3 ms·
There's more than one counter-case to rationalism. Atheists, liberals, Democrats, progressives can all be irrational or pseudo-rational. What would pseudo-rat
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
There's more than one counter-case to rationalism. Atheists, liberals, Democrats, progressives can all be irrational or pseudo-rational.
What would pseudo-rationalism even be? Purported rationalism, yes, but the rationalism would be just a smokescreen for positions that are not rationally derived and therefore not addressable by means of rational argument.
I don't understand why you think asocialism or self-interest is the opposite of rationalism. I think that's on an orthogonal axis.
- ggm 6y agoI guess because I see secular humanism as being rooted in a rationalist outlook, and the a-social claimed rationality of the Ayn Rand rugged individualists just leaves me cold, as does most libertarian rejections of society and social equity, collectivism to me is the highest form of rationalism.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI note that your rejection of Ayn Rand's philosophy is that it "leaves you cold", rather than a rational refutation of it. Ayn Rand begins with axioms, and logically derives her position from there. (Well, maybe. I suspect that at least to some degree, she already had her position, and derived her axioms from there, then argued for her position from her axioms.) So I attack her position by saying that in her third axiom, she mis-defines consciousness, and the rest of her errors follow from her flawed starting position. That's rational. "It leaves me cold" is not a rational response. (It may be an indication that you feel there's something wrong with the position, even if you can't define it or prove it, and that's fine. But it's not a rational response.)
- gxnxcxcx 6y agoOne may argue that the deliberate communicative act of expressively sharing feelings by means of articulated language may very well be a rational response by itself, as long as it's driven by a thoughtful enough intention. Even if at the same time it's fully void of rationalist value. (Sorry if it comes across overly pedantic and twisted: non-native speaker, not enough sleep, words hard.)
- coldtea 6y ago>Ayn Rand begins with axioms, and logically derives her position from there. There's no way to arrive "logically" at value judgements. You can just use logic as a klutch to support your pre-determined positions (and, of course, which is totally rational as a practice, to spread, support and enforce them).
- alisonkisk 6y agohttp://www.andrej.com/objectivism/ http://www.andrej.com/objectivism/ is a beautiful work from an expert in rational thinking.
- coldtea 6y agoNot so sure about the actual rationality of this. E.g.: "Things are what they are. There is only one reality, namely the way things are." That's only true for the least interesting things: objects and their arrangements in space-time. On that, the huge majority (besides maybe crazy people) agrees anyway, when they see them, or when they're given evidence of them (e.g. a photo of a laptop on a desk. 99.999% of the people will agree there's a laptop on a desk there). For anything else, politics, values, claims and the veracity of claims, morality, motives, aesthetics, goals, etc., there is no single way things are, there are ways people perceive them, and there are different interets, worldviews, and ways of interpreting them. What is the "reality" or "non-reality" of "I'm willing to die for my country"? Or of "I find it OK to make money stealing"? Or "You should treat people well even if you are not forced to|?
- slothtrop 6y agoRight, there's a difference between rationalizing and being rational.
- mcguire 6y agoWhy do you attack her position? Because you fundamentally, a priori, believe her third axiom is wrong, or because the collection of axioms and conclusions "leaves you cold" and the third axiom is a key place you find to disagree with her reasoning?
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoBecause I didn't think her conclusions were right, and because her system is laid out logically enough that I could trace through and find out where I thought it went wrong.
- stass 6y agoCollectivism killed hundreds of million of people in the past century alone. This was also rationalized. Rugged individualism is much less a-social from that perspective.
- coldtea 6y ago>Collectivism killed hundreds of million of people in the past century alone. So? The western states killed and enslaved just as many under various names (from christianity and manifest destiny, to democracy and free trade and "the free world"). What happened in the name of an idea doesn't mean the idea is bad or that what happened is an inevitable part of the idea.
- fao_ 6y ago> What would pseudo-rationalism even be? Purported rationalism, yes, but the rationalism would be just a smokescreen for positions that are not rationally derived and therefore not addressable by means of rational argument. Such as Yudkowsky believing that torturing a man for 50 years is ok if it means that a very large number of people don't get a single speck of dust in their eye? Or the creator of Roko's Baselisk openly stating recently on twitter that he wants "Traditional Futurism" ("Traditional" being a traditional (heh) dogwhistle for the alt-right https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Traditional_values https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Traditional_values)
- coldtea 6y agoOr the irrational idea of a "dog-whistle" making this a thought-crime to discuss. Because, "of course", "rationally" nobody other than a fascist or such would care for tradition and traditional values or use such terms positively. Only whether you're traditionalist or progressivist or whatever is a value judgement and a world-view, not something to put as rational or irrational. Those that say the opposite irattionally impose their value/preferences as "rational reason".
- fao_ 6y agoDid you actually go and read his tweets, or are you arguing on principle with no knowledge of what I am talking about?
- coldtea 6y agoI'm not talking (nor care) about whether some particular person (Roko Basilisk'd creator or whoever) is right-wing or not. I'm commenting on the argument in your comment, about "Traditional" being a traditional (heh) dogwhistle for the alt-right". He could be to the right of Hitler, and the argument could still be wrong. (I guess now you can write "I figured as much", and dismiss my comment, as if the particular and not the principle is what's important).
- fao_ 6y ago
- nullc 6y agoPseudo-rationalism is the construction of elaborate rationalizations for your biases and hot-takes while convincing yourself that the considered disagreement of others means you are fundamentally more intelligent and adept in the ways of reasoning. Bonus points for obfuscating your positions with in-group jargon and mathematical terminology that you don't actually understand. Nattering on about 'Bayesian priors' won't make you any more effective at reasoning than coconut headphones will help land airplanes, but it might keep people from challenging your ideas. If it does so because they've written you off as a fool or because you've successfully snowed them, you'll never know.
- mcguire 6y ago"What would pseudo-rationalism even be? Purported rationalism, yes, but the rationalism would be just a smokescreen for positions that are not rationally derived and therefore not addressable by means of rational argument." The fundamental question of philosophy: how do you tell a rationally derived belief from an irrationally derived belief?
- Viliam1234 6y ago> how do you tell a rationally derived belief from an irrationally derived belief? The former, I could change, given enough data. The latter, I am willing to die for (or rather, attack other people for). However, I could change it after hanging out with different people for long time.