9 ms·
Fukushima Reactor 1 melted down, 2 and 3 may have too
- wombar 16y agoOh no, that isn't possible. There were so many pseudo-reactor-experts, explaining the safety of those types of reactor in detail. And now those darn fuel rods just melted without appreciating the "don't panic, it's all exaggerated" - wall of texts :[
- mrcharles 16y agoThe fact that the fuel rods melted was always a possibility but not necessarily any worse than any other outcome. It's the fact that something is leaking that is the problem, not the melting of the fuel itself.
- nakkiel 16y agoI hardly see how an even partial but substantial meltdown wouldn't result in a breach in the containment vessel and thus in a leak.
- rimantas 16y agoAre you sure you understand what "meltdown" means? Three Miles Island accident involved partial meltdown too.
- nl 16y agoGiven that nuclear engineers don't agree what "meltdown" means [1] I don't think this is surprising. [1] The term is not officially defined by the International Atomic Energy Agency or by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. However, it has been defined to mean the accidental melting of the core of a nuclear reactor, and is in common usage a reference to the core's either complete or partial collapse. "Core melt accident" and "partial core melt" are the analogous technical terms. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_meltdown http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_meltdown
- mrcharles 16y agoSorry to be blunt, but it's because you don't understand how reactors are built, and what they are built to withstand. All reasonably modern reactors are built so that the reactor containment vessel completely contains the nuclear fuel, even during a period of full meltdown. Even some basic cursory research on your part will help you understand the whys and hows.
- marshray 16y agoI really don't think many people are lending those kinds of statements a lot of credibility any more. GE/NRC documents also describe all these multiple layers of containment as an impenetrable defense-in-depth strategy. Well, it turns out that the outer concrete building is mostly just environmental. The roof blows off and panels blow out. The pressure vessel has an assortment of through-holes for pipes and can't actually be trusted to hold in the temperatures and pressures seen by an actual meltdown. The concrete containment has an achilles' heel in this flimsy toroidial suppression pool. When it came down to it, none of it was able to hold up to the temperatures and pressures and hydrogen explosions seen in this actual meltdown. Many of us were led to believe that inserting the control rods would immediately "stop the reaction" and prevent a meltdown from occurring. These reactors melted down, all layers of containment were breached, radioactive materials were released into the environment, rendering a 20km radius uninhabitable for the forseeable future. And this is with the control rods in. So sorry if people don't simply accept your word that such-and-such "completely contains the nuclear fuel, even during a period of full meltdown". I don't think you really know.
- GHFigs 16y agoMany of us were led to believe that inserting the control rods would immediately "stop the reaction" and prevent a meltdown from occurring. I'm not sure how much you were "led" to believe that, given that the control rods became fully inserted immediately after the earthquake, where they did in fact "stop the reaction". The entire crisis revolved around the removal of decay heat, not halting the reactors.
- 16y ago
- DanI-S 16y agoPotentially 3 meltdowns occurred, after a 'perfect storm' swamped badly-sited and antiquated reactors. The end result: a few people with radiation burns, a local shortage of electricity, and a release of radiation that - while significant - doesn't come close to the radiation released by the thousands of atomic bomb tests performed in Nevada this last century. An area will be uninhabitable for a while. Lessons learned: nuclear power is pretty darn safe, although you shouldn't build 50s-style reactors near the coast in a tsunami zone. If you do, don't live nearby. No surprises there.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- kenjackson 16y agoI know what you were trying to say, but "doesn't come close to the radiation released by the thousands of atomic bomb tests" isn't exactly the way to calm people about the amount of radiation leaked.
- DanI-S 16y agoThis is true :) The most significant thing made apparent by this nuclear disaster, personally, has been how carefully authorities are forced to step around an uneducated public and a wild, hysterical mass media. How can we ever have transparency and full disclosure while the press are inclined to behave this way?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoReport all quantities of radiation in Banana Equivalent Doses rather than Sieverts.
- watmough 16y agoIs that even true? A bomb might have 100 pounds of nuclear material, fairly efficiently exploded, releasing a lot of energy. A burning, melting reactor might have 100s of TONS of fuel pellets, which can be aerosolized and distributed to the four corners.
- rimantas 16y agoYou should have read what those pseudo-reactor-experts wrote, maybe then you'd unserstand what they were trying to say.
- marshray 16y agoI read it. By and large it was "don't worry, this won't be another Chernobyl because the control rods went in and shut down the reaction and the cores don't contain flammable graphite". So, yeah, it wasn't Chernobyl, it wasn't TMI, it was its own Fukushima Daiichi style of meltdown disaster better in some ways and worse in others. But the many experts and analysts who went on record early saying this wasn't going to be a major disaster and that it was a "victory for nuclear engineering" were flatly proven wrong and it reveals the blind pro-nuclear bias in their thinking.
- pyre 16y agoOn the other side, there are the people that hear the word 'nuclear' and think that there is an atom bomb in the middle of the plant with wires coming out of it, ready to explode if someone looks at it funny.
- smithian 16y agoSo what? Sloppy thinking on the other side doesn't excuse sloppy thinking on yours. Nuclear advocates should be talking about how nuclear can move forward in the light of the dangers that are more obvious than ever now, not playing a game of "yeah but you're dumb too" with the anti-nuke crowd.
- pyre 16y agoMy point was that sloppy thinking about the pro-nuclear crowd doesn't automatically make the anti-nuclear crowd correct (or 'right') because there is plenty of sloppy thinking to go around on the issue.
- jdp23 16y ago
- chailatte 16y agoFairwinds: Fukushima Groundwater Contamination Worst in Nuclear History "That (contaminated) water is seeping into the ground table, and there will be contamination on that site for a long time to come. It could also move inland. This is ground water, it doesn't have to move out into the ocean. It is clearly moving into the north" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CAeixB19d4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CAeixB19d4 I don't believe that TEPCO is actively monitoring plutonium and uranium, which is heavy and more likely to seep into ground water than to be blown into the air. I hope that people in Tokyo do have some independent monitoring stations setup. Anybody know any links?
- yread 16y agoFukushima groundwater has been contaminated since at least 1st April http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/news/Blogs/makingwaves/daily-news-radiation-found-in-fukushima-groun/blog/34053 http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/news/Blogs/making...
- ChuckMcM 16y agoPeople will read the TEPCO report and they will process it in a variety of ways. According to TEPCO (and GE documentation) the containment vessel did in fact contain the core material. Looking at the measurements reported, (both from TEPCO and other agencies) there isn't an indication of either groundwater or watertable contamination. [update: The TEPCO folks early on said they did see some groundwater contamination with Iodine. They also point out that the plant is 'downstream' of the water table with any nuclides most likely being carried to the ocean rather than to either of the rivers higher in the water table. The engineers will know more when they open things up and start cleaning them out.] The 'news' is that cleanup will take longer because rather than pulling fuel pins out of the reactor and sending them off to be either re-processed or disposed, the core material at the bottom of the reactor will have to be removed piecemeal by what is probably custom equipment. This was the same procedure used at TMI to remove material that had migrated to the bottom of the reactor after having melted. I don't think anyone disputes that this was a tragic event and at seems nearly the worst possible accident (it could have been worse if all reactors were at full power) but it hasn't killed anyone yet, this incident is unlikely to be the principle cause of death for anyone in the forseeable future. And yet tens of thousands of people are dead because they couldn't flee the wall of water, so the tsunami was a disaster, the damage to the nuclear plant was not. When you see a head-on collision and the person in the car walks away because the airbags went off, we don't argue for banning driving because the car is destroyed, there is $50,000 worth of damage to the guardrail, and hundreds of people lost work because they were caught in the traffic jam. We say, "Isn't it amazing how safe cars are these days! That accident would have killed them even 10 years ago." We have had a head-on collision between a late model nuclear reactor and an incredibly and extremely unlikely large magnitude double disaster and so far, the safety systems that were built into the reactors and upgraded over the years have kept everyone safe. Slowly, steadily, and with good engineering practices. The results of that disaster are being addressed and will be cleaned up and repaired. I realize that someone walking away unhurt from what would have been a fatal collision might feel that it was a miracle, but it might just have been good engineering.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- andrewcooke 16y agosorry, i deleted my comment before (i thought) anyone had replied. i felt i was being too forceful without checking the facts, and i didn't have time to check everything. for the record, my argument was that the real problem is not fact-based, but a social issue related to trust and transparency. a chorus of how wonderful nuclear power is doesn't address that; it just makes you look uncaring and out of touch.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoWe can all point fingers and accuse people of being too conservative in their fear or not, but I think we can all agree that this is an unfortunate setback in terms of public perception of nuclear energy. I hate seeing coal ads that more or less state that it's safer than nuclear energy.
- nl 16y agowe can all agree that this is an unfortunate setback in terms of public perception of nuclear energy I - for one - disagree quite strongly with that. I think that it's very unfortunate that somehow Nuclear power has picked up a lot of support from people who think opposition to it is unscientific. I think that if you look even moderately closely at it you'll find that the risk modelling associated with nuclear power closely resembles the risk modelling that Feynman tore to shreds when done on the space shuttle after the Challenger disaster. For example, people will tell you that this disaster was so bad because of the combination of earthquake and tsunami knocked out the support infrastructure. They'll even give you odds on each individual problem occurring. But they don't look at the system as a whole: If an earthquake and tsunami did occur, it was almost certain that support infrastructure would be knocked out. In actual fact they were very, very lucky that no aftershock produced another significant tsunami in the area. The stupidity of those assumptions is obvious in retrospect, but nuclear fans are papering over it by saying it is a one-off problem, and associating anti-nuclear people with smelly, uneducated hippies from the 1970s. Well.. it's NOT a one off problem, and the risks aren't as low as they make out. Take seismic risks in the US. Quoting the report of Safety/Risk Assessment Panel for Generic Issue 19 (ie "IMPLICATIONS OF UPDATED PROBABILISTIC SEISMIC HAZARD ESTIMATES IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN UNITED STATES ON EXISTING PLANTS"): Updates to seismic data and models indicate that estimates of the seismic hazard, at some operating nuclear power plant sites in the Central and Eastern United States, have increased Using available seismic hazard and plant seismic fragility information, the Safety/Risk Assessment found that the increase in coredamage frequency for about one-fourth of the currently operating plants is large enough to warrant continued evaluation under the Generic Issues Program http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/msnbc/Sections/NEWS/quake%20nrc%20risk%20estimates.pdf http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/msnbc/Sections/NEWS/quake%20nrc%... So.. those risk assessments done when the plants were approved? They were wrong, and in 1/4 of plants in the Central and Eastern US core damage would occur during a seismic event within their design tolerances. Still calling this an unfortunate setback? I hate seeing coal ads that more or less state that it's safer than nuclear energy I hate seeing coal ads, but nuclear isn't the answer. (Oh, and don't believe the whole "no renewables can produce baseload" lie, either. Do some reading on solar-powered pump-hydro, geothermal and tidal power)
- patrickgzill 16y agoOne of the issues that is obscured by the discussion of nuclear plant minutiae is the question "what level of trust should be placed in government?"