5 ms·
Why do they even have to say this: >” This has less to do with misogyny than with prehistoric herd distributions...” It’s like stating that water is fat free.
by mc32 6y ago
Why do they even have to say this:
>” This has less to do with misogyny than with prehistoric herd distributions...”
It’s like stating that water is fat free. It kind of spoils the article.
- progval 6y agoThey probably meant misogyny from today's archeologists rather than from bisons and mammoths. There are known instances of gender stereotypes influencing archeological discovery. For example: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2017/09/viking-warrior-woman-archaeology-spd/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2017/09/viking-warri... > Since the remains were found alongside swords, arrowheads, a spear, and two sacrificed horses, archaeologists had considered it a warrior’s grave—and, thus, a man’s.
- mc32 6y agoEven with that possibility it’s ridiculous. It would require a conspiracy by archeologists (of both sexes) to only find male specimens (as if there are so many that they’d ignore female specimens just to be misogynistic. How realistic is that? It also primes the reader to think “aha misogyny!” where it isn’t. Just as saying fat free water!
- progval 6y agoRead the quote. It doesn't have to be intentional, they may assume some bodies are male when they aren't
- mc32 6y agoYes that was an _exception_ unless you believe all (or most) of the sex identity assignments of historical human skeletons are suspect.
- progval 6y agoThere are other examples of this. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/11/prehistoric-female-hunter-discovery-upends-gender-role-assumptions/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2020/11/prehistor... > it revealed that between 30 and 50 percent of big game hunters could have been biologically female. > This new study is the latest twist in a decades-long debate about gender roles among early hunter-gather societies. The common assumption was that prehistoric men hunted while women gathered and reared their young. But for decades, some scholars have argued that these “traditional” roles—documented by anthropologists studying hunter-gatherer groups across the globe since the 19th century—don’t necessarily stretch into our deep past. And that's just looking at the first hits on a search engine. Whether or not there is indeed a systemic bias in archeology, this makes it worth mentioning that in that case, we're sure it's not bias.
- posterboy 6y ago> saying fat free water! You keep repeating this as if fatty water were an entirely bizare notio. Suppose you heard of... milk? And militant vegans? And soy-milk? I haven't seen soy-milk claiming to be gluten free, but I have definitely seen many milk products claiming to be lactose free. And I'm bad at drawing analogies, because I don't know what drove the author. For sake of the argument I'd say that any investigation a male bias could be spun into into an investigation of male surpremacy. So your trying to claim male rhinoceros were better at dying, is it?!?
- Chris2048 6y ago> Suppose you heard of... milk? If milk was a type of water, this comment would make sense.
- phkahler 6y agoLater they offer this: >> This wasn’t a surprise, based on what Pečnerová had theorized about mammoth herd behavior, since bison social structure similarly isolates young males. “By [the mammoth] anology, some of the male bison are going off and doing stupid things,” Which could be interpreted as misandry even though they blame the males for their fate in the same sentence. :-)
- AnHonestComment 6y agoOkay — but they don’t talk about misandry, they talk about misogyny. Not even using the right word is misandry.
- mc32 6y agoMy complaint is the anthropomorphization of animals. Unless we know what drove animal behavior, we cannot make such attributions. It would be like saying dinosaurs raped each other. From a human perspective their mating behavior if we knew it might look negative, but we cannot attribute intent to animals like that.
- qeternity 6y ago> Why do they even have to say this Unfortunately, you and I both know why...
- Technically 6y agoPlease, do share!
- Technically 6y agoHow do you figure? Do you think misogyny is not real?
- tomjakubowski 6y agoIt's a joke.
- simias 6y agoFrankly I think you're reading what you want to read here. I get that those are hot button issues for many people but here I really think it's just a small joke because, as you point out, obviously the distribution of fossils has very little to do with gender politics. That being said if you want to take it more seriously sometime sexist bias does taint research in unexpected places, such as expecting that certain tools would've been used by males instead of females for no real reason for instance. It's important to be aware of these biases if you want to do good scientific work I think.
- coldtea 6y ago>That being said if you want to take it more seriously sometime sexist bias does taint research in unexpected places Similar to lets-discover-sexism-everywhere bias in social sciences though. In general soft sciences are prone to the ideology of the day (which is also what gets you grants)...
- bluntfang 6y ago>It kind of spoils the article. Man if that spoils an article for you, you must live a pretty miserable life. Not surprised a comment like this isn't dead on this site. It adds nothing to the discussion, and it seems like OP didn't even read the article and is flame baiting.