3 ms·
Something's wrong with all of the "deduce from patterns" answers in the article's comments. None of the patterns are deduced! It's definitely not an axiom that
by whatshisface 6y ago
Something's wrong with all of the "deduce from patterns" answers in the article's comments. None of the patterns are deduced! It's definitely not an axiom that an even number minus and even number is even; that would have to be proven from the definition of even-ness. The definition of even-ness is what decides whether or not zero is even. It would be equally coherent to define 0 to be even, or exempt from even-ness. An example of a definition where exemption would make sense would be to say that even numbers are those whose unique prime factorizations contain a factor of two. 0 is exempted from having a factorization, so exemption from even and odd would follow naturally. Whether or not 0 is even is a random accident of math history with at most a little justification from convenience. Nobody can be blamed for failing to deduce it because it cannot be deduced.
I think the people claiming that the right answer is obvious are making a mistake much more severe than the mistake made by people who guessed that zero was exempt. They are confusing the direction of reasoning by trying to prove axioms from conjectures by first assuming that their conjectures are theorems.
- wcarey 6y agoIndeed. And Euclid’s definition of evenness (Def VII.6) applies only to numbers, which for Euclid excludes both 0 and 1. So there’s at least one vaguely axiomatic formulation of number theory where the correct answer is probably “neither because it’s not the sort of object to which you can predicate evenness or oddness”.
- ColinWright 6y agoYes and no. You are right that the definition of even-ness is how we determine whether zero is even or not (by that definition). But there are reasons to choose one definition over another. Yes, you can choose to define zero to be exempt. But you can look at the patterns of numbers that are "obviously even" and observe that adding 2 to an even number results in an even number. So it's reasonable that subtracting 2 from an even number should result in an even number. That's not a definition, but it's a pattern to observe, and leads one to think that maybe defining zero to be even makes sense, and fits with existing patterns. You can define it how you like, but some definitions are more useful than others. That's why 1 is no longer considered to be prime, -1 is considered by some to be prime, and why even-ness is defined in such a way as to include zero. It creates fewer exceptions to general properties. It's more convenient, more useful, and simpler, than any of the alternatives. Patterns provide a reason to create the definition we use.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 6y agoNonetheless, the question in the twitter poll wasn't "how would you design the definition of even?" It was, essentially, "how did mathematicians, who may have made the decision hundreds of years ago for reasons you have not considered, define even-ness?" The first could be called an exercise in reasoning, the second is a call for memory.
- mlyle 6y agoThere are other reasons to exempt 0. But the use of the words "even" and "odd" isn't accidental: whether the number can be divided into an equal (even) number of elements or whether there is an odd element left out. When we are trying to figure out what can be encompassed in a term, the term's plain, non-mathematical meaning should be considered-- at the very least as a tiebreaker to equally valid definitions.