6 ms·
Tesla Mania vs. Economic Reality
- gwbas1c 6y agoRemember, Tesla does more than sell cars. Their grid-connected batteries are extremely profitable. A quick skim of the article makes no mention of Tesla's other businesses.
- simonh 6y agoThey're extremely profitable, but they still contribute to Tesla profits and Tesla revenue that are factored into the P/E, and are still tiny in comparison to the current valuation.
- mewpmewp2 6y agoCurrent valuation prices in future potential. And it's logical for it to do so. It's irrational to look at P/E and determine a company's value based on that. Here's a thought experiment. It's not a realistic one and is not supposed to prove that Tesla is not overvalued, but just out of interest, I'd like to see some responses. How would you value a company that has $10,000 profit this year and is expected to grow in profit 50% each following year and this growth would last infinitely? What about a company that is expected to grow 50% each year until $1T profit?
- simonh 6y agoI don't think anyone here has argued that possible future value can't override current P/E in principle. I'm certainly not arguing that. It's pretty obvious and well established. It's even possible Tesla will eventually improve it's P/E ratio by at least 50x to reach a more typical figure. That's also quite plausible, after all the big car giants now weren't always world dominating conglomerates. No problem there either from me. Where I think the current valuation departs from reality is the time it is likely to take to do that, and the risk that it won't happen at all. The current valuation only makes sense if that 50x ramp up in scale is pretty much guaranteed (not 10x, not 20x, but 50x at least) and will also happen in a few years. Technically they could be betting that the growth will be a lot more even than that, far bigger than the current entire car market, but with increased risk I suppose. I don't think that's what's happening though. What's actually happening is these recent investors over the last 6 months have simply bet that the Tesla share price will shoot up in the near terms and they'll be able to flip the stock to turn a rapid profit, and they've been right. They've made no bet at all on Tesla's long term prospects. That's why Elon tweeted a few months ago that he thought the stock was over-valued.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- webinvest 6y agoPEG Ratio
- coldcode 6y agoIt's doesn't matter. Tesla's stock price is around 450 times its cash flow, which is an order of magnitude beyond insane for a public company. Apple is around 30. The average S&P500 company is around 15. For Tesla's stock to be worth the same relative to the company's business as Apple the stock should be 15X less than it is now. To justify this price they would have to sell 15X more vehicles. Apple's gross margins are like 30%, cars are probably just a few % due to the complexity of making something as big as a car. Unless Tesla becomes the only seller of cars in the world, there is no way it will ever be worth the current price.
- davedx 6y agoCan you provide a citation for that 450x cash flow statement please?
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoTesla's PE ratio for 2020 is 627; it is forecast to quickly decline to a more reasonable 144 in 2022. https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/stocks/tsla/price-earnings-peg-ratios https://www.nasdaq.com/market-activity/stocks/tsla/price-ear...
- Retric 6y agoStock prices are always based predicted returns over time. Their revenue growth for 2020 was 40%, 2019 14.52%, 2018 82.51%, and 2017 67.98%. So, you really need to predict when that stops before you can get a reasonable estimate for sock value. A more reasonable 144x in 2022 after 2 years of ~40% growth is the equivalent of ~282x today. That’s not exactly the huge drop people are expecting. In other words I do expect a drop, but I don’t expect short selling is a great risk adjusted investment.
- manquer 6y agoThat is also assuming the stock won't grow crazy in the next 2 years as well.
- Retric 6y agoSure, and in theory directly selling to customers and manufacturing a higher percentage of parts should allow them to extract more profit per vehicle than using dealerships. EV’s also allow car companies companies to profit from ‘gasoline’ sales as the lower operating costs are linked to higher purchase prices. However, none of that supports the insane increase in Tesla’s stock price over the last 2 years. That’s likely an artifact of so many short sellers which ironically drive up the price faster if a stock starts to rise, and with a 40% increase in revenue in 2020 some rise would be appropriate. As the saying goes the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.
- nrjames 6y agoI would add that their competitive advantage now is not the cars, but the extensive and convenient charging network.
- fassssst 6y agoOne regulation away from being standardized like it is in Europe. Not to mention the biggest benefit of EV’s is charging at home.
- gwbas1c 6y agoI suspect that the Supercharger network will quickly become commoditized as charging stations appear everywhere. Every grocery store, mall, parking lot, and restaurant will put a few chargers in. This will be mostly to defend their business so that people with electric cars continue to patronize instead of going to a competitor with an electric car. BTW: From what I understand, gas stations don't make much profit from the gas. I suspect the same kind of economics from operating a car charger.
- sseveran 6y agoA quick look at their 10Q does not show that their Energy generation and storage business is extremely profitable. It eeks out a small profit before operating expenses. That may change in the future. It is also a small business relative to their car business. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000156459020047486/tsla-10q_20200930.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000156459020...
- 7e 6y agoTesla doesn’t operate those batteries. They are merely a supplier, or in the Samsung case, a reseller.
- davedx 6y ago"...anyone invested in an S&P index fund is essentially being forced along for the ride". Yes, that is exactly how an ETF is supposed to work. If you don't like it, don't buy ETFs. There's hardly a shortage of investment options out there.
- arijun 6y agoOr buy the index and short that amount of Tesla
- jmpman 6y agoConceptually, I understand that’s the path, however, practically speaking, shorts have expiration dates, which haven’t been kind to Tesla shorts. How do I counter my S&P 500 investments over exposure to Tesla?
- rapsey 6y agoWith the amount of cash they have now, why would anyone short Tesla? How can they fail?
- cwhiz 6y agoElon dying.
- gizmondo 6y agoCompany does not need to fail for short to be profitable.
- rapsey 6y agoTrue but so far shorting Tesla had been a hilariously bad trade.
- jmpman 6y agoThe Model 3 is a nice car, on the order of a Honda Accord nice. But, copy the performance of a Model 3, and wrap it in a BMW 3 series, and I’d take that all day, every day. So, what’s the barrier to other manufacturers making a competitive electric car? The battery packs of others are becoming competitive. The motors are nice, but nothing science fiction there. Yes, the Model 3 software is great, but in the recent updates, mine has become slow, so Tesla isn’t immune to putting out problematic software. I’d prefer more physical buttons over the current Tesla offering. The VW ID.4 looks extremely competitive to the Model Y. I just get an Apple Fanboy vibe out of Tesla owners. Yes, I have an iPhone and a Tesla, but I’d be willing to consider the Android of cars. With Apple rumored to enter the electric car space, there are many reasons to doubt Tesla’s long term dominance to demand such an elevated stock price. Do I really want my stock portfolio over exposed to Tesla? No.
- sfvisser 6y agoI don't have a clue about economic realities (especially not now in late 2020), but current market value is the market's bet on possible future earnings, not current state of affairs. Maybe the market's valuation is a lot of people betting on Tesla being able to scale up dramatically in a pace that current car manufacturers will not be able to catch up with. Not entirely unthinkable.
- davedx 6y agoYep exactly. This is also why the "GDP vs stock market cap" graphs for different countries don't really make that much sense - or at least, they portray different things than they are designed to portray. It is definitely true that the US market cap has become "decoupled" from its current economic output, but as you say, that is a (rationalised) prediction about the state of affairs in the next year or three, it's not "oh no everything is cer-aazy!"
- vesinisa 6y agoThe theory how to scale up car production is well known, and the established players like Toyota are already masters at that (lean and just-in-time manufacturing were after all invented at Toyota). It's Tesla who's having issues with scaling up production[1]. We're in the middle of a turning point in the car industry. I'd wager in 2-3 years sales of electric cars will already be a sizeable chunk of the market. Within about a decade electric personal cars will take over sales of petrol cars. But nothing suggests that VW, Toyota etc. would not be any less apt at producing electric cars than Tesla. On the contrary, the established players have a MASSIVELY superior pre-existing production capacity and expertise. [1]: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-batteryday-productivity/tesla-warns-on-challenges-of-scaling-up-production-idUSKCN26D1BN https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-batteryday-producti...
- teruakohatu 6y ago> and they have MASSIVELY superior pre-existing production capacity and expertise. They need batteries for those cars. Are they also investing in battery production?
- blunte 6y agoThe modern stock markets have been insane since at least the 90s, and I bet there are some underlying banking and finance rules which led to the changes in overall market sanity. If you go back in time, value investors really dig into companies to try to understand their current and probable future values. Also, I believe it was rare or never that companies could pull off an IPO without some history of profitability. At least since the dot-com era, hype-only (no valid financials) IPOs became common. I suspect the whole VC funding ponzi system had something to do with this. Uber was my favorite example... years of never-profit, but rather multiple higher rounds of funding and then IPO. But at least in the case of Tesla, they not only have managed to build actual cars that sell well, but more importantly they are a battery company. This last bit is probably a big part of their future valuation.
- davedx 6y agoSerious question: how do you define "valid financials" and why?
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoThe malinvestment seems to be a byproduct of low interest rates, too many investment dollars facing too few returns, and increasing wealth inequality (further driving too much investment capital).
- ekianjo 6y agoYup. Inflation created by QE ends up in the stock market where pretty much anything goes these days.
- rapsey 6y agoWhich means worrying about fundamentals like cash flow to market cap is meaningless. Those days are over. It is all about supply, demand and liquidity. Stock prices are a popularity contest and banks are full of cash so they are in no danger of crashing like in '08.
- jbob2000 6y ago
- tedk-42 6y agoI'm no Tesla short seller. They make damn nice products, but I feel like you aren't really getting for what you think you're paying for. The FSD option isn't a real thing yet. You've effectively paid for a promise of a feature (if they ever deliver it?). While I do see the value in the data they've collected, I haven't been very impressed with their autonomous driving promises. Before there was FSD, 'autopilot' is what they marketed as their driverless offering.
- Ecko123 6y agoMarket reflects future not present . That is how I take it. Tesla in itself is a fully vertical car Company + Chip Company (think Nvidia) + Battery/Electrical/Electronics Company (Custom Battery Cell) + Materials Company (Custom materials including Aluminium n leather) + IT Company (Self Driving Division) + Automation Company Please add if I missed something Good starting point would be https://www.youtube.com/c/MunroLive/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/MunroLive/videos
- vardump 6y agoFrom the article: "What they’re saying: “Tesla shares are in our view and by virtually every conventional metric not only overvalued, but dramatically so,” wrote Ryan Brinkman, a JPMorgan analyst, in a research note." Checked Ryan Brinkman's rating: https://www.tipranks.com/analysts/ryan-brinkman https://www.tipranks.com/analysts/ryan-brinkman Not very great performance... On the other hand: "Yes, but: Tesla makes cars, but they could also be categorized alongside pure tech or electric vehicle companies. It is early in the "golden age of EV playing out globally," says Dan Ives, an analyst at Wedbush Securities." Dan Ives rating: https://www.tipranks.com/analysts/daniel-ives https://www.tipranks.com/analysts/daniel-ives Everyone can draw their own conclusions, of course.
- runawaybottle 6y agoIf Apple is truly entering the car market, then Tesla’s valuation is validated by an attachment to this confidence on growth from a player like Apple. It will only come back down to reality after Apple hits the market and we see the true competitive numbers across the car makers (or until Toyota goes harder at EV), but until then, it’s a future-minded investment into a sector where we are expecting stronger players. It would be the same as being 10x bullish on cellphones years in advance with the belief that smartphone companies will validate the market beyond our wildest imaginations.
- snicksnak 6y agoI wonder how much of the supposed overvaluation can be attributed to the "traders" on r/wallstreetbets
- jfoster 6y agoThis is boring because it lacks the type of imagination that Elon Musk's companies tend to bring to fruition. I would like to see this type of article rewritten for a scenario where Tesla Network is up & running. Would the stock price still be mania in that scenario?
- ada1981 6y agoSo we short Tesla? Are people taking the other side of this if they are so sure?
- CrazyStat 6y agoThe market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.
- robteix 6y agoApparently many are. Tesla is the most shorted stock in the US, apparently[0] [0] https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/tesla-stock-most-shorted-us-beats-apple-highest-short-interest-2020-1-1028823046 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/tesla-stock-...
- lazyjones 6y agoWas, in January. This is how it went: https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/tesla-short-sellers-lost-39-billion-betting-against-stock-2020-12-1029915087?op=1 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/tesla-short-...
- davedx 6y agoTesla has always had plenty of shorts. If you are less confident about it you can buy a put to limit your downside risk.
- siddarthd2919 6y agoWhy is Tesla being singled out? Compare DOW 30 vs economy or SPY(Pre Tesla) vs economy. Same story
- bob33212 6y agoI'm far more comfortable investing in TSLA than IBM. IBM has had a great run and made major contributions to computing over the past 50 years. But now it is a sham company that tricks executives into buying buzzword bingo services. When enough people get burnt by their lack of results their reputation will take a turn and they will have a downward spiral. Orcl will buy them within the next 10 years.
- sadfev 6y agoYet another hit piece. These stupid media puppets are in the business corrupt practice of writing hit pieces for a cozy profit no matter who funds them. They (Big Fossil) are not evil as long as they pay these “media” houses cozy bribe.
- pmart123 6y agoInterestingly, the first chart left out Ferrari, which has a +$40bn market cap.
- ricc 6y agoThat’s why TSLA’s P/E ratio is sky-high...