4 ms·
So, the main claim is “By transferring the ownership of the ISA to RISC-V International, the original developers of the ISA have assured its longevity.” So, wh
by Someone 6y ago
So, the main claim is “By transferring the ownership of the ISA to RISC-V International, the original developers of the ISA have assured its longevity.”
So, what prevents that association from selling the IP? Reading the articles of that association (https://riscv.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Certified-copy-of-articles-of-RISC-V-International-Association.pdf https://riscv.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/Certified-copy-...), there must be at least 5 board members appointed by different companies and individual members, so that seems good. It also says the general meeting cannot decide to merge into an entity with largely different goals. I don’t see anything forbidding the sale of IP, though (and the board is explicitly in control of that), and couldn’t figure out whether the board can lock out non-members from using the ISA, prevent companies from becoming members, etc.
Also, as is common with these kinds of associations, it is geared towards companies (premier and strategic members each appoint a director in the board, while all individuals combined appoint 2 others)
My (IANAL) overall judgment from cursory reading is that it looks fine, but isn’t 100% bombproof.
(I also noticed that site is using https://sso.linuxfoundation.org/login https://sso.linuxfoundation.org/login, but doesn’t seem to mention any link between those organizations. Is there any?)
- skissane 6y ago> My (IANAL) overall judgment from cursory reading is that it looks fine, but isn’t 100% bombproof. Nothing is "100% bombproof". They probably don't want to clog up their articles of association with detailed limitations which might not be needed and which might get in the way of doing useful things in tune with their original purpose. Keeping the association true to its original purpose is really up to people and culture, not legal terms. I'm pretty sure lawyers (which I am not) would advise to keep details out unless they really need to be there, too many detailed rules can just add to legal uncertainty (doubts over exactly what they mean) and risk (lawsuits if someone thinks you've violated them, or if they were accidentally violated due to oversight or difficulty in understanding them, etc).