7 ms·
People don't realize that a day 1 "pop" in share price of an IPO (sometimes 100% or more, like some of the recent ones) benefits only wall street, not the compa
by paxys 6y ago
People don't realize that a day 1 "pop" in share price of an IPO (sometimes 100% or more, like some of the recent ones) benefits only wall street, not the company itself. Big banks are, therefore, incentivized to underprice IPOs as much as they can get away with. And employees themselves are subject to long lockup periods. With the recent success of direct listings, cutting them out of the process is a logical step.
- jariel 6y ago"Big banks are, therefore, incentivized to underprice IPOs as much as they can get away with." No, the banks get underwriting fees as a % of the offer, so they are incented for a higher price as well. The 'winners' are the folks who get to buy from the underwriting bank and that's opaque: it could be 'the same banks clients', and so they get some major favour points for those allocations, and their own private wealth managers would ostensibly get a cut, but that's quasi insider stuff. The banks 'working with the IPO company' lose money with a price that's too low. Even if you were to say 'oh, the other parts of the banks are working for some action' the answer to that is, well, bankers are 'very me first' and I don't care who it is, the underwriting team wants to make as much money as they can, it's their personal bonus, and they're going to maximize the price. They don't care about the 'private wealth management teams' bonuses, they care about their own. AirBnB I guarantee literally had some of the world's best bankers on the case. There's just a lot of variation in very frothy markets and it's hard to estimate demand from far flung corners.
- kumarvvr 6y ago> No, the banks get underwriting fees as a % of the offer, so they are incented for a higher price as well. What is the counter balance to this? Obviously banks can value a share at abnormally high prices and take a big fee, but clearly that is not happening.
- nemanja 6y agoCounter balance is the free market - if you set the price too high, investors will not buy into it and the price will be adjusted down.
- jariel 6y agoThe counterbalance is that they are underwriting the stock, meaning, they are actually buying the stock from the company, and then selling it into the market. The umderwriters are the one's actually putting money up 'ahead of time' at the 'specific price' for the company, which involves some risk obviously. So if the underwriters price too high, they are stuck with shares. The people to first buy shares from the underwriteres are likely other institutional investors, and then large private wealth clients etc.. Understand that this is likely one source of the 'jump' - large institutional investors are not generally buying to flip the stock on the same day, in fact, the underwriters (and even AirBnB) don't want that. They don't want volatility. Ideally, AirBnB sells to the bank/underwriters, the big funds buy from the underwriting bank and then hold. All of this will have been established/prepared for during the roadshow. AirBnB is huge, Fidelity wants a cut, so they'll take an allocation X shares for $Y on 'the day'. Nice, clean, straightforward, not a lot of volatility. Going an 'IPO' is like 'being born' - it's a sensitive time and a lot of money is changing hands you want it to go 'as planned' and 'smoothly'. So there's likely a smaller number of shares really floating out there on day 1, which may enhance the pressure from the demand curve.
- reissbaker 6y agoIPOs for banks are repeat businesses: they'll be selling many different companies to the same institutional investors over the years. If you don't get your investors a pop, they'll be less likely to buy the next time around. The incentives are a little more complicated than just the underwriting fees — and the underwriting banks often both get a % fee and a flat fee, the latter of which is less useful for aligning incentives on pricing with the company going public (but useful for aligning incentives with the investors). That being said, seemingly-paradoxically, despite big pops being bad for the companies, they're actually typically good for employees. RSUs will typically turn into shares at IPO time and the entire bundle of shares will be taxed as income according to the listing price; a giant pop means you get higher dollar value shares while paying less tax, assuming you then hold onto them for a year and pay long-term capital gains tax on the difference between listing and pop price rather than selling immediately and paying short-term tax. Waiting a year to sell isn't that unlikely, since employees often aren't even allowed to sell at all for the first six months.
- pgwhalen 6y agoI don’t want to defend the traditional IPO process too much, but “only” is a strong word. One possible benefit from a “pop” is that it makes it more likely for investors to want to participate in future IPOs. That is, the pop from an earlier IPO makes it easier for a later IPO to occur. Of course this isn’t benefitting the first company, but it is benefitting companies at large. I’m just trying to offer some explanation, I still believe the process deserves modernization.
- sombremesa 6y agoStrangely reminiscent of Aposematism. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aposematism#Behaviour https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aposematism#Behaviour
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mayneack 6y agoHow does the listing status affect employees with lockups? If you can't sell for a month (or whatever), wouldn't you benefit from any increase in price immediately after listing? If the price when the lockup period ends is the same, why would an employee care? (I don't know how it works, I'm actually asking)
- nickff 6y agoThe volatility may not directly impact employees with lockups, though there are two potential outcomes. First, the volatility could cause issues even after the 'cooling off' that would take place over that month. Second, the 'lost capital', which was captured by the investment bank is lost to the company, so the company is in a weaker state, both because having a weaker balance sheet is bad, and because it could have used the money.
- paxys 6y agoThe lockup period for an IPO is usually 6 months. That means that institutional investors have the opportunity to realize their gains any time post IPO, while employees have to count on the price to hold for that long before that can get any liquidity. Two or more earnings calls in the period add to the risk. In a direct listing employees can sell on day 1, since there are no obligations to underwriters.
- tempsy 6y agolockups aren’t specific to IPOs. Palantir shareholders are also subject to a lockup. They were only able to sell some fraction of their shares on Day 1.
- gnicholas 6y ago> banks are, therefore, incentivized to underprice IPOs as much as they can get away with. But don't banks compete for the IPO business by telling the company what a high price they will list it for? That doesn't solve the problem of a bank saying they'll list for a high price, winning the bid, and then coming back later and saying that intervening events cause them to think it should be listed lower. But presumably companies that are about to IPO have advisors/lawyers who can see these sorts of shenanigans coming and fight against them?
- lmm 6y agoThe company's attention may well be on its actual business, and the bankers will put a lot of time and effort into positioning themselves as someone the company thinks of as a partner (not always in a "fake" way - often the bank will genuinely do a lot of free work for the company in other areas as a kind of gift economy action).
- hinkley 6y agoI think the perverse incentive may be in the other column of signatures. It's not always the case that all of the shares are sold in the IPO. Some are allocated to board members and investors. Those people will negotiate a share count based on the IPO price. I may feel entitled to 5% of the company, they may offer 3%, but might only be able to negotiate 4%. But if the shares will double in value after the pop? I'm perfectly fine with that. I know that. I expect that. There's an incentive for me to fight for shares as if there is no pop, but then agree to the IPO term sheet knowing that there will be.
- TearsInTheRain 6y agoI think it is more a supply and demand issue. There are less people that can buy shares pre-IPO. If the IPO was accessible to everyone the price would be the market price.
- georgeek 6y agoBanks do compete but it's not really an iterated game - a company only goes public once.
- nemanja 6y agoThis is pretty non-sensical. Banks are incentivized to price IPOs at the highest possible price, their comps are directly linked to the proceeds. If IPO pop was something nefarious, how do you explain IPO pop of Goldman Sachs stock? They ran their own IPO and you can be sure as hell that partners didn't want to leave any money on the table. In general, IPO pop is an interesting phenomenon and it's not fully explained in the literature.
- thrill 6y agoIt's easily explained by accepting that the IPO price is a guess in the first place, and that the negative publicly of guessing wrong and having a significant IPO decrease is more professionally embarrassing than having an increase.
- TearsInTheRain 6y agoDont the bankers go through a discovery process where they find buyers pre-IPO? Its not like a blind guess
- rocho 6y agoThose buyers are institutional investors and they get a huge discount.
- anonu 6y agoThe answer, like most things in life, lies in between. Yes, in an ideal world you "price it right" and on IPO day the stock doesnt move up or down from the opening price. Optically, it looks a lot better to price low and have the stock rise. Additionally, there is something called an over-allotment option (aka greenshoe) that allows banks to sell more shares than initially allotted, to help stabilize the IPO price. This is usually more $ for the banks.
- cowsandmilk 6y ago> They ran their own IPO and you can be sure as hell that partners didn't want to leave any money on the table. The optimal return for partners probably is giving the institutional investors a pop on even your own IPO so you keep them as investors for future IPOs where you are collecting fees. When the institutional investors lose money on an IPO, are they going to come back to you for the next one?
- hinkley 6y agoIt's a racket, for certain. The story as it goes is that they need big investors to soak up a lot of the IPO so that they all sell. The brokerages cultivate a set of people who can pony up that money, and part of that cultivation is a history of good (profitable) interactions. Thinking Fast and Slow asserts that humans use a different weighting system for upside and downside (making $10 does not feel as good as losing $10 feels bad), but it also asserts that people who look at finances and statistics for a living have a bunch less pronounced bias in this respect. In the same way that it's worth some guy's time to climb into my tree for $250 bucks, and worth $250 to me to not have to make that climb, the investment houses should be profiting off of the difference between my speculative sense of risk in the situation versus their objective sense of risk based on expertise. But that doesn't seem to be what happens with IPOs. It feels more like an Old Boys' Club, full of people who are as averse to loss as I am, maybe even moreso, demanding an experience that ranges from good to fantastical, instead of fair to excellent. The good news is, that gap means there's space for competition. The bad news is that many of the people who might participate seem to be more motivated to stretch enough to get an invite to The Club instead. Someone is going to have to defect. A lot of someones...
- jklein11 6y agoYou hear a lot about the day 1 pop in share price but I really think the price is just the tip of the iceberg. I'm not sure what the trading volume is but I doubt that you could fill the entire IPO at the highest price on the IPO date. From what I understand, supply is constrained as employees typically can't sell shares, and retail investors who were lucky enough to get in on the action are typically locked up for 60 days. Institutional investors are happy to hold on to alot of their shares because they can mark them to market and make their returns look great. Edit: clarified first paragraph
- maxerickson 6y agoI tripped over your first paragraph a bit, but I got it, you mean the market open price ("IPO price" has a specific meaning, the price that the people participating in the offering get, that is usually set by the bank).
- jklein11 6y agoGood point. I just edited the comment. Hope it is more clear. The point I'm trying to make is if you are trying to sell $100 million worth of share it is going to be at a lower price then selling $10,000 worth of shares. It seems like critics of IPOs just take the number of shares issued and multiply it by the highest price on the IPO date and say "Look at all the money those bankers left on the table!"
- kenneth 6y agoYes and no. A pop means that shares sold were at a discount to their true value. At the same time, it's usually benefital to a company to have a high stock price for various reasons, and that benefit likely outweighs the downside of having raised capital expensively at the IPO (including having the ability to raise more capital much more cheaply in the future).
- habosa 6y agoUnfortunately because the media gives such fawning press coverage to IPOs that "pop" the companies also want it to happen. No executive wants to have the IPO that dips on Day 1. Now if they were thinking rationally they'd realize the extra funds raised from a high IPO price are worth much more than the positive media coverage from a pop, but we all know that people response irrationally to media coverage.