3 ms·
Impressive monumental structures like that have been built. The Albany Mall, New York,[1] Nelson Rockefeller's monument to brutalism, probably comes closest. Th
by Animats 6y ago
Impressive monumental structures like that have been built. The Albany Mall, New York,[1] Nelson Rockefeller's monument to brutalism, probably comes closest. The Raj Path in New Delhi is similar, built huge on purpose to intimidate the populace.
Sheer size to impress has gone out of fashion, since building very large structures isn't a big deal any more. Huge convention centers, air terminals, malls, and stadiums are normal now, and don't impress people much.
[1] https://earth.google.com/web/@42.6489482,-73.7611536,51.20615875a,0d,60.39003113y,31.55121449h,101.83203331t,0r https://earth.google.com/web/@42.6489482,-73.7611536,51.2061...
- trianglem 6y agoI don’t think sheer size to impress can truly go out of fashion since that sense of awe transcends topical sensibilities. It’s probably just not cost effective so no one does it. Huge buildings now are built out of light, transparent materials and part of being awed by scale requires the large building to be built out of solid, impenetrable feeling material like stone.
- Ancapistani 6y agoExactly. We build lots of big buildings now, but “big” is not the same as “massive”.
- pjc50 6y agoFor this kind of thing, the cost is part of the point made.
- trgn 6y agoRather than comparing it to the authoritarian architecture of the postwar period (which was horrible), I think it's more fair to point out the actual inspiration for Speer. It was the City Beautiful movement and the existing examples of grand boulevards in imperial capitals. That main boulevard he envisioned lined by monuments and institutions of great importance was a German equivalent of basically Philadelphia's Franklin parkway or Paris' Champs-Elysees. Philadelphia razed entire city neighborhoods only decades earlier to build it. In fact, an almost identical vision to Speer's Berlin already existed. It was Washington DC. On a smaller scale, dozens of other cities had already embarqued on similar projects, Brussels Parc du Cinquantenaire is another on, or Budapest's parliament building and Heroes' Square. Germany was playing catch-up to what was fairly mundane practice. The only thing that gives pause is perhaps the Volkshalle, which has a little too much of a mine-is-bigger vibe when putting it next to DC's congress building.