3 ms·
> Due to the signed system volume, doing so is now impossible without disabling system integrity protection, one of the main platform security features of macOS
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> Due to the signed system volume, doing so is now impossible without disabling system integrity protection, one of the main platform security features of macOS.
No, macOS is fine without SIP! SIP just defines a set of actions that Apple thinks no user, including root, should ever be able to perform. Consequently, disabling SIP empowers root users to do whatever they want, which is exactly what root is supposed to mean! You're still protected by the standard UNIX permission system—just don't grant root to software you don't absolutely trust!
Security is all about layers—but in the case of SIP, the security comes from delegating control away from the user in favor of Apple. If you're a power user, I'm not convinced this is necessarily good, because you're giving Apple almost absolute trust. What if they get compromised?
And, if you're the sort of person who would want a de-Apple-ified version of macOS, I would think you'd have already disabled SIP.
- sneak 6y ago> No, macOS is fine without SIP! SIP just defines a set of actions that Apple thinks no user, including root, should ever be able to perform. I agree with Apple here. > Consequently, disabling SIP empowers root users to do whatever they want, without Apple having a say in the matter—but you're still protected by the standard UNIX permission system. It also empowers malware. The Creative Cloud, for example, installs as root and installs admin-permissioned services. The standard POSIX permissions system is crap, and SIP is a huge improvement and valuable tool against malware.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> The Creative Cloud, for example, installs as root and installs admin-permissioned services. So don't use apps that do that! Creative Cloud has no business installing itself as root. I realize that's probably not feasible if you e.g. need Creative Cloud professionally, and that's a perfectly valid reason to leave SIP on, if applicable. Although Adobe and similar vendors still need to be yelled at. I think SIP—like Gatekeeper—is a great default setting for novices, who should trust Apple over themselves. But if you're a power user, turning off SIP is not going to spell disaster. It leaves you with equivalent security to most Linux distros like Debian. More importantly, there's no way to have a feature like SIP while also granting users full control. I get really frustrated when I see people say they're switching to Linux because macOS is too locked down. If you want to switch to Linux, that's wonderful, Linux is great! But if you otherwise prefer macOS, just go ahead and open it up for yourself.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arvinsim 6y ago> I get really frustrated when I see people say they're switching to Linux because macOS is too locked down. Perhaps they are not referring to just permissions. Maybe how the system as a whole is setup.
- sneak 6y ago> It leaves you with equivalent security to most Linux distros like Debian. This is why I don't run desktop Linux, either. That's not a good security model.