4 ms·
Or, do they have it wrong, sexing creatures? Seems the far simpler explanation. Further the 'explanation' that males might have taken more risks, explains noth
by JoeAltmaier 6y ago
Or, do they have it wrong, sexing creatures? Seems the far simpler explanation.
Further the 'explanation' that males might have taken more risks, explains nothing. The one common denominator between every single mammal from ancient times is, they are all dead. It doesn't matter how; all their skeletons should be somewhere in the fossil record. A disparity would have to explain how male skeletons died in precisely the right way to be preserved more often. Which seems like nonsense.
- daenz 6y ago>Further the 'explanation' that males might have taken more risks, explains nothing. It does though: >Luckily for paleontologists, some of these death sites—bogs, crevices, lakes—are pretty good at preserving remains.
- sieabahlpark 6y agoIt's just some armchair redditor trying to gloat about how scientists are incapable of sexing animals and doesn't consider the chance that behavior can lead to death that preserves the body.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoAnd how about the locations female Mastadons choose for giving birth, raising calves - do they preserve remains? The OP seems a careless off-hand analysis, if it doesn't go more than skin-deep into behavior differences.
- metalliqaz 6y ago> "It doesn't matter how; all their skeletons should be somewhere in the fossil record." This is false. Most skeletons decompose. Only some happen to end up in the right spot to remain intact long enough to become fossils. Also, these mammoth remains aren't fossilized, they aren't old enough. These are just remains that have been preserved.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoOk, how about "represented in equal numbers in the fossil record". Leading to the main point: why would male skeletons happen to be preserved more often? Any ideas? That involve science, not guesses about impossible-to-measure Mastadon behavior.
- turbohz 6y agoTypical "I know more than the experts" answer.
- theduder99 6y agowelcome to hacker news
- qeternity 6y agoWorse than that. This is “I can use basic, uninformed reasoning to work through a complex, highly domain specific problem”. Usually people who think they know more are at least able to face the facts when it’s clear that they don’t. This group of people know that they don’t know as much, but believe their “superior” intellect can’t make up for it...
- swayvil 6y agoSeriously. I think it's because of the way they see the problem domain. Both ways of seeing the problem domain look much the same. I mean, a thoroughly explored domain and an utterly unexplored domain present much the same picture, in that... There are not many unexplained mysteries hanging around. Which may be translated to "The problem domain is thoroughly understood". It's the problem of invisible stuff. You can't measure its extent.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoOh get over yourself. Its a "That doesn't seem to answer anything" comment. If the paleontologists had an answer, why are they making flippant comments and un-founded guesses?
- qeternity 6y ago> If the paleontologists had an answer, why are they making flippant comments and un-founded guesses? Right, like I said, person with no domain knowledge alleges experts are making “flippant” and “unfounded guesses”. What exactly were you trying to prove?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> all their skeletons should be somewhere in the fossil record Why do you think this? It is not a true statement. Not all skeletons get fossilised - it requires a fairly particular set of conditions. It may be (likely is according to the people studying it) the case that males got into these conditions more frequently than females.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoI guess the article claimed that. I'm wondering, why? I'd like some actual science.
- chrisseaton 6y agoYou're the one claiming 'all their skeletons should be somewhere in the fossil record' - why don't you start saying why and back that up with some actual science!
- ragnarok451 6y agoSee this, from a high school science teacher, for an overview. TL;DR rapid burial in high mineral content soil creates the best chance of fossilization https://socratic.org/questions/what-conditions-increase-the-chances-of-fossil-formation https://socratic.org/questions/what-conditions-increase-the-...