3 ms·
It makes no sense whatsoever to "compare" Web Authentication methods for humans in 2020 without even mentioning WebAuthn since that's literally why it's called
by tialaramex 6y ago
It makes no sense whatsoever to "compare" Web Authentication methods for humans in 2020 without even mentioning WebAuthn since that's literally why it's called WebAuthn (Web Authentication) and that's exactly what it's for.
In one sense this is bad news for this comparison, but it's also bad news for the general state of security on the web, because this item is 8 hours old and I'm writing this top level item now, which means for eight hours people who think of themselves as "web developers" didn't even ask "Why not WebAuthn?"
- PudgePacket 6y agoJust tried webauthn.io. Doesn't even work :/ I clicked register and it said "Use your security key now or cancel". What does that even mean? What's a security key? Is it a setting in my browser? I have lastpass installed, can it use that? Is it supposed to integrate with the Mac keychain somehow? Gave me no options but cancel. Pretty underwhelming if that's the future of web auth..
- tialaramex 6y agoA Security Key is a physical object. For example here are some reviews by tech press people: https://www.zdnet.com/article/best-security-key/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/best-security-key/ https://www.wired.co.uk/article/best-security-keys https://www.wired.co.uk/article/best-security-keys Or here's an actual expert writing about them a few years ago if you suspect "tech press people" are worthless: https://www.imperialviolet.org/2018/03/27/webauthn.html https://www.imperialviolet.org/2018/03/27/webauthn.html Or, more practically, if you have a nice phone, try visiting it on that. If it's a relatively modern iPhone or high end Android with a touch sensor running the current OS version you can use that. Since you mentioned Mac keychain, if your Mac has TouchID that will work on the current OS (in Safari at least) too. Some Windows PCs with fingerprint sensors likewise.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoIsn't biometric authentication just a huge password reuse that you can't even stop?
- tialaramex 6y agoSure. But biometric authentication for WebAuthn or the related mechanisms built into iOS and Android themselves only takes place on your device. So at the extreme to "stop" you can just replace that device, I understand most people do that every few years anyway. WebAuthn doesn't end up with a third party (say, Facebook) having biometric data, what they've got is just a public key and an identifier. Your device is signing to say it checked you are still you, whoever that is. It does not promise how it did that and there's no reason a web site would care. Your biometric data (if that's how you authenticate) is only needed by your device, to verify this is still you when it makes that claim. So any changes (e.g. you decide to use your other hand) are a local device problem, no need to tell any third parties anything interesting happened.
- webstrand 6y agoI think that's a bit uncharitable. WebAuthn isn't terribly useful right now simply because most users lack hardware tokens. And from a backend services perspective, which the article seems to take, there's no good place to install hardware tokens for cloud services. If you own the physical server, only then does WebAuthn provide advantages. I hope that someday, users can just plug their phone into their computer and use it as a security token.