4 ms·
Neither Gates, nor Jobs, nor Zuckerberg, nor Bezos, nor Musk inherited their billions. At best they inherited access to the social circles of their parents, and
by nine_k 6y ago
Neither Gates, nor Jobs, nor Zuckerberg, nor Bezos, nor Musk inherited their billions. At best they inherited access to the social circles of their parents, and maybe paid-for education (too lazy to check). Knowing the right people is not something you can, or want, to limit or forbid.
Should anyone suggest to prevent passing as much as, say, $100k to your child (an approximate price of a university tuition), said anyone will see a massive push back from basically all strata of the society.
- rmrfstar 6y agoYeah, but they benefited from a system that coerces people to trade their labor for less than it is worth. Zuckerberg is worth >3x the annual income of all surgeons in the US. It is implausible that his net worth reflects his replacement cost. Even PG has said (to Zuckerberg) that if it wasn't him, it would have been someone else.
- imgabe 6y agoThe amount of value you can obtain by trading something is by definition what it is worth. If nobody is willing to pay you an amount for something, it's not worth that much. > It is implausible that his net worth reflects his replacement cost. Why should it? His net worth reflects the expected value of the portion of Facebook that he owns. Why would it have anything to do with his replacement cost?
- sudosysgen 6y agoHmm, not really. The cost of labour is actually generally agreed to be the replacement cost of the labour. As a society, the only thing that we take out of Zuckerberg is his labour, so he shouldn't get anymore than the replacement cost of his labour. In other words, if someone would have done Zuckerberg's work for less compensation - and the GP asserts it is the case - then we as a society lose by having Zuckerberg do it instead of the lower compensated alternative. In other words, when someone gets paid more than their replacement cost, there is a market inefficiency that causes loss to the vast majority.
- imgabe 6y agoHe doesn't "get" anything. His net worth is due to ownership in the company he made. When people talk about his net worth increasing, that's due to the shares appreciating. He didn't get more of anything. He owns the same number of shares, they just became more valuable. Zuckerberg is not employed by society. We're not all collectively paying him a salary. If you're saying we should completely abolish private property, that's a different thing altogether.
- sudosysgen 6y agoPrivate property exists because it is an organization of things that is useful to society. That's why we heavily limit it using taxation and so forth. We allow people to own capital because it motivates them to do some types of work. If we allow people to concentrate more capital than necessary to motivate them to do that work, we lose.
- imgabe 6y agoThere is no "we" allowing or disallowing anything. Who is this "we" and why do use suppose they have some divine insight into the ideal allocation of capital?
- ardy42 6y ago> There is no "we" allowing or disallowing anything. Who is this "we" and why do use suppose they have some divine insight into the ideal allocation of capital? You only really own something if enough people in society ("we") agree that you do own it. If enough of "us" change our mind (for instance, if your ownership is no longer useful to us), then you don't really own that thing anymore.
- imgabe 6y agoWe, that is you are free to devalue Facebook stock at any time by not buying it. The fact that most people are not doing that should tell you that you are not as much a part of the dominant "we" as you think.
- rmrfstar 6y ago> The amount of value you can obtain by trading something is by definition what it is worth. That is one important definition, but it's just a statement of ideology. Was Instagram only worth $1bn when they sold to Facebook in 2012. Are we supposed to ignore the fact that Instagram's options were sell for $1bn or face "Zuckerberg destroy mode"?
- missedthecue 6y agoI feel like there's a false equivalence being made here. You're comparing wage to net worth. Zuckerberg's net worth is not a function of his replacement cost. It's the percentage of his own company that he owns, valued at market price. This happens to be worth $100B at current market levels, but it is independent of whether he continues to work at Facebook or anywhere else. It's not compensation for labour.
- nsajko 6y agoYour point is truthful but not completely relevant: Bezos, at least, did receive a considerable amount of money as funding for Amazon from his family. My point is that the money received from parents most often is, in fact, an advantage. Now that I wrote it down explicitly, I wonder why is it that I have to argue this, seems quite obvious. (Note: I'm not saying the funding from parents was sufficient, or even necessary in Bezos' case.)
- nine_k 6y agoI see! It's a transfer between generations, though not an inheritance (which some people suggest to tax heavily). Again, Bezos got about $300k from his family (both his parents were doctors), which, I think, is far below the level of "unjust inherited fortune" or what is usually people suggest to tax into oblivion. Yes, when your parents help you, it's helpful — it's nearly tautologically true. This is why I as a parent do help my grown-up son sometimes. Limiting this behavior is not quite realistic, and would be met with a huge backlash (justly, to my mind).
- usrusr 6y agoThe problem is not intergenerational help, that existed at least as much if not more in times of less inequality. The problem is the size of the spoils. Intergenerational help is only brought up as a counter to the tired "it's your fault if you aren't a billionaire" defense (which is rarely brought up by billionaires themselves but all the time by their broke admirers)
- Rebelgecko 6y agoIt's a lot easier to make billions when you already have millions (like Elon Musk's dad, who joked about how he had too much money in his safe to be able shut the door when his gemstone mine was doing well). It's a lot riskier to be an entrepreneur when you're living paycheck to paycheck and don't have a family fortune to fall back on. Extraordinary people also often have extraordinary childhoods. Most teenagers can't borrow their dad's private jet to go sell emeralds to Tiffany&Co, but I imagine that sort of experience comes in handy for a businessman
- nine_k 6y agoThe fact that Musk's dad had millions does not imply that Musk himself had access to them; according to Wikipedia, their relations were not very good. But yes, being around people who have businesses and millions does give you certain experience and perspective. Despite that, Musk was heavily bullied at school; apparently dad's money could not buy him a private school, or maybe just a better school. Indeed some childhoods of billionaires are special, like that of Steve Jobs, a highly problematic adopted child who suffered at school so much his working-class family decided to move to get him to another school district. OTOH, neither Mark Zuckerberg, nor Jeff Bezos appear to have had extraordinary childhoods, or family wealth above a normal middle-class level. Many of them, though, were exposed to electronics and computers early, and their parents were wise enough to encourage it, or at least to allow. [Edited: typos.]
- Armisael16 6y agoMusk’s family probably didn’t own an emerald mine. There’s only one source - Errol Musk - and everyone else who’s willing to talk about it denies it (including Elon) https://www.insidehook.com/article/history/errol-musk-elon-father-myths https://www.insidehook.com/article/history/errol-musk-elon-f... The same is true about that drivel about Tiffany.
- jedberg 6y agoGates, Zuckerberg, Bezos, and Musk were all in the top 1% before they started their companies. Jobs's family was middle class, but well off enough to own a house with an empty garage and enough money to get him started. They also fed, housed, and clothed him while he started his company.
- missedthecue 6y agoPoint is, hundreds of millions of people have access to a garage, food, and clothing, yet cannot mirror the success that these men have achieved.
- jedberg 6y agoThat's not the point at all. The point is that starting a company was not a risk for these men, because they would be just fine if they failed. And I think you're way off with that hundreds of millions number. I doubt there are that many people that can fully support their adult children, including footing the bill for all startup costs.
- ardy42 6y ago>>> I always like to say that we live in an exponential meritocracy, where your accumulated merit enhances your ability to accumulate more merit, eventually resulting in a small minority rapidly pulling ahead of the pack. Goes with the old adage: turning $100 into $120 is work; turning $100 million into $120 million is inevitable. Perhaps we need a linear meritocratic function. >> So basically, some way to prevent wealth from being passed across generations? > Neither Gates, nor Jobs, nor Zuckerberg, nor Bezos, nor Musk inherited their billions. At best they inherited access to the social circles of their parents, and maybe paid-for education (too lazy to check). Knowing the right people is not something you can, or want, to limit or forbid. But, there are others who did. For instance, just off the top of my head: the Koch brothers, who combined inherited wealth with extensive political activism. Also, the fortunes of most "self-made" meritocrats can be traced to building exponentially on some elite inherited opportunity, then that kneecaps a lot of the moral reasoning used to justify that those people deserve full control of those fortunes (and thus shouldn't be subjected to heavy taxes).