the earth". How did you measure how far away the Sun was? Without that information you can't reconstruct the Earth's orbit as you describe.
- 6nf 6y agoMaybe they just looked it up?
- gumby 6y agoI remember measuring the angle from a stick in the schoolyard (which wasn't far from home). A science teacher helped me. I also remember looking up a method involving looking at the moon at the right phase to calculate the distance to the sun but I do remember I never got that to work.