3 ms·
I've been trying to stop myself from commenting further but you've forced me to! > They’re not nearly as good as the actors in the film, and they’re used to a
by klelatti 6y ago
I've been trying to stop myself from commenting further but you've forced me to!
> They’re not nearly as good as the actors in the film, and they’re used to a much lesser extent. (Seems a little mean but you did force me to spell it out.)
Factually incorrect on both counts and very unfair to an outstanding cast.
> The positive comments make me feel I do need to give the series another watch someday soon to understand where the fans are coming from. I think I had a much more positive view of Smiley’s People than some, which I’m curious about too...
Maybe a good idea to have a recent watch before criticising. Actually Smiley's people suffers from many of the flaws you've highlighted with a much weaker cast beyond Guinness.
> You’ve got me wishing it was filmic - unless I’m mistaken it’s 576i :(
Yes it was made for TV and made in 1979. As a result it is also utterly authentic.
I have many, many criticisms of the film which I'm not going to express because it may just be my taste and I'm glad that lots of people enjoyed it. I just don't want anyone to be put off seeking out the TV series because of an assessment that is so far out of the consensus.
Edit: for an independent view the LA Times gives a good assessment of both.
https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/la-xpm-2011-nov-27-la-ca-second-look-20111127-story.html https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/la-xpm-2011-nov-27-la-...
- justin66 6y ago>> You’ve got me wishing it was filmic - unless I’m mistaken it’s 576i :( > Yes it was made for TV and made in 1979. As a result it is also utterly authentic. “Authentic.” Okay. The remarkable photography of the film is part of its value. > I just don't want anyone to be put off seeking out the TV series because of an assessment that is so far out of the consensus. It’s free on YouTube. The most people have to lose is their time, and it's Alec Guinness, so of course people should watch it and form their own opinions. > I've been trying to stop myself from commenting further but you've forced me to! It's an interesting topic that doesn't involve the ongoing decline of civilization, or Rust, so I don't think you should be shy about it.
- adamsea 6y agoBtw here's a lovely New Yorker article about the miniseries. https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/we-are-all-smileys-people https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/we-are-all-sm...