4 ms·
>If every Apple stock holder would try to sell it today, the market cap would plummet. This is often repeated but not necessarily true. I don't own a particula
by whatshisface 6y ago
>If every Apple stock holder would try to sell it today, the market cap would plummet.
This is often repeated but not necessarily true. I don't own a particularly large amount of Apple stock, but if the price dropped even a little bit, and if I knew the drop was due to nothing more than this weird thing where everyone was selling for some reason, I might decide to own more. If aliens sent out a mind control signal that caused every Apple shareholder to start selling, the buyers (whoever they were, maybe the aliens? ;) ) would compete with each other to buy.
To give you a concrete example, let's say I am the only owner in the world of a flying car. One day, I decide to sell it. 100% of the owners of flying cars have decided to sell, but the price would clearly not drop to zero! The idea that everyone selling implies the price will drop to zero applies to pure Keynesian beauty contests where 100% of the value is in owning something perceived to be valuable. For currencies that is completely true, but for companies that is less true.
- boh 6y ago> This is often repeated but not necessarily true. This is always true. It doesn't have to go to zero to qualify as plummeting.
- whatshisface 6y agoI would suggest that my flying car example is one where it's not true. Another example would be intermediate industrial products: everyone who has intermediate chemicals is trying to sell them! Everyone who buys them uses them up as fast as they can, which means that at any given moment, virtually every owner of the intermediate industrial chemical is trying to sell it.
- boh 6y agoThe price of stocks decrease if everyone sells them. Your examples are incompatible.
- abduhl 6y agoWell if everyone is selling then nobody is buying and the quoted stock price remains unchanged. See how ridiculous it is to nitpick purely hypothetical situations?
- boh 6y agoIt's not hypothetical because it happens. Stocks don't operate in low-entropy hypothetical planes of existence, they trade on markets. If your ask has no bids you lower your ask. Sellers will keep lowering it and if there's no bids it will get very near zero in which case the exchange will likely de-list the stock. A hypothetical where you sell one flying car doesn't illustrate a comparable dynamic.
- VRay 6y agoThat argument could be applied to anything What you're really looking for is the fact that Apple shares have an intrinsic value related to the company's assets and future cash flows. Bitcoin, on the other hand, has an intrinsic value of zero, so it could theoretically plummet all the way to zero. Same goes for some companies' stocks
- whatshisface 6y ago>That argument could be applied to anything Yeah, it could be applied to anything. Its conclusion is true for everything. Prices will not actually go to zero when everyone sells, unless there is no intrinsic value.