3 ms·
My point is that notebooks are not a development tool, so it makes no sense to criticize them from that perspective. Nobody is asking or even suggesting that yo
by nerdponx 6y ago
My point is that notebooks are not a development tool, so it makes no sense to criticize them from that perspective. Nobody is asking or even suggesting that you develop software in a notebook, and I haven't met anyone who does it.
Spyder and RStudio are very much not oriented toward traditional software development and very much oriented toward interactive work between the text editor window and the console/REPL window. That is, they are fancy implementations of the Editor+REPL workflow. The fact that you can develop software in that kind of environment is not the point.
- otabdeveloper4 6y ago> ...and I haven't met anyone who does it. Really? Developing software in Jupyter must be almost as common as the "just code an Excel macro bro" approach.
- BadInformatics 6y ago> Nobody is asking or even suggesting that you develop software in a notebook It doesn't have a huge audience at present, but https://nbdev.fast.ai/ https://nbdev.fast.ai/ is doing just that. I'm personally of the opinion that those looking to use notebooks as a programming environment would be better suited by something like Smalltalk. That is, something that seamlessly blends between stored programs and the runtime. You can see some progression towards this in VS Code (I believe there's an issue about exposing variables evaluated in the ipython REPL in autocomplete), so I'm not terribly bullish on Jupyter-style notebooks being the next big thing.