4 ms·
> I'm not judging them I don't understand - what is the point of you interviewing them if you aren't there to judge them? What are you doing it for then?
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> I'm not judging them
I don't understand - what is the point of you interviewing them if you aren't there to judge them? What are you doing it for then?
- hnrodey 6y agoTrying to understand their thought process, is the candidate coachable, can the candidate accept feedback, does the candidate at least understand the underlying ideas, etc. The more prestigious the employer then the less forgiving they are on your shortcomings.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> is the candidate coachable, can the candidate accept feedback, does the candidate at least understand the underlying ideas ...isn't that judging? Making a judgement on whether a candidate is coachable is judging isn't it?
- hnrodey 6y agoApologies are due, sir. Two things happened. First, I hastily read through the question and rushed my response. Second, just a few minutes prior I finished a workout and was quite exasperated. The use of the term "not judging" is a bit strange, without further context.
- jlokier 6y agoThe word "judging" has multiple variant meanings. It is being used to mean two different things in this subthread. Judging whether a candidate is coachable, their thought processes relevant to the job, understands the ideas etc is what the interview is for, you're right. But "I'm not judging" doesn't refer to that. It refers instead to the concept in the word "judgemental". Some definitions of that are "having or displaying an overly critical point of view" and "thinking, speaking, or behaving in a manner that reflects a critical and condemnatory point of view".
- closeparen 6y agoWhen a candidate bombs an interview, I don't think "wow, what a shitty engineer, how are they even employed?" I think, "wow, interviewing sucks."
- chrisseaton 6y agoWhy bother interviewing if you aren’t learning anything about the person but only about how bad your interviews are?
- closeparen 6y agoThere are several hills I would strongly consider dying on, but interview reform is not one of them.
- symlinkk 6y agoSo you’re not going to answer the question I guess?
- closeparen 6y agoYou get classroom training, shadow hours, supervised hours, and certification on a particular type of interview. From that day forward any open slot on your calendar is fair game for Recruiting to schedule, up to 3 per week. You might get away with a "No" RSVP if you have a good excuse, but not in general. It's part of your job.
- shemnon42 6y agoThree a week? What SVP did your group piss off? Or are they back to the 4 rejects per hire game?
- closeparen 6y agoIt was like that during hyper growth and also during massive attrition in tougher times. Now it’s more like 0-1.
- darkerside 6y agoI think one of the biggest problems we have today is that we use the same word for estimating or evaluating a characteristic or ability of a person, as we do for evaluating the person themselves. I am evaluating your ability to perform this complex task in this situation, and it has nothing to do with my value for you as a person. You may not care whether I value you as a person, but at that point, that's your problem and not mine. I'm not even exaggerating, I believe this is a major source of strife in modern societies.