5 ms·
Cultivate compassion for people trapped in dogma-driven politics, whether religious or secular dogma. Or did you mean "dogma held with religious fervor/intensi
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
Cultivate compassion for people trapped in dogma-driven politics, whether religious or secular dogma.
Or did you mean "dogma held with religious fervor/intensity"? If so, I will agree with you. People hold political views the way they used to hold religion, and it has not improved politics...
- ggm 6y agoReally, I was just responding to the prior. They drove the pseudo-rationalist line. I do think there is a toxic culture in rationalism, but I tend to blame it on neoliberal economic reductionism, or libertarianism. I don't think rationalism per se is at the root of it, pseudo-rationalism, what would that even be? purported rationalism but actually.. over-arching asocialism? self interest? Anyway, I saw religiosity as the counter-case to rationalism.
- earwaxauditor 6y agoDavid Hume is an empiricist. Noam Chomsky is more of rationalist. LessWrong-rationalism is just crackpottery. This brings to mind a review of Stephen Hicks “Explaining Postmodernism”. In the book he contrasts postmodernism with objectivism: postmodernists are irrational while objectivists are rational. And once you look long enough at the comparison tables you realize that there is no philosophy there; it’s just “bad thing” v.s. “good thing”. Kind of like “rationalism”, that obvious good thing. Who wouldn’t want to be rational? What’s our philosophy? Uh, to be rational? To be for good things and against bad things? Hence your indignation at putting pseudo in front of that word: how could one possibly object to something called rationalism? Hello, it’s in the name—rationalism! It’s about being rational. What more do you want, Jack? “Per se”... And nice touch with the but-religion-though. That was a zinger.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoThere's more than one counter-case to rationalism. Atheists, liberals, Democrats, progressives can all be irrational or pseudo-rational. What would pseudo-rationalism even be? Purported rationalism, yes, but the rationalism would be just a smokescreen for positions that are not rationally derived and therefore not addressable by means of rational argument. I don't understand why you think asocialism or self-interest is the opposite of rationalism. I think that's on an orthogonal axis.
- ggm 6y agoI guess because I see secular humanism as being rooted in a rationalist outlook, and the a-social claimed rationality of the Ayn Rand rugged individualists just leaves me cold, as does most libertarian rejections of society and social equity, collectivism to me is the highest form of rationalism.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI note that your rejection of Ayn Rand's philosophy is that it "leaves you cold", rather than a rational refutation of it. Ayn Rand begins with axioms, and logically derives her position from there. (Well, maybe. I suspect that at least to some degree, she already had her position, and derived her axioms from there, then argued for her position from her axioms.) So I attack her position by saying that in her third axiom, she mis-defines consciousness, and the rest of her errors follow from her flawed starting position. That's rational. "It leaves me cold" is not a rational response. (It may be an indication that you feel there's something wrong with the position, even if you can't define it or prove it, and that's fine. But it's not a rational response.)
- gxnxcxcx 6y agoOne may argue that the deliberate communicative act of expressively sharing feelings by means of articulated language may very well be a rational response by itself, as long as it's driven by a thoughtful enough intention. Even if at the same time it's fully void of rationalist value. (Sorry if it comes across overly pedantic and twisted: non-native speaker, not enough sleep, words hard.)
- coldtea 6y ago>Ayn Rand begins with axioms, and logically derives her position from there. There's no way to arrive "logically" at value judgements. You can just use logic as a klutch to support your pre-determined positions (and, of course, which is totally rational as a practice, to spread, support and enforce them).
- 6y ago