The original post you replied to said: > since we don't have currently good way to use our health data for health purposes It's difficult to share Fitbit data

The original post you replied to said: > since we don't have currently good way to use our health data for health purposes It's difficult to share Fitbit data with my primary care doctor. I think this statement describes that situation well (and beyond). And Fitbit data is clearly health data. And nobody has claimed it's for "healthcare in a clinical setting". I think you're beating a straw man you've constructed.