3 ms·
It’s amazing that corporate America thinks it can’t hire a at all levels from the custodian to the CEO, but almost every school system and government can figure
by scarface74 6y ago
It’s amazing that corporate America thinks it can’t hire a at all levels from the custodian to the CEO, but almost every school system and government can figure it out.
- laverya 6y agoGovernments (in the west) don't hire their leaders, though. Same is true of schools - principals and the like might be hired, but the school boards that chose them are elected.
- dexterdog 6y agoAnd those boards usually select the superintendent and that superintendent certainly didn't start in the system as a janitor, nor did any of the principals under him.
- umanwizard 6y agoBy the West, do you just mean the US? Where else are small potatoes administrative positions like school board, etc. actually elected?
- rualca 6y ago> It’s amazing that corporate America thinks it can’t hire a at all levels (...) I don't believe that's the case at all. It's not like they believe they can't hire someone. That's a silly assumption. There is however the idea that there are operational advantages in outsourcing non-core areas of their business. If they hire a specialized contractor to do maintenance tasks then you no longer have to bother with gaining expertise in that area, and you can even scale up and down your service to meet demands. The rationale is like figuring out how we have lunch. Sure, we can cook it ourselves and it will certainly be cheaper. However, if we pay a third party to provide us with our lunch then we get food cooked by pros and we even have the freedom to pick fancy dishes from some other restaurant if we deem it necessary.
- burntoutfire 6y ago> There is however that there are operational advantages in outsourcing non-core areas of their business. If they hire a specialized contractor to do maintenance tasks then you no longer have to bother with gaining expertise in that area, and you can even scale up and down your service to meet demands. From what I've seen in practice, it's always about the outside "specialized contractor" breaking various labor laws and generally screwing workers over in order to drive costs down. This way, even with the contractor markup, the company saves money and, at the same time, is not liable and does not take a reputation hit. It's a win-win for everybody but the workers. I guess they don't put that in the MBA textbooks though.
- kube-system 6y agoThis is a correlation that you've observed that is actually caused by a third variable: these are often low-wage and low-leverage positions. Easily replaceable, low wage employees are common victims of labor law violations regardless of whether they're contractors or not. Employees that are in no position to fight back often get screwed.
- Closi 6y agoThe key operational advantage is that you avoid providing any worker protections and can better achieve a race to the bottom via competitive tendering to low-margin outsourcing providers hiring minimum wage employees on temporary contracts.
- kube-system 6y agoOr alternatively, they've "figured out" how not to hire people unrelated to their core business? What does Frito-Lay have to be gained from engaging in the janitorial business?
- Guest42 6y agoNot paying the person in between? I worked at PepsiCo for a little and most of their job responsibilities weren’t unique to the product offering or business model.
- kube-system 6y agoA job that supports the core business is definitely not the same thing as a job unique to the product offering or business model. e.g. food safety is something that is important to PepsiCo's business, yet they are far from the only business that needs food safety expertise. In contrast, they may also need potholes filled in the parking lot, but they may choose to hire outside help for this, because they do not do it enough to be good or efficient at it. Paying a middleman is often cheaper than hiring labor directly. Labor is the largest single cost for most businesses.
- Guest42 6y agoI think the distinctions between supports and essential to value get pretty subjective. Since 2008 the number of contracting roles has increased quite a bit and there are disputes as to whether Uber drivers (or engineers) are employees. I’d claim there is an unnecessary and unhelpful bias towards outsourcing (not saying that it’s always wrong, just more prevalent than ideal...).
- kube-system 6y agoWell, Uber drivers definitely directly support Uber's primary business. So I'd say that's a different situation altogether. (and they're not really outsourced, Uber directly "contracts" each one of them) Many businesses fail when trying to outsource staff that directly support their primary product or service. A more direct comparison to the issue of Frito-Lay's janitorial staff is something like: should Yellow Cab should hire their own car wash staff or make a deal with a local car wash?
- caturopath 6y agoI'm not sure I follow. The reason that large companies subcontract out these roles is that they're incentivized to do so, not that they "can't figure it out". I'm not sure I've really heard people pretending otherwise.