4 ms·
Other way round: announcing it in advance allows time to bicker. This is at the last minute so it can be presented to am exhausted parliament who have to sign i
by pjc50 6y ago
Other way round: announcing it in advance allows time to bicker. This is at the last minute so it can be presented to am exhausted parliament who have to sign it before the truck backlog gets worse. There was no other way a deal could be achieved.
(Does anyone know if the deal includes ECJ jurisdiction for anything? That was a sticking point)
- secondcoming 6y agoBased on probably third-hand info, but I believe the ECJ is gone but Britian is still under the obligation to adhere to the ECHR, which is a Council Of Europe institution, not an EU one.
- hardlianotion 6y agoNot sure what the thrust is here, but there was some form of insistence early on that certain parts of any deal be conditional on UK being part of ECHR. I believe that was negotiated away, but it remains the case that UK remains a member of ECHR.
- tremon 6y agoThe ECJ is part of the ECHR framework, not part of the EU framework. So by remaining part of the ECHR, the UK is still -technically- bound by the rulings of the ECJ. The rub is, that the ECHR has no enforcement mechanism by itself, so the UK could just choose to ignore any rulings of the ECJ it doesn't like. It was the EU treaties that made adherence to the ECJ rulings mandatory, and therefore formed an enforcement mechanism for the ECJ.
- antientropic 6y agoNo, the ECJ is the highest court of the EU. You're confusing the European Court of Justice (EU institution) with the European Court of Human Rights (Council of Europe institution).
- djmobley 6y agoWorth pointing out the truck backlog is unrelated to Brexit.
- vr46 6y agoIt is like a one-week free trial of Brexit though.
- galvin 6y agoWhile the official reason for the border closure was unrelated to Brexit, stockpiling before the deadline certainly worsened the situation.
- ben_w 6y agoWhile true, the French customs authorities caused a similar but shorter one a month ago just by running a live test of the post-Brexit customs checks: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/nov/24/trial-of-brexit-border-checks-causes-five-mile-lorry-queues-in-kent https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/nov/24/trial-of-br...
- hardlianotion 6y agoThere is ECJ jurisdiction for trading standards in Northern Ireland to permit frictionless trading with Ireland. The details I cannot remember, but it is not a well understood point as to how this can indirectly affect affairs in UK through some kind of jurisdictional leakage.
- alisonkisk 6y agoParent was commenting on what was supposed to happen under EU policy, no the hash UK made of things.