4 ms·
> Yes - but now we can trade with those countries on our terms… Er no, we get to trade with them on their terms, having just lost the benefits of any preferent
by simonh 6y ago
> Yes - but now we can trade with those countries on our terms…
Er no, we get to trade with them on their terms, having just lost the benefits of any preferential terms negotiated by the EU. Those “overall terms depending on EU trade deals” were overwhelmingly favourable terms negotiated thanks to the immense negotiating power of the whole EU trade bloc. We’ve now lost almost all of that.
And bear in mind a lot of these EU trade deals weren’t forced on us, we played a leading role in negotiating those deals ourselves. Now we’ve lost the benefit of a lot of that hard work.
Fortunately we have negotiated maintaining trade access with some countries, including Canada and Japan under our former EU arrangements. On many other cases though I believe including India, no such luck so far.
- breakfastduck 6y agoAgree that's the situation in the short term, but there's no avoiding that. We can go on to negotiate and agree our own deals with those countries ourselves in the long term. They will be different agreements, obviously - while they may be lesser overall they can at least be more targeted to our specific interests rather than a whole bloc, which may yield some advantages for the UK. Again, not trying to say this is necessarily better than staying in, but it does have its own advantages as well as compromises.
- simonh 6y agoIt has severe disadvantages right now and for the near future, but might possibly lead to some benefits if we’re lucky eventually if you squint right. You’re not selling me on it.
- breakfastduck 6y agoNot trying to, just rationalizing why the deals been set. I think it's actually a pretty fair compromise from both sides - doesn't necessarily mean it's better than being in though!
- rndmio 6y agoWhich countries? What major untapped markets are in need of what the UK exports but don't already have it? About 60% of our exports are services, particularly financial and insurance and we just lost passporting rights to the EU on those. The EU is not perfect but we've fucked off out of it without planning or preparing what to do next. I mean the deal that we'll be trading under in 7 days time has only just been agreed and isn't even ratified.
- breakfastduck 6y agoAgain, it's not that we don't have access to those other markets in the EU, it's that the terms are set by the EU as a bloc. Now, it'll be up to the UK to negotiate the specific terms with those markets, while being able to access free trade with the single market. Absolutely agree it's absurd that the deal comes so late with basically 0 time to really prepare, but negotiations between blocs, countries and even small domestic businesses always go right down to the wire, just a human thing.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoNone of which answers the question - which significant new markets exist for UK goods and services? Unless you count tax evasion and money laundering - something the UK was doing okay at already - there simply aren't any. There is no promised land here, no sunlit uplands, no glorious future as an independent trading nation. In reality the UK has just pulled the rug out from under its most productive service sector and cut out the heart of its tax base. And it doesn't have the skills or the culture to develop new service markets, because it's thinking like a 19th century imperial power running a 19th century economy, not like an interconnected smaller power with significant unique skills and talents in a mixed 21st century economy. When you sell a plane or a computer or a tractor to a foreign country you don't just sell an item that needs to be shipped. You also sell training, spares, continuing support, consultancy. and business development. These were relatively friction-free when freedom of movement was a thing. Now they're much harder, because they rely on employees visiting customers and possibly staying with them for long periods - which can't be done with paperwork and restrictions. This "deal" makes all of this much harder for EU trade, and does nothing at all to make it easier in Rest of World. And all of this held up for weeks by arguments about fish, which are barely a rounding error in GDP terms.
- spzb 6y agoExcept now we're a small economy and one that's shown itself willing to break international laws we'd only just signed up to. Not something most trading partners are looking for.
- krona 6y agoThere was never an ambition to diverge on day one. But as the COVID vaccine authorisation and rollout has shown, the UK is (somewhat) free to choose to do things which will influence the EU (in this example via the German press) to the mutual benefit of everyone. Sometimes 'solidarity' can prevent anyone from setting a good example.
- breakfastduck 6y agoAgreed. What the deal does provide is a different relationship. It's absolutely not just 'being defacto in the EU'. How you take that depends on your own political opinion, but it's certainly not the same as before!
- spzb 6y agoWe always had the right under EU law to make emergency authorisations for medicines. How is that related to Brexit?
- krona 6y agoThere is a right to ask permission for emergency authorisation in the EU. It was not given, and still probably wouldn't have been given if the UK hadn't rolled out the vaccine.
- spzb 6y agoSection 174 of the Human Medicines Regulations disagrees with you https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2012/1916/regulation/174/made https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2012/1916/regulation/174...
- jen20 6y agoThis is simply untrue, and spreading such misinformation has been the hallmark of lying right-wing politicians in the UK - Farage, Rees-Mogg, François etc. A direct quote from The Financial Times [1]: "Was the UK able to do this [provide emergency authorisation for the Pfizer vaccine] because of Brexit? No." Sources: [1]: The Financial Times - https://www.ft.com/content/021720c2-157e-40b4-b2f9-33515032fb19 https://www.ft.com/content/021720c2-157e-40b4-b2f9-33515032f... [2]: UK legislation - https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2012/1916/contents/made https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2012/1916/contents/made