7 ms·
Something I highly recommend avoiding (though it may look tempting) is the TB16 thunderbolt dock from dell. There is something really screwy with the USB contr
by dijit 6y ago
Something I highly recommend avoiding (though it may look tempting) is the TB16 thunderbolt dock from dell.
There is something really screwy with the USB controller in that device, the ETH is on the USB hub and corrupts Ethernet frames, under Linux you can force disable hardware offloaded CRC checksumming as a workaround, but still the USB devices that are directly connected can just stop functioning.
It also has the annoying quirk that it enumerates the display ports differently each time, which means your operating system has almost no chance of redrawing your desktop when you plug it back in.
Looks good on the spec sheet though, and will probably be flooding the used market as companies try to offload them. I tried 5 different ones from different batches, they all had the same characteristics.
Didn’t try the WD19 yet, but I hope that’s better.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThat's a bummer to hear; I have the WD15 dock through work and it's been excellent; I have a bunch of complaints about the XPS itself (power management, for example), but that dock has been great.
- ianai 6y agoFor the prices, these docks have no excuse for bad behavior.
- gumby 6y agoI dunno, TB is basically a mass of high frequency analog madness with long cables thrown into the mix. I, kind of astonished that it works at all, at any price.
- mmcnl 6y agoI also have a WD15 and it works very well. Connecting everything with one cable is a very nice feature. It's a USB-C dock though, and not Thunderbolt.
- alcidesfonseca 6y agoI have the WD15 connected to a 2016 MacBook Pro and it is incredibly unreliable. USB devices stop working randomly (mouse+keyboard), ethernet comes and goes as it pleases and the display output works for one month before stops working all together. The only thing that works reliably is power supply.
- test1235 6y agoI can echo this - our company runs off dell machines and our laptops came with these docks. Despite (in happier times) having to leave my desk frequently for meetings, with my laptop, I'd rather faff about with plugging and unplugging multiple cables than have to deal with the frustration of peripherals randomly losing connection while you're in the middle of working.
- MrMid 6y agoI have the WD19TB and it is great. I've never had problems with it, though Dell updates its firmware frequently, so it seems they are still tuning it.
- bionade24 6y agoI do have it, too and I have to say despite it's being a fucking computer on its own it works astonishingly well under Linux, especially compared to the docking stations I had before. Feels like they really cared about their Linux support. Tested with both my XPS 9310 and my Precision 7530.
- arnmac 6y agoI had tons of problems with my TB16 and one prior Dell dock but the WD19 has been working flawlessly all year. I have used it with my XPS 7550 and 7590 and had no problems. I also have had good experience using it with a MacBook Pro 15.
- v4nd0ck 6y agoI started with the TB16 but after finding all these things out I actually switched to the TB15 and had much more success with that.
- gspr 6y agoHold on! Is this why ethernet is exhibiting intermittent and impossible to diagnose behavior for me at work, and only for me?! Do you have some more information?
- MichaelZuo 6y agoWhat is typically called ‘ethernet’ is actually a family of interrelated protocols. Correct implementations are costly since they require quality components and fine-tuning between hardware, firmware, and software levels. Most consumer products just use generic components that some factory negotiators were willing to offload for cheap. The high end products with megabucks contracts are the ones capable of hitting guaranteed reliability targets. Apple, like for most other components, is the only big consumer brand that consistently uses something better than whatever was cheapest in Shenzhen. Even business oriented brands, like Western Digital, Brother, etc., have been cutting costs in these areas recently for their cheapest lines. Boutique smaller brands like CalDigit, Lacie, etc., who justify their premium pricing with quality, also usually puts effort into doing it correctly.
- lloeki 6y ago> the ETH is on the USB hub and corrupts Ethernet frame I have a USB-C Novoo thingy (PD passthrough, HDMI, 3x USB-A, Ethernet) that might do something like that. If I plug Ethernet into my home router it ends up killing all other ethernet links on this router in about two minutes. I unplug it and things come back to life in under a second. The thing also has a habit to produce EM interference that makes WiFi useless. Would you believe, running a ping and wrapping the device's cord in tin foil back and forth and you can see the packet stop dropping and start again. Crazy.
- cat199 6y agoiogear usb-C -> 3x USB+ethernet - had the same EM interference with a MacBookPro, ended up wrapping the cable in an antistatic bag fragment, and good to go..
- tda 6y agoRecently wasted a morning at the office swapping all variants of Dell thunderbolt and USB-c docks, kept getting weird USB errors. Most frustrating was I couldn't reproduce the error at the helpdesk with same dock. The weirdest thing was usb peripherals were working fine, but somehow Windows kept giving me a non suppressable popup every minute ad infinitum. I don't see the point of docking stations anymore now you can get 49" screens with USB-c connectors. No reason to put a docking station in between or dual screen setups anymore
- GordonS 6y agoAlso avoid the HP Thunderbolt Dock - was a steaming pile that is! On 2 identical laptops (fresh builds), 1 of them BSODs, the other works sometimes, but BSODs at random when resuming from sleep or plugging in devices. They've releases various versions of the firmware, along with various versions of various drivers that need to be installed on the laptop. Only some random variations of these work, and only on some devices, and only some of the time. Total garbage.
- other_herbert 6y agoI have this dock.. I basically just use it for the power and DisplayPort to a 4k60 display... since USB is awful on it I have a USB hub I plug in to the notebook also... So I guess calling that thing a “dock” is generous
- 0xTJ 6y agoI was really impressed with the Dell WD19TB dock I was issued from work for COVID. I had never used a dock before, but having all my external displays (I used 2 DP, but I think it could handle 3 at once if using HDMI too), Ethernet, all the USB, and charging all through one port was amazing.
- bionade24 6y agoI have the WD19 and I have to say despite it's being a fucking computer on its own it works astonishingly well under Linux, especially compared to the docking stations I had before. Feels like they really cared about their Linux support. Tested with both my XPS 9310 and my Precision 7530.
- bionade24 6y agoIf you want to answer they have to because they sell Linux preinstalled: Their Ubuntu is garbage. If you setup Archlinux on your own, some features which haven't worked before will work, for example backlight oder hw acceleration. Still better than Lenovo telling it's a feature to not setup proprietairy Linux drivers on devices who need them.
- eulers_secret 6y agoI have a 9310, and the stock Ubuntu was OK. The biggest issue is thermald was older and limited the frequency boosting (so lower perf). I run 20.10 now with thermald master and kernel 5.10.1 (includes patches which enable pc10 sleep states and 400mhz cpu idle speed). Now it boosts and idles appropriately. What’s “backlight oder hw acceleration” are you referring to refresh rate or something like PSR? I want to know if it’s something I need to check on my 9310...
- pizza234 6y ago"oder" is "or" in German, so I think they meant "backlight or hw acceleration". I own a more recent Dell XPS 13, and the keyboard backlight support is indeed buggy - it needs a configuration patch to prevent it from turning on on logon. Not sure what's exactly the hw acceleration. If they refer to the Intel integrated GPUs, the configuration is pretty much standard; up to 18.04 the only thing I needed to configure was the VSync (this was the same also for other laptops), but with 20.04, I didn't need anymore.
- OakNinja 6y agoTried loads of TB docks (as well as USB3 ones) and gave up. They all have annoying quirks. I finally settled with a Razer Core Chroma, with Ethernet and USB. My MBP16 is finally silent with external displays, and the offloading really helps during video calls.
- neodymiumphish 6y agoI had the original Razer core right when it launched. Razer did an excellent job with their eGPU TB3 enclosures. In my case, a firmware update made the USB ports practically unusable, and I eventually got Razer to accept it as a return, but I'm eventually going to go with them and their future iterations of the Core once I get a laptop that supports TB3/4.
- NwtnsMthd 6y agoI can second this! The TB16 works alright after updating it to the newest firmware, but still has it's quirks. For example, my mouse lags / cuts out briefly, now and then (I plug it in direct). The TB19 I use when working from home appears to have little to no issues (none that I can think of right now).
- Bud 6y agoI support a LOT of Thunderbolt docks for clients in my IT work and have also had experience with a lot of them personally. My feedback is, almost all of these docks really suck. Spend the money and get a CalDigit. You won't regret it. It's the only one I've found that reliably performs the way a dock should.
- vxNsr 6y agoissue with caldigit is that it only has one dp out, wd19 has 2, and an hdmi. my optimal dock would have/support: 3 video out (dp, hdmi, etc) 5+ usb-a (2.0 is fine) 2+ usb-c (3.2 preferred) gigEth
- swiftcoder 6y agoThe CalDigit only has one dedicated DisplayPort, but you can also plug a USB-C to DisplayPort cable into the outgoing ThunderBolt port - I had dual 4k60 monitors running for a while that way.
- gumby 6y agoDaisy chain is supposed to work for two monitors, but I don’t know if it ever has in the wild. I believe it’s mandatory for TB4
- swiftcoder 6y agoDisplayPort daisy chain is specifically unsupported by Mac OS since forever. If you dual-boot an Intel Mac to Windows (via BootCamp) it'll daisy chain just fine, so the hardware supports it, but booted to Mac it'll just ignore the second monitor in the chain. If you are lucky enough to own a Thunderbolt (note: not displayport) monitor, that can chain to a displayport monitor. But thunderbolt monitors are rare as all get out these days.
- Bud 6y agoIt's only on PCs that it doesn't work properly, because PC makers suck and never bothered to be honest about implementing Thunderbolt 3 properly. They didn't even tell the truth about it. That's why we have this utter silliness called "Thunderbolt 4". All Thunderbolt 4 is, is Thunderbolt 3, but actually implemented properly, with no wiggle room for chintzy PC makers to weasel out.
- vxNsr 6y agoYup, we had a good venting session at our Dell rep about this issue last year. They were very aware of the issues, very apologetic and suggested we try some sorta displaylink garbage in the meantime. We did, and then as soon as the WD19 came out we tested that, and it's been night and day. They still require custom drivers but 99% of issues disappeared. I had one issue with a laptop that likely had a faulty tb module and was failing back to usb 3.1 but no other complaints from anyone. Well aside from the lack of usb ports on the thing... the Eport had like 8 usbs, the wd16 had 5 and now we're down to 3 on the wd19, that'd be fine if the laptops didn't keep dropping usb-a's also, most of the 7000 line only has 2 now. I refuse to get a usb dock to plug into the wd19 just for usb, that's insane and I'm not a crazy person.
- 908B64B197 6y agoI wish Microsoft would open-source their magnetic Surface Connector. It Just Works with a dock, period. They made an USB-C adapter if you want to try out the buggy Thunderbolt/USB-C ecosystem.
- glangdale 6y agoI've used the WD19. I haven't experimented with Linux, but it's a pretty screwy device. A firmware update meant that it stopped playing "which device is going to work today" lucky dip, but it is always a festival of that Windows "hey, something interesting happened at a hardware level" noise as it takes 10 seconds and 3-4 redraws of the whole screen to finally figure out where all the displays are. It's workable on PC and Mac, but I don't love it.
- dghughes 6y agoI've had two jobs both government (not US) those WDx docks are terrible. The connector is a two inch lever just waiting for something to break it off.
- arcticbull 6y agoPersonally I disagree, I love my WD19TB. It's hooked up to all my peripherals and monitor, and until a proper TB3 KVM comes into existence, I plug it into my laptop or desktop as needed. Nice to be able to swap a single plug and get full speed everything.
- dghughes 6y agoI'm referring to the sheer volume of calls I got to replace or update or reset the docks. It was probably in the top three of calls I would get maybe even #1.