4 ms·
Most of the comments here are hung up about the accuracy or lack thereof of the saying hi observation, which is just the article's title and hook. I'm more curi
by Apocryphon 6y ago
Most of the comments here are hung up about the accuracy or lack thereof of the saying hi observation, which is just the article's title and hook. I'm more curious to see if anyone agrees with the author's point about the lack of intermixing in SF between people of different classes, and the seeming lack of urban social cohesion, unlike other cities such as NY or perhaps Boston ("Boston Strong").
Certainly, if one works in tech in SF, it's easy to get stuck in an industry bubble where the first questions strangers ask each other at social events is "oh who do you work for?" and it just becomes a parade of corporate logos, tech stack holy wars, weekend side projects, and comparing option offers.
- somethoughts 6y agoI think its also where the new transplants end up. They end up in the recently gentrified areas such as the Mission/Castro/Dolores due to affordability/closeness to the GBUS, etc. Being fairly adjacent to the Tenderloin/City Hall/Haight, people are generally going to have the guard up higher and you'll have more interaction with the folks who've been gentrified out. YMMV but if the author was in the more residential areas such as Marina/Cow Hollow/Inner Sunset/Noe Valley and jogged the same routes regularly, perhaps he'd have had a more small town interactions.
- jrockway 6y agoI am not sure we have a ton of social cohesion in New York necessarily. Among the well-to-do, sure, we're not only working in tech, but there is still the discomfort with there being many classes of people. (The gig economy killed any hope of there ever being a middle class again.) I think if you want people to say "hi" to you, you have to act the part. Some single 20-something walking around with headphones and a hoodie... nobody is going to talk to you. Get a dog and a partner, and people will talk to you while you're out walking the dog. They're walking their dog, and so you have something to talk about. (The dogs will break the ice!)
- Apocryphon 6y agoGranted, he's talking about something that's very subjective, but there does seem to be a popular conception of New Yorkers having a shared identity regardless of class- > There is certainly class separation and racial division in New York, but there is an inherent camaraderie to the city itself, a shared feeling that everyone is in the belly of the same vast urban beast. Of course, that could just be something unique after the collective trauma of 9/11 (and Hurricane Sandy, etc.). You see it in pop culture depictions- "this city sucks, but it's our city!" Again, getting random city dwellers to say hi to you is the opener of this article, it shouldn't be the last word that everyone fixates upon.
- raffraffraff 6y agoThe dog thing is so true. Are they a nice dog owner? Do they pull the dog along their own preferred route, staring at a their phone, getting annoyed when the dog stops to sniff? Do they yank on the leash? Or do they patiently allow their dog to take in the smells of the neighborhood and leave their own messages in return, let the dog change direction in response to a smell or sound? Do they allow their dog to meet other dogs, with the other owner's permission? (As my wife says "this isn't your walk, this is the dog's walk") Is this a responsible owner? How does their dog behaved around other dogs? If the dog misbehaves, how does the owner respond? Do they pick up after their dog? Bottom line: a dog is an excellent asshole-o-meter.
- c22 6y agoDo they leave a bag of their dog's shit in my freshly-emptied trash can (or worse, recycling bin) for me to smell all week after I wheel it back to my house? (All signs point to yes)
- c22 6y agoI assume the downvotes are coming from people who do this? Help me out, cause there's something I've always been curious about: If you are walking down the street drinking a Starbucks or eating a candy bar and you finish, do you leave the empty cup or wrapper in someone else's bin too? Genuinely curious... I've always brought my own garbage home with me, or to the next public bin. What do you do when it's not trash day?
- Barrin92 6y ago>unlike other cities such as NY or perhaps Boston ("Boston Strong") Yes, I do and I think it's as Noah mentions visible in transport, and unlike Noah I think it is closely related to the 'tech' mentality. I've been in SF but I live in London. Like NY, in London everyone uses the tube. Doesn't matter if you're rich or a poor sob, there is still public life and shared public space. SF feels, to use tech jargon, 'unbundled'. I have never met more classist people than Californian tech workers, who seem entirely unaware of their own classism to boot. The ideal world of the SF tech worker I think is an individual driving around in a driverless car (because that means they don't need to talk to the driver), ordering their food on Uber eats, having chats on clubhouse. And what's weird is how distinct this is from the finance driven culture of NY or London. The SF tech scene is also where I for the first time encountered people talking about 'unschooling' frequently, which is basically affluent people separating their kids from everyone else but they seemed to be convinced that this is very progressive. Despite folks in finance also making a lot of cash, I don't think I've ever met a trader in the city of London who unschooled their kid.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]