3 ms·
That sounds like a weasel word version of "we can detect vehicle warranty status without using PII."
by tyingq 6y ago
That sounds like a weasel word version of "we can detect vehicle warranty status without using PII."
- bagacrap 6y agoI think they're saying they can't even tell if it's actually out of warranty, ie if you did buy the extended warranty you'd still see the popup.
- smarx007 6y agoMost likely they figured out that they are about to violate GDPR and altered the code to also show the notice to those who bought the extended warranty. I cannot imagine execs spending so much money on a project to shame both those who bought an extended warranty and those who didn't. In that case you can just put a static printed ad for the warranty.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- avianlyric 6y agoYou can probably guess without using PII. In the UK numberplate info is public, you can look up the make, model year and colour of a car just using it's numberplate, and anyone can do this. Using that info it would be trivial to detect a BMW car that was older than X years old. Where X is number of years the normal non-extended warranty is. You then just assume that any car older than the non-extended warranty doesn't have an extended warranty and display the advert. Then the only thing the advert would be giving away is that there is a BMW nearby that older than X years. Which anyone with a pair of eyes could figure out because the numbers of UK numberplates encode the issue year (thus the age of the car), and well, BMW's are pretty easy to identify just by looking at them.
- itronitron 6y agoThey could also not do the numberplate look up and achieve the same end result by posting a billboard that just says 'Don't buy a BMW'
- floatingatoll 6y agoThe phrasing around "no vehicle data is stored or retained" implies that they're doing vehicle plate->VIN lookups in their database of cars manufactured and perhaps warranties issued, which as the manufacturer of said car they might well be correct to say that no PII is required. There's a missing piece of anti-targeting marketing legislation here, that GDPR won't cover under PII, even if it is eventually found that their plate lookup is a PII violation: Can the manufacturer of an object use their privately-held data about the object to target marketing to the bearer/operator/etc. of that object? Probably, yes, at least until a law is passed or a ruling is issued that states otherwise. The best short-term route of attack here would be on the plate->VIN conversion database, assuming that's what they're using anyways. But long-term, they'll figure out how to use a telephoto lens or LIDAR or paint-embedded QR codes to get VIN numbers somehow, so best to tackle the bigger problem too.