3 ms·
I agree that both the original post and the media coverage of this is extremely misleading. > So someone enthusiastically posted about wasting their time as if
by woodruffw 6y ago
I agree that both the original post and the media coverage of this is extremely misleading.
> So someone enthusiastically posted about wasting their time as if it was a technological achievement.
I think there's plenty of value and achievement in understanding a program's functionality, even when the source is fully available to you.
We all (presumably) agree that source code isn't self-documenting and that understanding someone else's work usually involves a lot of individual comprehension and context; I read this blog post as someone (diligently) describing their mental process as they tried to understand Signal's internal formats. As others have pointed out, there are oodles of "legitimate"[1] reasons for doing so.
[1]: From the perspective of LEO and the legal system, anyways.
- thedanbob 6y agoI agree as far as the content of the article is concerned. I think the main problem with it was its tone. I think if they had approached it the way you described, someone just going into detail about how they analyzed an unfamiliar application, it would have been fine. As written, it feels like a new programmer bragging to his friends about how he got "hello, world" to compile.
- polar 6y agoOne has to bear in mind that the typical digital forensic examiner is not a programmer and would therefore be impressed. Perhaps impressed enough to purchase Cellebrite's products instead of the equivalents from MSAB, Oxygen, Elcomsoft etc.